Mono

Media has also reported that his contract is heavily back ended. Talk about a stuff up. I'd have him in a heart beat BTW.

If we don't get Brown, and the Filth pay some of Treloar's contract for next 2/3/4 years, it might be doable. Heard on talkback (SEN) that Treloar wants to spend half each week in Qld; doubt any Melb club would touch that.

Franklin says hi.

Maybe he said he is staying in Perth. Simple as that.

Doubt he'd accept $650k given what he knocked back at North.

I was trying to make the point that North effectively offered him 4 yrs Money is a key determinant for Brown Happily Melbourne has had no public media coverage about money a la Collingwood.

North offered 3 years with a 4th yr option @ $850k. And he knocked it back. Certainly has a high opinion of himself.

If Hogan really wants to play AFL, I'd have him in a heart beat over Brown. Probably much cheaper too. But does Hogan still have the stomach for AFL?

Would not touch Brown with a barge pole. Too fragile, too limited. If he doesn't catch it, he's done. The best (ie big coin) forwards do more than catch it; even the King boys. Brown can't.

Agree entirely. Adelaide and West Coast - 2 flag favourites - got belted. Just saying.

No. Scott gave Abblett 5. Beyond words.

Much of the comment is hysterical. We lost because of 20 pathetic minutes, not individual players. 1st quarter - excellent 2nd qtr - 1st 10 mins - good 2nd qtr - last 20 min - pathetic (go home stuff) 3rd & 4th qtr - good Not going to beat many teams unless good (or better) for whole game.

Melksham and ANB - skills not good enough at AFL level/intensity. They have had lots of chances. (ANB a great disappointment after an A+ preseason.) Nothing I saw has me wanting Maynard and Wagner out. (eg Wagner tackle on Selwood.) We lost because of 20 pathetic minutes, not individual players. Pre-condition to play: hardness!

Gawn Petracca Oliver Jones Harmes Lewis appol: Fritsch, Wagner

Still spots available in this comp. I'd like it to be all Dee supporters/Demonlanders. Mono

Turned my Public comp into a Private one. Name: Deepends Code: 111400 Mono

Set up a comp: DEEPENDS. YOUR LEAGUE INVITATION CODE: Z7MUYWYJ 16 players, final 8, no bye games. All welcome. Cheers, MONO

Yep. (Looking to join a DT comp as well)

I'm in. Team: Deesperates

I'm in. Team: Deesperates

Team: Deesperates if room left in a comp.

FFS. NO and NO.

Lewis and Dunstan are the feature players on the HFC web site, as of now.

2 extra years is good for the club. It will then know just how good he is, rather than be paying long, big contract, largely on promise.

As Roos said: no matter where he is, Hogan will be well paid; he has to decide where he wants to be. If he goes home, a deal will get done; MelbourneFC moves on (albeit with plenty of salary cap space). IMO, no player in a successful team gets $1m - consider Geelong and Hawks. I'm happy if he stays; if he goes, so be it.