Bring-Back-Powell

Please let both of these players be once in a generation type players.

I think our entire forward line is a shambles. We may have kicked less goals in other games this year, however last week (V Brisbane) our forward line was at it's most dysfunctional. Our entire forward line is a real concern going forward, and certainly agree with the OP that our list is sorely lacking a competent small forward.

I would hope the last player highlighted would be an answer to our problem given that he cost us 2 first rounders and we are 18th for points against.

Given that Carlton has a better percentage than us and has performed no worse than us this year I don't really see how a loss to Carlton changes anything in this disgrace of a season. Our coach has a longer contract afforded to him than the queen of England so he ain't going anywhere. Would just be another of a long list of shameful losses. If any action should have been taken, it should've been after St Kilda beat us by 40 points on our turf. That was as low as it gets.

Great effort compiling that list. Had no idea we actually played a practice match at Boronia in the early 90's!

How short were those goal posts! I've seen taller posts at the local under 6's game.

Kent to miss rest of season with quad injury.

The fact they got 13 consecutive games out of him is a minor miracle.

At the 29 game mark for each player (sauce - afl tables) Schwarz - 27 goals Weideman - 25 goals

I get that those in-game injuries really helped us, but if Freo were good enough they still could've beaten us despite being 2 players down. Many clubs have won games with 2 men down - as recently as round 12 when Sydney were down to one on the bench against West Coast.

Our average was inflated by our Port rd 1 game of 40K when all the red and blue army had premiership dreams. Play that game this week and we'd be lucky to get 23K and would be below St Kilda on the OP's table.

Last week Port fans wanted him sacked after they lost to Freo.

Sydney were 3 men down against West Coast and won. Enjoy the win mate.

My thoughts too. Hope he doesn’t get booed but hope he has a dirty and undisciplined day.

We’ve gone from $1.85 to $1.67 over night. Firstly why are we favourites? Secondly who had a big nibble on us last night and does he have some insider trading?

He started the season poorly (and who didn’t!) but came back for the Hawks game and played well, and I was surprised he was dropped the week after. 1 or 2 year extension is hardly going to make a difference either way to the club’s fortunes. Strikes me as the sort of player that only plays well when the side plays well, which is not an overly great attribute.

I reckon Hogan will have a much better second half of the year and those modest stats mentioned above will skew the other way. He had a heavily compromised pre season and also fitting into a new system. I, like many others, got seduced into T Mac's season last year and was all too ready to punt Hogan.

I reckon Weideman isn't far away from a break out 4 goal game. Had he nailed his last set shot V's Collingwood he would've had a nice 3 goal performance against Darcy Moore who's clearly one of the premier key defenders in the league. Slowly but surely he's getting there.

Joel Smith | Groin – TBC Misson now won't even bother with a one liner with his injury anymore.

Not sure Petty is needed. May can take Hogan. Frost can take Cox. Hore can also help out in the key defenders department. The rest of their forward line are full of dangerous smalls such as Walters and Matera. Hoping the Petty selection isn’t a waste of time.

Takes me back the infamous Melbourne V GWS game in 2014 (Roos's first year) when they didn't have a fit player on the bench in the last quarter but still out scored us: 5-1 to 1-5.

In fairness Collingwood probably had as many best 22 out as us on QBday.

Someone said Hibberd missed training so I'm guessing he's back on the list?

Each to their own. I like Thursday Night Footy. It Feels like the weekend has come early and it gives you something to look forward to during your Thursday work day. Hopefully they can increase TNF from 8 this year to 11 next year.

Geelong are woeful after the bye so Port might be good money at $2.80?? Reckon Brisbane might have another road setback, this time against St Kilda. Sydney should keep Hawthorn to a very low score. Hopefully Essendon get flogged tonight.