beelzebub

Don't know why.... just visualised Oddball uttering those words 🤣

I saw no malice in your post. Seemed to just be stating a collection of facts and observations. Despite what some might suggest I've no real thoughts or cares about Goodwin other than how he prevails ( sts ) at Melbourne. As any would I'd but him a beer , thank him as part of an ensemble that secured that ellusive win. Seasons come and seasons go. Today's hero often becomes yesterday's man. And so it has. Logic suggests when a 'part' becomes ineffective its refurbished or replaced. Time for a new part. I think you might agree. Deep down we all just want what's best for the Dees. In wanting that we'd like to enjoy the footy and our engagement with it. And that's not where I think we currently sit. Cheers

This all sounds very wonderful. Somehow images of Frasier and Niles leaping into action sprung to mind. A handful of annoyed intelligencia writing strongly worded reprimands advocating reciprocal wet lettuce slapping whilst pouring a red and cutting cheese. Don't get me wrong , telling the club what's wrong is action. But as it has been for a long time its largely ignored. You'd think someone would be instigating change at the club just on noticing a non arguable trend, or watching $$$ .. i mean members leave in droves. And yet here we are.... again. I think @Chook has his head on ok. Seems to understand the relationship correctly as an adult and makes suitable life choices according to expectations, results and the value of his breathing hours. Many do. I also understand the rusted-on types. The suggestion the club only listens to coterie groups .... give that man a cigar. This mob guards its activities, influences and power very carefully and craftfully. By all means form your action group. I wish you well. Suggest you adopt a Quixote like logo as your masthead. Those who know know, this club hasn't had competent leadership since Jackson. I admire the sentiments of the o.p. You're wasting your time. Like others I've barracked through thick and thin since 65. Sunday's debacle followed by something that read like ai slop doesn't say, 'we're a club that knows what it's doing' to me. Simply put conversing with an admin that seems otherwise focused doesn't strike me as garnering wished for outcomes. Im intrigued to how the present will play out. The silence is interesting. Good luck all. Happy trails and snappy emails !!

Cassie, rightly or wrongly he/she felt passionate about it enough to squarely bat your bowling. Thats all. The post didn't come out with ink pink you stink. Etc It laid out a reasoned and contextual rebuttal. We've all got something to say. Apparently not everyone agrees with me. Shocking isn't it. I welcome yours and most everyone's posts. I welcome aboard the pain train possiblework1999.

Sad thing is she probably could. Fair head for footy.. just sayin' ( better than some )

I was heartened to see Smith joined in, if only zoom ( or such ) . But he could have not. I think in the old vernacular... the 💩 has found its way to the fan. We're at a point the club needs more than a 🩹 approach.

It's interesting revisiting this conundrum. Some days i think both can still contribute . Other days I just wonder. You watch the 21 big dance and then watch any game since especially this season . Neither are the player they were. Trac has ebbed and flowed somewhat since but to be brutally honest his performance since coming back from that dastardly injury hasn't been the same. Clarry.... well.... just not as dynamically hurtful to the opposition as once. Not blaming either. They're older . Really starting to think it might be time for many to move on . Dees aren't playing deep into September for some years on current trend. Dees need a big refresh. Im not losing sleep if either or both are elsewhere in 26. Wish them both well , here ......or there.

Sponsors especially

The poor optics are nothing that's appeared overnight. They've been there for all to see for some time. Granted it might vary according to colour of lenses 😉

Is that an omen ??

Oh... mate.. Jumbo... there's definitely something afoot, if not amok among the Elms 😉 To say nothing of the resounding silence

You'll get used to it ....

🤔 It bloody would be too.... in spades !!! 🤣🤣🤣

Sorry Jumbo but I can't in any scenario posit Goodwin in a manner whereby he's immaterial to the methods, performances and outcomes of the players. It may not be an intended effect but they play one way or another as a result of he being the coach.

It's comforting. Gives you that warmth and fuzziness knowing that no matter how bad we can be.... we can actually up the ante and do something even more stupid. Other club's supporters must be livid, be so jealous of our abilities. I chortle smuggle knowing we're just THAT good !! 😉

Yes they would... but... but ... could they be sounded out, talked with even now. It's a very exceptional thing... sacking a coach... buy it alone I would think might warrant a meeting of minds ... off campus as it were ... to break bread and pow wow ?? If I were Green i would seek their counsel and imput/views. But it might be just 'easier' to do nothing ( nothing maverick that is ) and just let the problems flow downstream. All care, no responsibility etc.

I think it's reasonable to suggest there will be some changes , off and on the field. Player wise there are always the "shock" trades no one saw coming. Why would we be surprised ( really) if 'playerX' .. well loved at the club decides to up-stumps and seek other fields !! If some come in ...well some have to go out. We have sfa currency in terms of picks . There is a legitimate question of do we need a super-hand of picks in order to add to our talent. F/S opportunities might come at a relative discount if we can only use an amalgamation of picks we have 🤔🤷‍♂️ Trade seems to be the preferred route to get a type of player rtg that you need. This was always Roos' philosophy and I agree with him. Well trade by very definition means X for Y. Classic Omelette and Eggs situation. Something will have to give ( literally) .. in order to get. I for one will be fascinated to see how we manage the off season... both on and off field. That said I'm not really expecting much for 26. 27, maybe.

Well.... here in lies a very real concern for me. If something was to happen ? When ? I then fall back to who would/could instigate such change. I'm of a mind that Green wouldn't off his own bat. Also Guerra wouldn't, Smith might but I doubt it.. but could ALL liaising/ discussing among themselves find a position from which to weird axes etc. And if so...again when. Logic, a precious and rare commodity at Melbourne, would dictate as early an agreement as possible to allow not just the handover of roles/duties but the ability to even find that suitable replacement(s) . You would definitely want the 'new hands' at the wheel going into trade. I just fear we'd stuff that up too. A lot of people , not just at our club, are going to have at least one eye peeled towards the club and what if anything it decides to do. I'd be very , very surprised if Simon is shown the door at end of season ( or before ) . It would be very Melbourne- like to suggest any extension might be subject to team performance in 26. That may or may not help/hinder some as to their decisions. ( both at Melb and possible trades coming in ) I think the club is majority hamstrung currently and this doesn't help anything that we need to do. All of our own doing...again, as is our way.

I tend to agree. Much will happen whether intended or not.

Tbh... might that just be the rabid 5th estate ??

I wonder if the phones will continue to get a workout among the Board Members 🤔 Tbh.. I'm not expecting an iota of change. Lots of words... but no action.

Can you please point me to the "wayback machine"

Wonder whats tge bet his manager has suggested he wait and watch. Would be my advice. Nothing to lose, everything to gain in his position. In reality he owes nothing to the MFC.

Yes, the most likely scenario. The preferred one ? NO A very Melbourne outcome.

I'll second this. Two things. I think it might serve Clarry well to start afresh and reset. I think whoever we might garner from allowing Oliver to move on might give us... us... a better return. Honestly just think it's ts a win win all round.