Kent

Deservedly so in my opinion, but lets wait and see how the end of year plays out

I was actually talking about Goodwin and Maccas relationship. But take your point Bb.

How in hells' name can you tell?

They have a high performance high performance department?

Roughhead and Burgoyne talking with Suns Who are Melbourne talking to? Roughy to coach our forwards YES Please.

And why McCartny, who calls a spade a spade, was removed from the coaches box and then given the flick. Carp on that!

Looks like a stunned mullet in the box but you are right dont know him at all. Can I be allowed to judge him on his performance? Challenge all you like. You must know him very well if you know for sure he isn't stubborn.

Mate these people were hand picked byGoodwin and Mahoney We have trusted them and they have failed in all ways possible. I am not sure the best assistants and staff in the world would be able to help Goodwin.He is too stubborn and obviously out of his depth He is dead man walking in my view.Too difficult to come back from where he has put himself and the club. Put him and the supporters out of their collective misery. Nothing can really change between now and midseason 2020.

Can he coach?

Find it amazing earlier in the season many here and in media were questioning the competence of the Melbourne coaching staff and we were told all was ok, we have the right coaching team, the metrics are trending positively yah yah yah> No review necessary etc etc. Now all of a sudden we are having external review overseen by Mahoney and we are jettisoning coaches like no toomorrow. Has the football club finally woken up from their slumber? The whole year has been about spin and I for one am tired of it. We can handle the truth!!!

I bet they wish they hadn't prematurely re-signed him Nowhere to hide now Mr Pert and Mr Mahoney

There is so much going wrong in that picture it beggars belief. Frame it, put on the wall and tell every player every day that is not how you play modern footy Its a disgrace.

Deluded view.

Jaded Goody is dumb and stubborn. We have three more years of this carp>

Ahhhhhhh I wonder who is the problem ??? In the end he will be left alone contemplating what might have been. As said on other thread Its a bad combination Dumb and stubborn. He is not listening.

Was at the game Nobody was anywhere Sidebottom for the whole game. Our wingers including Jones started on the corner of the square and no matter what the outcome ran back into space. Very strange set up.

Sign him up please has been our best defender this year Hasn't cost us 1.6 million like the other two SIGN HIM UP!!

Because of his style and lack of real footy smarts the team has been influenced to play Jones style over many years. I have always apprecciated Jones' efforts and desire but he isn't a good enough footballer to make a difference Thanks for your efforts Jonesey Enjoy life after Footy.

Bottom 4 finish 8 years in the last 20. Another miserable record is ours.

Pert said yesterday "we are talking 5 ,6,or 7 years" What planet is this guy on?

The coach works for the board So they hear the same claptrap from the coach that we do. And they put up with it seemingly. Goodys end will come quickly and without notice in my opinion.

I also engaged with Pies supporters as there were few demons supporters around me. I must say I enjoyed their analysis. The problems with our game are easy to see.I almost can't watch at the moment so predictable are the poor set ups inevitable turnovers and missed kick tackles handball and goals. The problems have been easy to see the coaching staff either can't or won't address them. How our board are putting up with this is beyond me. Maybe they believe that the team metrics are trending in the right direction. If they are prepared to accept that claptrap then anything is possible.Please for the love of God end this torture.

Stretch will not make it Free up a spot please Keep Lewis one more year Find a KPF who can mark and contest.

so who then is our main man? SW who cant hold his place and is still developing or TMac who really is a second tall who struggles against the best defenders Surely we need a key forward who can mark contest and Kick goals regularly This year has shown me that we certainly have a vacancy

Except we have managed to get the list from 4th to 17th in 12 months