picket fence

Introducing Fencescore ( A trip down memory lane where in the late 70ts every player was given a rating out of 10 in the Sun) Here's mine for the week ( Please note even had we have won I wouldn't change a score) Jones 7 Viney 7 Fritsch - 8 Hogan 6 Harmes 8 Brayshaw 7 Lewis 5 Melksham 4 T.McDonald 4 Neal-Bullen 2 Petracca 2 Tyson 1 Weideman 4 Gawn 9 Hannan 2 Hibberd 5 Oliver 6 Petty 1 Salem 3 Smith 4 Jetta 4 O.McDonald 2

Yep this almost harks back to the dismal Neeld years Gee never saw that coming!

Exactly right and this from the coaching staff was extremely poor support. Gee he looked so slow!

This is right on the money, needs to be addressed, Pronto!

Add to that Clarry starting on the bench for 8 minutes start 3rd quarter?? Wtf

But Nasher, as you know VFL form on tiny grounds slower play .. some players look good! Unfortunately he is a long way from it lacks pace and a poor left foot looked like under 12 stuff! These professionals in the FD ARE PAID BIG BUCKS TO GET IT RIGHT! With this one NQR

This is extremely poor and this used to happen often in the Neeld Tenure! Not right at all!!

My son is in New York and he rang me straight after the game and heaped scorn ….. And blame! On me for indoctrinating him from birth as a die hard Dee! Consigned to torment! His footy career ended at 25 after 3 serious knee operations and he said to me .. Dad what is going on ? we have a great list some great in and under's and still cannot cut it!! Can players respond when up against it? Shattered! Walking away from the G, I thought of Rob and put myself into memory mode! to give some relief! Tonight, I may watch the last round in 87 vs Doggies , have more than a few scotches and dull the pain! Will it ever end?

Yep but also Petracca and Neal Bullen need to go Oscar Baker a chance , Pedo at least offers grunt and experience!

YES and this is something Roosy would not have put up with! Hnmm

Another good question!

Maybe add another to this list... Petracca! Needs a rocket!

YEP MORE PAIN 10THBOURNE HERE WE COME !

Macca come on DOWN!!

Yep!

Unfortunately the worst debut since Glenn Giles in 1980! No PACE, in fact he is Slower than Oscar ! That embarrassing left foot kick which went nowhere was cringeworthy. Those that have been singing his praise better think again. Frost is clearly Clearly a much better player and demands inclusion this week. Petty was today a heartbreaker! Sorry to say!

Delusional !!!no wonder our players drink their own bathwater! we are a too cozy footy club that lacks serious balls, smarts and credibility!!

Jack Viney!!

Nice to see ! Thought he was cooked at Melbourne but a feel good story !

Gee some tough comments here, I thought him quite serviceable and will be better for the run!

Well how did he go? Anyone got the inside info?

NO ! If we play finals he will get a game. MARK MY WORDS AND WATCH THIS SPACE!

Agree with most but would offer this Oskar Baker looks ready but where does he play, deserves a game with recent very good form and excellent game today.Reminds me a bit of Cameron Ling the way he plays Sam Frost is too good for this level hardly made a mistake and unless Petty is one out of the box He also deserves a game . He was top notch today Bernie was irrepressible as he was impassable also too good Stretch started very well faded a bit at the end but again was consistent. Still not convinced though but he has definitely improved. Jeffy some good pressure acts classy goal but this standard does not suit him I believe. Not sure he would ever dominate a game.

As mentioned previous a mate of mine who had a major association with Collingwood said one thing to me when this was announced "Good Luck"

Tellingly, the bloke that was most rapped for Petty was PEDO! Just watch the vid on the official site! This is the hallmark of not only a great spirit but hopefully a great mentoring program!!