Everything posted by whatwhat say what
-
2026 Injury List
concussion - definitely; knee - potentially
-
GAMEDAY: Practice Match vs Richmond
some days? some days?!?? norm smith curse only lifted when none of us (well, most of us) could go to see us win a premiership!
-
GAMEDAY: Practice Match vs Richmond
nothing in it; complete accident wow now lightning and the players are being called off it's almost like the afl should use a stadium that they own that has a roof to play practice games on
-
GAMEDAY: Practice Match vs Richmond
luker looked in a bad way knocked out cold - elbow to the head in the contest possible mcl injury as he landed too
-
Next Captain? (in a few years)
major tom [matthews] as his vice?
-
Barassi Way
that's pretty cool
-
The New Home Base & Training Ground Thread
i seem to recall they were more stunned by the LACK of parking required due to easily accessible public transport options
-
NON-MFC: 2026 Practice Matches Week 02
grundy knows how to take advantage of the situation that is at hand definitely going to get rules on the run with this garbage new approach to centre circle
-
NON-MFC: 2026 Practice Matches Week 02
since i put it on at half time, these two teams look very, very good annoying
-
2026 Injury List
also, does this create an opportunity for ah mu to get on the list? he showed more in that practice game than el jefe
-
2026 Injury List
creates an opportunity for others hopefully a kentfield or max the younger can grasp it
-
PREGAME: Practice Match vs Richmond
Kentfield firms for rd 1 debut
-
Our 2018 Attempt to Land Zak Butters
General impression I get from non Dees fans is still this They still see him as a ‘dirty’ player and would love to have him
-
NON-MFC: 2026 Practice Matches Week 02
derksen going well
-
Rolling Weekly Best 23
yeah i get that i am presuming at this stage he'll be good to go, as per petty getting the key defender spot over mcdonald pending fitness
-
The New Home Base & Training Ground Thread
i would argue we were not 'nomads' but instead in 'isolation' arguably it was the thing that allowed the players to focus and work together as one to build towards the premiership
-
Rolling Weekly Best 23
at this stage, i want milkshake's "smarts" in the team more than i want to see kentfield debut it's either him or moose for a bench spot imo
-
Rolling Weekly Best 23
that's a very tall line-up; i would expect el jefe and taylor might not make the 23, and tholstrup is borderline too mine: B: Jiath - Petty - Lever HB: Linsday - Turner - Salem C: Langford - Steele - Howes HF: Fritsch - Mihocek - Langdon F: van Rooyen - Melksham - Chandler Foll: Gawn - Rivers - Koz Pickett I/c: Windsor - Tholstrup - Heath - Sparrow - Kuz Pickett Emerg: Taylor - McDonald - Kentfield but still a fair bit to play out before the seasons starts in earnest obviously yep, he's one of our more consistent players and a clear leader around the group
-
Our 2018 Attempt to Land Zak Butters
you know full well he'll praise it as an astute decision, just like he did the mega-contract for the horny one
-
Kane Cornes to Slam Carlton
andrew wu in ninefax much more balanced: https://www.theage.com.au/sport/afl/sam-walsh-s-new-deal-is-a-risk-for-the-blues-this-is-why-they-had-to-take-it-20260224-p5o4z0.html
-
Kane Cornes to Slam Carlton
written down rant: https://www.sen.com.au/news/2026/02/24/afl-news-kane-cornes-on-sam-walsh-carlton-contract-editorial nothing that anyone else hasn't said, albeit it negates that baggers were likely damned if they did, damned if they didn't sign him up
-
Kane Cornes to Slam Carlton
and has basically been broken ever since the gary ayres medal is a strange one - if you finish in the top 4 and go thru to win the premiership in straight sets it's harder to win it as you don't tend to have played as many games as someone who has come from outside the 4 / lost in the first round of finals but make it thru to the grand final and still not win a premiership - for instance, jackson macrae won it in 2021
-
Welcome to Demonland: Thomas Matthews
Agreed Mostly as he’s not smart nor skilled enough to flourish as a half forward / mid at this stage His kicking still looked like it left a lot to be desired - under no pressure executing a switch kick he still failed to hit targets He clearly seems to have a great attitude and positive personality but he is a long way from looking like a first round pick should as they are about to enter a third year on an AFL list
-
Kane Cornes to Slam Carlton
guaranteed $$ and certainty for Walsh - makes plenty of sense for him baggers were damned if they did, damned if they didn’t - as one of their better players to lose him as a free agent and get a pick probably circa 10-18 would have been worthless, particularly with Andrew Walker’s son set to be a top end pick at this year’s draft when they already hold two first round picks to help them match the points that will be required to select him
-
Jeffo Ready to Soar in 2026
by the same age, weed had been best on ground in a final has el jefe ever been best on ground for casey in the vfl?