bing181

Misson's fault (obvs).

I'm surprised we don't just forfeit.

Not if they don't have the skills to execute, or the time playing together for it to click.

Yes, his two possessions in a half of footy in the twos are going to make a real difference in the AFL.

Given the players who are out/injured, hardly surprising.

Get him in.

Clearly.

Spargo had 10 possessions last week. (To go with his 3 marks, 4 tackles and goal.) To put that in context, Lockhart had 8, Hunt 7 and Garlett 6, all of whom had fewer tackles than Spargo, and except for Lockhart, fewer marks. You see what you want to see.

Dunning-Kruger

The main consequence for me is simply an absence of playing time *together*, compounded by a lack of consistency in who's actually playing. People asking how Spargo keeps his place ... maybe that's one of the reasons, that more than anything we need on-field stability.

re Stretch: maybe, but he wasn't the worse last week, and hopefully if he gets a run at a few games his confidence and his decision-making will improve. Also, it's not as if he's keeping anyone out, KK would be his only/main rival for the role he plays (?) Happy to see them stick with him, at least for a few more games.

I suspect that it's any combination of these: - that even though we're not seeing much result, he works hard - that he does exactly what he's been asked to do in terms of structure, position etc. - that the club see a long-term future for him, so they're putting games into him at a level that's above VFL

Oops. That's a thought that you would have been better keeping to yourself.

That would be Josh Wagner. C Wagner had 8 possessions.

Thus giving us a clear run at a strong pre-season come November to set us up for a serious tilt at 2020.

With the same medical/physio team in place.

Because there's nothing to drill into. "Injuries take the time they take to heal" isn't exactly major clickbait.

Estimation (noun): an approximate calculation or judgement of the value, number, quantity, or extent of something.

Er ... Most of that list is "Test", so presumably playing. It also includes Lewis, even though he played last week. Apart from the two young long-termers, list is Jetta, Melksham, Smith and VDB. Plus Maynard who has a week or so with concussion.

Yes lord forbid we get injuries in a contact sport. We'd be better off just not playing anyone.

As above, reported as OP. Thus the length of the time out, though as reported, seems to have turned the corner on the way back to playing/fitness.

Ridiculous. Lewis has been a phenomenal get, and was a key driver in our success in the finals last year - and in helping install the hardness we needed to get there.

... the fact that he's been injured and/or carrying an injury and/or coming back from an injury.

If you follow best practise it's not a mistake - regardless of outcomes.

Who said they weren't smart? They followed a cause of treatment/recovery that has worked in plenty of cases. But not all. Didn't work for Jo. Nothing to do with mismanagement, everything to do with the uniqueness of each person's physical makeup.