PeterJames

I have bought my three packets! Even got some pink ones!

Yeah I like this idea, just cver it up with black tape or something. Although I dont want players to distracted from the game. The best message is to win I think and win well. Lay a few huge tackles!

I like the marshmallow idea. Im am buying a pack tommoro! We need to do something... this isn't a mfc thing this is an AFL thing! All lovers of our great game are effected by this, some are blinded by the fact that he was wearing a mfc gurnsey but he was wearing a afl one when he got rubbed out! Adrian Anderson must go!

Good, Hopefully this sparks a shake up with Adrian Anderson sacked! He is a disgrace!

I know, i think i brought that up with the person but they haven't commented yet. Jones was one of our best yesterday and kicked one of the goals of the year. I still have to giggle when pre season people where saying that Moloney and Jones would not be in our best 22 or we could only have one. How silly they are, there our best 2 mids now! ANd MArix was handy yesterday, very good game, needs to do it consistantly but same with a few others. Has good skills, makes smart decisions just needs to work on his toughness. I think he gives a lot more than bennell who are probably going for a similar role.

Totally agree, no idea why everyone wants him in. Has a pea heart and is so scared. Is flashy but never does enough. Leave him at casey long term. Would much prefer Macdonald or maybe even unleash a debutant. Bennell only saving grace maybe that he could be a good sub.

When I have listened to Paul Roos, the one thing that stood out to me was when they recruited players from other clubs the one thing he gave his players was a specific role. He had 22 players playing a specific role. I think this has been an issue at our club for a while. We have a lot of players playing various roles. Dunn is one that hassn't had a specific role, I think also why Green has been struggling is that I'm not certain of his role.

Nickname is Hank!

It is also worth noting we are playing badly but are in the 8. I know it seems strange but if we win the next two we will be close to top four! This also goes to show the next month will determine his coaching and also we will find out from a few players if they are fair dinkum or not!

To be fair to Wona, Jurrah and the other forwards the ball entered our 50 3 times in the first quarter and I think at least one was the West Coast player kicked backwards into it. Our issue is the Centre Half forward to Midfield area. Davey will be lucky to get a game I think, his attitude is terrible and I am sick of him sooking it when he gets tagged.

Ah Sylvia? He was one of our bests! He may not have had a great game but seriously get a grip. How you miss Bennell and Wona out there. There are horrible at the moment. Bennell never has had an impact and reminds me of Isaac Weetra! Sooner he is gone the better, never seen a softer afl player in my time.

Anyone see the guy in the wafl that broke his leg? The subi player that fell across it was former rookie Danny Hughes. Thats the worst injury I have seen on a footy field.

Massively over rating his game. Yes he was 'OK', did a few nice things. Made better decisions but he wasn't in our top 5 players on the ground. Guy like Tapscott showed so much more and put his body on the line a number of times. Jones was by far our best and tried more than anyone out there and yet he still get put down far to much. One thing I will also say though once our midfield gets going and we get the ball in the forward line Watts will find it much easier!

When was that? when he got crunched from glass? Im sorry but if that was watts or bennell they would have run in the opposite direction. Jones took his hit and was our best player on the night. Very starnge you see this the other way.

Jones was our best lastnight and put his head over the ball a number of times so leave him out. Moloney has stepped up all year and West coast focused on him more than any on else. Davey has to be mentioned as he is soft, scared and has sulks it most games now. Im also not sure why you left Green out, the captain has been horrible this year, and has gone back to the soft, go missing player that saw him left out of the leadership group. The point when he was trying to claim the mark instead of playing the game was so frustrating to see a captain do that.

Bennell, Davey AND Wona should all be dropped. Soft passengers. Morton and Grimes have stalled and deserve a run in the two's. MAcdonald, Petterd, Bate all deserve games and we may as well see what guys like Cook, Blease and that have. Not sure Tapscott will get week though, wasn't high contact and he was fine after it.

Bennell and Wona out. Bennell is so soft and insipid! In Petterd and MAric. Out Grimes IN Macdonald. He turns it over and plays to lose. Green is lucky he is captain! Davey should also be dropped, has a pea heart and refuses to put in hard yards when required.

To be honest Strauss always plays like he has blinkers on. Not sure why you have a go at Dunn for this....

You serious about Jones? Was our best with Garland and Tengove was ok. A lot of people have giving Watts votes. He was ok but come on, it must show how poor he has been playing for that to be a pass mark.

Needs to do a blighty and walk out or make them run laps after the game. Make them hitch hike home...

From his interview he sounded under the pump a little.

I've had a crack at Watts, probably more than anyone. But tonight he has been ok. Bailey is in trouble, he can't coach. Green was a horrible choice for captain, i really want to say moloney should have been captain but we know the story. Davey goes missing far to much. Bennell is the biggest pea heart i have ever seen. Does everything to avoid contact. Trengrove has a long way to go and has plenty to learn (will be a gun though) Grimes isn't as good as I thought. Terrible decision making, skills are woeful and gets beaten far too often. Stefan Martin is clueless, has little idea. Rivers is slow and no good on a man. Wona is fat and not sure what he brings to the game. Any danger in us manning up?

Simple answer a lot of young guys and a few i feel aren't reading thee play. Some just don't like working to hard. Beamer is one who 'gut' runs more than anyone in our side and would love a few senior guys to follow.

Yes Hurley is patchy but has shown so much more. Will Watts be a better player, maybe. Will Watts be a very good player, I think so as he has all the attributes. But he has struggled and isn't in our best 22 at this point. The subject is Watts vs Hurley and Hurley wins hands down.

Hurley is so far ahead of Watts it isn't funny. Hurley has one bad game against the best side in the comp and people think he is no good? Hurley runs hard, attacks the ball and can read the play. Watts is scared of body contact and makes critical errors. Sooner he is out of the 22 the better!