John Dee

6. Viney 5. McKenzie 4. Kent 3. Sylvia 2. Garland 1. McDonald

1 N.Jones - plenty of touches but just wish he'd stop running around the back for easy handball. He gets the ball first; do you want him to stop that too?

www.melbournematters.com.au I have had a look at it; ambivalent.

Back on the topic : Do we deserve draft assistance? No, no team does, however the AFL has given draft assistance to many teams in the past. History will show that the automatic priority pick for lowly performance was the stupidest thing the AFL ever did. The pick being given at the whim of the commision should have always been the way to go. Do I want our team do get draft assistance? You betcha, and the fact that it would upset the other 17 teams is one of the main reasons I want it!

Frawley out is a big out. Every time I have been down to see Casey, I have been impressed with Davis' defensive capabilities. His disposal is questionable at best but defensively he is very good. I just wish we would play him at the top level once or twice; you never know. I am so over Pederson, Sellar, Gillies et al ...

6. Dunn - I can't believe it!! 5. Frawley 4. Gawn 3. N Jones 2. Sylvia 1. McDonald

On the Couch is just about my favourite footy show; really looking forward to this one!

N. Jones Grimes Frawley Garland Watts

I know we need midfielders. Tall forwards are in demand because they win games for you. With Clark's recent history, I wouldn't be counting on him. Watts will not be a key forward. Having Hogan and Dawes as key forwards with Fitzpatrick and Clark who can double as credible ruck options is a future I do not want to give up.

I can't believe that there are people on here that want to trade Fitzy after we have put in the hard yards and he is just starting to show us how good he could be. FFS, what gets into some people. My daughter, a hard marker, finally relented last weekend and told me that she wanted to take back all of the derogatory things she had said about Fitzy in the past. She is now on his bandwagon!

Bartoli might not be the flashiest tennis player but she has got guts and competitiveness in spades. If the Melbourne players had that, we would win every week.

Sylvia is a free agent. Whilst technically he can be traded, it is a very remote possibility. He would become a veteran, which is another wrinkle. I hope we just make him a reasonable offer and wish him well, should he not accept it; no baragining.

6. Fitzpatrick 5. Garland 4. Terlich 3. Watts 2. M Jones 1. Dawes

I have seen but a few highlights of the U-18 carnival and I hope we pick this guy up.

He did not tee up Brock. There was another player, I can't remember who, that was going to be on that night. That player could not come and Brock was organised as the replacement.

There is a reason why 200cm players go late in the draft. They take a long time to come on, if at all. Fitzy is progressing nicely and, given an injiry free run, should play for the rest of the year. He will, IMHO, not get to his best for another 18-24 months.

I definately got this one wrong, I could not understand why we paid what were, I thought, massive overs for him. Now I can't understand how the Filth were happy to ditch him for the Q Stick; the Q certainly doesn't stand for quality! Dawes is, by all accounts, a very smart cookie. Hearing him speak and hearing about how he is percieved by the players and the club, leads me to think we have had a massive win here.

I am unsure about Magner's availability; he was upgraded for Grimes, who was put on the long term injury list. If Grimes is to even play VFL, Magner must go back to being a rookie. How this sits with the availability of rookies after round 11, with Clisby as our nominated rookie ... As I said, I am unsure. Having said that, I would have Magner in in a heartbeat. Our midfield got pushed around all night, not just in the last twenty minutes.

6. Watts 5. Terlich 4. Dawes 3. Roman 2. Crawley 1. Nicholson

6. Garland 5. McDonald 4. N Jones 3. Spencer 2. Watts 1. Terlich

I can't believe that they have dropped Maister; he always kills us.

I'd love to get a priority pick even though I think history will show that priority picks were the greatest mistake of all time. The fact that all of the other clubs are bleating about it makes me believe that they know it is going to happen.

Whilst I agree that Knights had issues, I think that the first coach after Sheedy was a dead man walking.

I can't believe the trashing that we are getting over this. Martin and Hogan have the same manager, Martin has been given a five year contract, their manager has obviously pointed this out to us and said "How about it?". This is not us deparately trying to stitch him up, it's more of their manager trying to stitch us up. Having said that, I would still give him the five years.

This is a major point of disagreement between my daughter and I. I think the clock is ticking on Jamar and the time of his demise is nigh, she defends him.