BDA

I think the Dees are the real but i hate Geelong so i'm barracking for the Lions.

The head says a cats win best for the Dees as we're still a chance for 3rd, possibly 2nd. but I can't barrack for a cats win. i just can't bring myself to do it.

The pick 3 dream has officially died. but pick 4 is still a real chance so... Go Swannies!

Tiges with all the momentum. Hawks badly need a goal here

How is Brodie looking up forward?

Hawks playing very well. Mitchell is doing a great job with them.

Hard to believe how far the Eagles have fallen. I thoroughly dislike the club and its supporters, so no tears shed here. The only downside is they are so bad i don't think they're much hope of beating Freo which could impact the deathride.

I haven't given up on pick 3 just yet. Go Hawks

If they are really interested in making the fixture fairer why not ensure teams alternate between home and away every second year. why do we have to play Geelong and west coast at their home grounds every year. Makes no sense from a fairness standpoint

Great goal Oskar

bailey smith misses everything from 20 meters. horrendous set shot

Langford and Wright are a very good double act.

Petty has been injury prone this year and his form has been patchy. If tommo takes his opportunity this weekend I doubt he’ll get dropped again. You never know how things will play out. Tommo’s injury in 21 opened the door for petty who took his opportunity brilliantly. Who’s to say tommo won’t do the same thing now?

I wish the Matildas the best of luck for the rest of the tournament but tonight I'll be cheering on the girls in green.

We should make him an offer commensurate with his value to us. I don't want to lose him but I think he's worth more to rival clubs where he'll be best 22. He's borderline best 22 for us and is relying on injuries to get regular games. Personally, I think he should go to another club to fulfil his career. He deserves to I reckon.

Sarah black needs to raise her game.

I reckon there's a 5% chance he gets traded this year. A small chance but still a chance.

Brodie is good enough to be a No 1 ruck somewhere else. The plan/experiment as sold to him doesn't appear to be working out. It might yet. There are still 6 H&A games and a finals series to go. He may decide that he is ok playing second fiddle to Max for a couple of seasons. I think all parties entered into this arrangement with the best of intentions. If its not working nobody would blame Brodie for asking for a trade. As a club we have a proven track record of treating players fairly. I reckon we would accommodate his request. We'll come up with an alternative plan for Maxy's successor.

footy fans are very ungrateful

Caulfield is the solution for us. Ticks all the boxes. As long as we satisfy the community use conditions there is no reason why we can't make this work. I hope Kate Roffey is working overtime on this.

Rugby League is the most boring game on the planet. 5 tackles. kick. 5 tackles. kick. I'd rather watch paint drying.

Early in the season plenty more posters said hawthorn were tanking to get Harley Reid. They’ve won 5 games. They have been having a crack every match (notwithstanding they’ve copped some beatings along the way which are par for the course for young developing teams). I’m not sure they would rather lose than end up with pick 4. I think Mitchell is telling his team to go out and have a go and let the cards fall where they may. I think this is the right approach from a cultural perspective.

He's great back-up for Max this year. Let's face it. It's highly unlikely Grundy will become a serviceable KPF. Next season and perhaps the season after he'll have to accept fewer playing minutes as back-up to Max. This may not be what he wants to do. And it may not suit us either. We're paying $650k (reporting) for a back-up ruckman. Thats a lot of coin that could be deployed elsewhere. He would be perfect for Port so I don't think a trade is impossible. It might actually be the best for all concerned depending on what we can get in the deal (2nd round pick or a Port player?)

Death riding is great fun chook. You should give it a go. It's wonderful watching a team fail knowing the greater the failure the greater the benefit to us. And its extra satisfying if you're petty and mean spirited like I am.

Works well in the NFL because a small number of teams qualify for the playoffs. You need a very good W L record to secure a wildcard spot. Playing finals after winning 10 games would demean the competition.