Do you ever say anything positive? EVERY comment on this thread from you is negative!
How about posting something when we are playing well or have a good passage of play!
My God some Melbourne supporters have absolutely no idea, one peanut behind me who ran with the old "kick if long" all day, said during the game "if the ground spoils the ball, then it is a mark".
To be fair, I wouldn't want either coming in for their first game against the cats. I understand the "super fresh" philosophy but that's no good if they aren't up with the speed of the game. If they are right to go (and there's a spot available) i'd play them against Carlton to find their feet before the cats.