jayceebee31

Good to see that Judd and the leadership took some of the blame in the BoozeBoat incident

A further question to ask is he(JUDD) worth 2+ million a year seeing his club is over 6 million in debt.

Thanks for the explanation- Neita was a better leader than Judd

We are getting off the track a little but Kristy is a labor politician in Victoria, since 2002. Do not know how this interweaves with Judd etc..

I think you are being harsh- however he will never be a Sinartra or a Connick jnr.

I concur-this kid is a gun- when he gains confidence & stamina watch him go- to me he was the pick of 2008.

Four letters - JUDD Very good points raised Demoniac- supports my points totally.

Hi Jack, hope you are over the flu. With regards to your viewpoint ,what I am querying is the merit as captain and what the purposes are. In the thread outline, it mentions factors regarding Judd and the points raised re McDonald and the merit of MFC reappointing him captain . Furthermore, in my post regarding Judd stepping down, I think his overall behaviour as leader is appalling. And as you may remember people were after Neitz's head re his fight with a taxi driver at the Crown which he was fined 5 grand,when he was captain.. His behaviou is peanuts compared to the behaviour of Carlton players which are lead by Judd. And by the way, our leadership group lead by Junior runs rings around the leadership group at Carlton NOW. It was great that you concur when you stated they have a poor culture and little way of leadership. I say they have NONE.Judd lets the players run wild,and this will show on field as well..

If Carlton gets charged with bringing the game into disripute should Judd step dowm?

Agreed - or go close to it

Dappa, please note I was not getting into him for anything.However as his football life is ending and re his success in that singing show on 7 early in 2009,I thought he may try to set up another worklife utilizing his voice and charm.

Agree with your points- thus too selfish to be a captain,as it is team sport.

Hope you have a great birthday with your wish to play senior football in 2010

Maybe Kernahan is not the right one to be President,however the thread is about Judd and his leadership-I say he is not the one that should be captain.

Our youngest player on the MFC list Max Gawn's birthday is today- Happy birthday from Demonland

Shown on Win television Xmas Eve that both were coming

I also do not know much about young Stretch.Some of you S.A Demonlanders please fill us in.However, to have a Stretch & Viney would be great.

Please note I am not saying it is his fault- however as a leader he knows (especially after the West Coast fury and the the Fevola booze up) that the guys were out of control.He would have known that a rookie was in a drink off with a senior player and as a leader could have said enough is enough.A leader is one the players look up to- similar to our players looking up to Junior and before him Neita.

At West Coast- he did not want to lead the West Coast Eagles after the Cousins affair. Now at Carlton,he definately is not showing the leadership qualities of a reasonably young Carlton group. After his stupid excuse saying he was trying to use a pressure point- and got rubbed out- did not show on field leadership and in particular captaincy.Also, him unable to to stop the Fevola antics and now- the booze boat trip asks questions about his leadership.He seems he wants to be one of the boys. Maybe he wants to feel accepted. He may have a personality complex. Also shows why our MFC football department felt it crucial to have McDonald (Junior) reappointed captain. Leadership is critical in the development of a young team, your thoughts ?.

Good point Bingo- a tall experienced forward,hopefully we do so next draft

I thought Woe was coaching East Fremantle and still is.. I've been told Adam Yze will play with him

Yep- Higher Set released August- was as flat as his current ego- refer-http://www.russellrobertson.com.au/ I think you can now buy it at the Reject shop(only razzin)

Gee your greedier than I

Are you talking Stef Martin- whom I feel has the potential to be a very good footballer whom I also believe got 99.1 or thereabouts.-

To all Demonlanders, a safe,happy and prosperous New Year. All I want for Xmas- is Big Jim getting an excellent result, thus get well, keep well in2010. And the Dees winning at least 7/8 games-(really think they can win 8 to 11 & be outside chance for the eight.) Most improved- McNamara . Star- Colin Sylvia A great time to all