Jump to content

daisycutter

Life Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by daisycutter

  1. seems like there is a 20m (10m either side) x 5m area where no-one allowed except man on mark. This 20m x5m area already exists. man on mark must be directly on the mark and no movement laterally or back (until ball kicked or play-on called) one can only pray that umps will apply a bit of common sense and not go 50m penalty crazy
  2. doh.....that was my initial question of jnr
  3. while we have switched to the behind the mark rules, i have to say 10m either side is a lot of real estate. players frequently retreat 20m, so that means 20 x (10 + 10) = 400m2 which is about the current size of a block of land! Go back 30m and we are talking of 600m2. And that is ignoring the 5m arc behind the player. imo the corridor should be 5m either side. Now if the opposition encroaches the corridor the umpires are savage....50m penalty. No common sense used even when breach is minor and of zero impact. Now contrast this to player who strays off his direct line. He is either made to go back (given another chance) or it is called play on (but not consistently)
  4. that's the old law mr !
  5. well he did sign the team apology statement and for all we know he might have been instrumental in it we don't know what he has done or is doing within the club he's not obliged to publicly say anymore. people will judge him either way he has always come across as a very polite and considerate person, so no need to pass any cheap criticism on him
  6. that's in the other direction, mr. i.e. from the mark to the player who is kicking we are talking about the other side of the mark
  7. does this include 5m laterally from mark?
  8. any source on this jnr? and is it a 5m arc or just 5m behind mark? also how much can the man on the mark roam in this arc......1,2,3,4.5m?
  9. i couldn't handle the mental torture of watching max take a 25m set shot from direct in front so, no
  10. or just have no-one on the mark, and put another player behind the man on the mark so he can move laterally. they will need to define a no-man area behind the mark.......more opportunity for 50m penalties....lovely
  11. daisycutter replied to Redleg's post in a topic in Melbourne Demons
    seems that dad jokes will now be called "non-gestational parent jokes" or ngp jokes for short so get used to it and be inclusive
  12. they will have to rename the game of australian rules to "australian 50 metres rules" and we can thank kevin sheedy for even having a 50 metres penalty
  13. daisycutter replied to Redleg's post in a topic in Melbourne Demons
    c'mon ernie don't be such a killjoy, you've never recovered your good side since the nazis cruelly burned your books and accused you of writing "popular entertainment literature that depicts life and life's goals in a superficial, unrealistic and sickly sweet manner, based on a bourgeois or upper class view of life" all that unwarranted persecution and now you are the self-appointed persecutor of what.....banana lovers! vive la banane
  14. daisycutter replied to Redleg's post in a topic in Melbourne Demons
    and if you're feeling a little blue
  15. daisycutter replied to Redleg's post in a topic in Melbourne Demons
    here you are, froggy.....a double fingered banana
  16. can you expand on why "it isn't particularly applauded within the walls of the MCC boardroom"?
  17. well only 4 weeks till rnd1 and yet to start training (AFL wise) I seriously doubt he would be afl match ready i'm sure he is basically fit and looked after himself, but has done nothing approaching an afl preseason still, i hope he's not required by rnd1 anyway
  18. i wonder how much of a pre season he's had? might not be up to scratch for first 4 or so rounds
  19. i'd have said since maurie bartlett.........lol
  20. daisycutter replied to Lord Nev's post in a topic in Melbourne Demons
    today is 2 weeks. 4 weeks is 1st march which is almost 3 weeks before round 1 (20th March) making round 1 unlikely, but round 2 a good possibility. now saying round 4 to 6! what changed?
  21. daisycutter replied to Lord Nev's post in a topic in Melbourne Demons
    nah, said back to training in 4 weeks (2 weeks ago)
  22. daisycutter replied to Lord Nev's post in a topic in Melbourne Demons
    yep that's the pork pie i was referring to - upto 4 weeks off
  23. daisycutter replied to dieter's post in a topic in Melbourne Demons
    i can't see any connection whatsoever between kozzie's absence and kobe's potential rookie signing if kobe is signed up i would have no expectation of him playing seniors in 2021.
  24. daisycutter replied to Lord Nev's post in a topic in Melbourne Demons
    pork pied to again...............just a little clean-out procedure
  25. wouldn't cost much, nothing much to lose. good depth, insurance may come in handy but no great expectations