whatwhat say what

isn't that the same thing?

sadly bo allen won't be there with our pick 18...

i would be shocked if one if not both the camporeale twins aren't rated in the top 20 prospects of this year's draft crop

that backline was mint too - baby david neitz, paul prymke, sean wight, the febey bros, brett lovett, yeats it was a team that coulda shoulda woulda gone on to great things but never did due to unfortunate circumstances schwarz's pirouette out of a contest to kick a goal in the final vs the baggers is one of my favourite things of all time

you think? i'm not sure sure... smith - yes, but his limitations with disposal are clear for all to see shiel - no parker - yes, he's the 'senior player' i'd love us to target reeves - would not be in our best 23 o'brien - same cumming - not sure who he'd replace in our best 23 peatling - borderline lobb - doubt it, hope not of the others you listed, rayner would be a walk-up start in any team's side, daniel borderline, and the others not so much

we don't have any requirement to trade petty he's under contract and will be a restricted free agent at the end of 2025 unless the crom or the pear come in with a juicy offer, i expect he'll be in red and blue next year... ...and fwiw rucci - who is pretty connected in sa medja - thinks he isn't comin back to sa

There’s a lot of players here who aren’t in their side’s best team for a reason; I doubt they’d be in ours either We already have a lot of sloppy seconds who aren’t in our best 26; we don’t need more list cloggers on good coin

I would expect every club wants it Hopefully the tall we have coming thru in 2025 is an elite talent

different era started last year obviously 13 wins to make finals will become the norm, i expect

i think we should have at least three demonland podcasts a week absolutely fantastic stuff @binman on yr lonesome

the fisted, listed: - us: mac andrew - aints: cam mckenzie - norf: riley sanders - meth coke: lance collard - flagmantle: jesse motlop and mitch edwards - dingley: tew jiath

the fisted, listed: - us: mac andrew - aints: cam mckenzie - norf: riley sanders - meth coke: lance collard - flagmantle: jesse motlop and mitch edwards - dingley: tew jiath

not remotely surprised it was a knee jerk change and now they've jerked the knee the other way it'll be the likes of andrew bassat's 'compromise' for the northern franchise academies

a real mfcss sufferer would say "because there are no guarantees he's EVER coming back"

different era with 1 extra game per home and away season with the advent of 'gil's round' 13 wins is the new 12 wins

zerohanger is trash ladhams might be a delisted train-on option, stringer is no chance and they can't even spell 'marke' keane's name correctly, plus he's keen on going to the filth according to most other thources

yeah arguably one of the best drafting years that taylor has had 3 premiership players with 3 picks within 10 of each other, and all deemed as speculative at the time outstanding imo lever is one of the best recruits we've ever had as well - a leader who performs an outstanding and crucial role i would assume it's between him and trac as our next skipper

he can ask to his heart's content... i personally wouldn't rule the pear out of chasing him either fwiw premiership talls who are 24 years old, can play either end - and even pinch hit (sort of!) in the ruck - aren't dime a dozen

based on current points a bundle of 38. 42, 47 is equivalent of pick 14... so right on the money for baggers and the bears' likely first rounder that depends on when the value cut-off for points is; last bit of speculation i saw was that it was expected to be end of third round, so after pick 54, so all those three picks will retain some value, if not as much as now if we did those three picks for baggers first rounder i'd be curious to see if the recruitment dept would add it to our 11 and see if we can get higher again it seems to have been our modus operandi since the advent of future picks

almost as egregious as nic martin, who was on meth coke's 'train on' list and they passed on him completely would be very interested to see shifter's under 16 team for that year to see where he makes it i'm one of those 'why move him from half-back?' peeps, but the promise of amw means that it does become a possibility hasn't rivers trained with the mids for the last two pre-seasons or so, but it's taken an injury to petracca to see him unleashed into the midfield? could definitely see mcvee having that sort of impact if required

i could be wrong, but i have a memory of jamar being a mollydooker really setting him apart as a ruckman at the time? he was very good, but - as @Wells 11 said - not in the same echelon as the three i called out

this bit is symptomatic of the change of football that has happened in the time since - pressure forwards have become one of the key components of every good side, so it makes sense to target them less obsession, more being ahead of the curve this was very much a 'trades' year rather than a 'draft' one, and ended up being pretty important for our success 2018 to 2023, with hibberd such an important part of our side going forward with the best players coming late or in the rookie draft, it really seems like the choice cuts were relatively uncertain in this year

angwin is the only name we've been linked with by the medja thus far other than battle, who seems to be choosing between staying at the aints or going to his 'childhood club', the dingley dorks it's a shame, really, as i think battle would perfectly suit our system

of that selection, i'd be most keen on humphrey, but can't see any way gc17 will let him go hobbs, sheldrick, davies to a lesser degree, and binns cos he's 'known to the family' (well, a friend's family) wouldn't go near tsatas - he can't hit a target by foot

curse of ruckman, ya say? i say a blessing... gawn - the greatest ever jeff white - they literally changed the rules to stop his dominance jim stynes - the original indestructible warrior fullarton is a forward who can ruck a bit, and jvr / petty / turner are far more effective at it than he is