Jump to content

BangBnagBang

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by BangBnagBang

  1. 10 For 26 & 34 & 40 1395 points for 1700
  2. Lions will be looking for future picks for the younger Ashcroft next year.
  3. That's not my memory and Im happy to be corrected, but Jolly cracked it due to ND playing Jamar in front of him late in the season and looked to leave at season end.
  4. BangBnagBang replied to RedFox's post in a topic in Melbourne Demons
    Nathan Bassett let go from port. Was highly rated a couple years ago. Could he do mid job or at minimum could take over defence if Chappy moves into mid.
  5. While I don’t hate the idea of asking the question about Dursma I had been thinking of helping port out another way. They need draft capital for ZT. Zauva and street and only have pick 37&43. Could we ask for there F1st and send them 23&32. Would give us 2 1st round picks in consecutive years.
  6. Is assume this is better mail than last time when it was Petty to miss 5 weeks???
  7. Unless we can tempt North ( com'on Todd mate) with a bounty and trade for pick 2. It then put us in the above position?????? If we can get hold of GCS pick would north swap 2 for 4 and 5????
  8. Taylor and Lamb have shown over the years they will have no hesitation to use next years first and pay it forward. I don't see us taking 4 picks under 30ish. we just dont have the list spots or the depth need to bring in 4-5 18yo this year. You can see with Laurie and Howes we just cant fit them in the team, form not withstanding. What we can fit in the 22 is high end talent. That's why I can see us offering the world for pick 1 or CG 5 and taking 1 or 2 high end talent instead of 4 top 30.
  9. BangBnagBang replied to Romey's post in a topic in Melbourne Demons
    The girls also had photo day yesterday at Casey so boys may have moved for the day to allow this to happen. Nibs and JV also spoke to the Vic players on leadership so one may have worked around the other??
  10. I’m not😉
  11. My thoughts would it would be purely match ups. Against Rich Jack was the best match up for Thomo and May could take a smaller option which is not Thomos go. It will be interesting with finals teams v North. North only have Larkey and maybe the resting ruck. Do we play Thommo on Larkey and May on a small or does May take Larkey and we bring in Hibbo for Thommo to play on a small.
  12. not what casey wants but finishing 7-10 would be best for Melbourne.
  13. just too slow in body and mind, and not damaging by hand or foot to compensate. great depth but hes not best 22 and thats alright, but he has to decide if he stays and fills a depth role or goes and try and be best 22 elsewhere
  14. BangBnagBang replied to dazzledavey36's post in a topic in Melbourne Demons
    My concern is we need to guarantee WCE can get Curtain if thats who they want. Pick 4 doesn't do that. Esp with Haw with Frost coming to end, DGB not really working so far and Sicilly not big KP size. Therefore can we get 2 off North. Pick 2 would be a lot more tempting for WCE than 4 as it grantees they get there man. could we swap 4 15 23 to North for 2 & 17 then swap 2 & 17 to WCE for pick 1 or something similar???
  15. BangBnagBang replied to dazzledavey36's post in a topic in Melbourne Demons
    any love for Caddy for the exact opposite reasons above. Small tall fwd/tall mid, but has the physicality that maybe Duursma lacks?????
  16. once you have been delisted you become a FA for life
  17. If we have to loose someone hes the one. Not great at anything, OK at most things.
  18. Its not like JT did his best to trade up for Humphreys last year who plays nothing like Trac???
  19. Why is it some people have to be grammer police. Won wonders what they do in there spare tyme.
  20. Think Id prefer to go to port first week, free hit with a nervous port team. Win and we set up a home Prelim. loose and we hopefully win week 2 and set up a home prelim against the pies.
  21. No one is paying Ben McKay 800K
  22. Are you talking about Melbounre and grundy??
  23. Shaun Smith 3 Brownlow votes and no goals. I assume he played on Carey who only had 6 kicks 1 goal. Only one player over 20 disposals, Clarkson with 23. how the game has changed,
  24. There is a difference between bid and nominate. Ashcroft nominated Brisbane and was bid on by North. White can nominate Melbourne but there is nothing stopping GCS bidding on him. its up to Melbourne to match the bid. I never understand why people post stuff which is just plain wrong and shows they don't know what they are talking about. Still school holidays isnt it.