Redleg

Is he as good as Grundy, who was ready to go and went 18? Anyway if he comes to us great and if he doesn’t, so be it.

Let’s throw some MFCSS in. If he goes top 20 to another club he will end up the greatest player in the history of the game. If he slips and we get him, he won’t be good enough to get a game for Casey.

I am happy to allow throws that look like handballs to most observers, as that is the way sport is umpired. They can't see everything and get every decision right. I am more concerned at blatant incorrect decisions, like ducking, push in the back, htb etc.

Pick umpires who know the difference between a handball and a throw and are professional enough to pay what they see.

NO!

What do you mean?

On top of the ladder with 6 rounds to go, can we stay there? Some unbelievable results this round.

Either do I. Hunter and Daniel match Selwood for ducking. Both again got frees for it yesterday. Commentators just laugh. Libba's throw was a beauty. Also loved Daniel running about 35 metres without a bounce from a kick out. Hilarious. Then the umpires call an 8 meter kick 15. So what do they think Daniel's run was?

Perfect game could be the Darwin game for him, being fresh and with lots of hype around the game.

The extra 60 rule is coming in too. Any Victorian team that is based more than 60 k’s from Melbourne, each season, gets an extra top 10 draft pick, a guaranteed 10 games at their home ground, 5 extra fees in front of goal each game, 25 more rotations each game, 19 allowed on the ground in each game, 25% more on the salary cap and unrestricted father/son and NGA players as well as anyone who says they once visited Geelong or have even heard of it. Also a finals wild card if they miss the 8 and a captain’s protest, to be used in any losing final, to have the result reversed.

85-90000 people and the money it brings is the answer.

Hopefully we play Dogs and Cats at a time they can’t change ladder position.

Hopefully we keep him on and make him into at worst, another good depth player. TBH we only have 3 real rucks on the list and 2 of them are quite young.

Didn't see the first 3/4 but commentators saying Bradtke beat Buzza a former AFL player. Bradtke playing in defence last few weeks.

Too much wine.

Similar builds, long hair, long sleeves and a 5 in the number, make it understandable to some degree. Then again it is their damn job to know better.

And charged and locked up too I hope.

Agree. Funny how we are all praising the game of a key forward who didn’t score.

Really hoping Blues and Saints can pull off big upsets this weekend.

A very good win, with several playing below their best, like Langdon, Spargo, Harmes and Fritta for example. Once again, where are the DL experts who wanted Tom Mac, JJ, Hunt, Spargo and Petty gone last year. Then again the FD wanted Tom Mac gone too. What a wonderful rejuvenation of his footy career we have seen. Credit to you Tom, you are now one of the first picked.

So now they can give them the dodgy ones in front of goal.

They are dropping the ball continually and then we are getting pinged for hold the man. Agree disgraceful. You can throw the ball if you are the home Adelaide team, but heaven help you if you handball quickly it’s a throw if you are the away team. Boys playing well atm, hopefully can go another half against 25.

While many suspect AFL interference, if anyone ever came out with proof of that, people would go to jail, there could be some collateral violence/retribution from fanatics and the game might never recover. Even a misplaced comment could cost jobs. It's a zillion to one.

Answer. When we get back to maximum effort and pressure, a settled competent forward line, good goal kicking and decent inside 50 disposal.

Yes Port would release their best young kid.