Smokey

Y’all overthinking this badly. Smith forward, Tommo back. Simple.

No point worrying about injuries, they are bound to happen

Hugely disappointing but on the bright side we have our number 1 key forward locked in for the foreseeable future. He looked good again today before he went down.

Harmes - Not AFL standard

Yeah, nah. Josh is the most petrified footballer I've seen in years. Hard pass.

Sums it up perfectly

Goodys call to switch to man on man defence was a great move

Why on earth are we being offered jez or lynch below market value? These sorts of hypotheticals are ridiculous.

Strange feeling when our key forwards delivered most of the score rather than smalls and mids. Great signs

Had decent oppo on him too. I’ve long advocated for petty as a forward. Him and JVR are the future key forward structure 100%.

Harmes is such an ordinary footballer these days

Love this post I saw on Freo's BigFooty today: "Pick 4 going to Melbourne makes me physically ill. Not even the most pessimistic of supporters last October in trade week could have seen this coming. I thought maybe it could be pick 9 or 10 and that would still be expensive but I could live with that. Jason Taylor and the Dees recruiters must be laughing their asses off at us. We are the gift that keeps on giving as far as Melbourne list management is concerned. If there’s any semblance of pride and anger left in our club we have to try win 3 or 4 more games and push that pick out a bit. Avoidance of ridicule if nothing else"

I've just pivoted here from the "What they're saying at Punt Rd" thread. Please, PLEASE boys - put them to the sword by 50+.

What on earth? Why would they think either of the following: - Lever a faux tough guy? - We would view a game against a team sitting 10th as our grand final? These people are insane. Much like us I guess.

I'll give you the benefit of the doubt and assume that if you had your time again writing this comment you'd include Viney in that list of A-graders

I have Woey ahead of Spargo. Spargo's mind is as slow as mud when he takes a mark and his kick penetration is liabilty. Woey showing enough signs, and can kick a footy further than 30 metres.

Fine, I'll say it if no one else will ... Coaching record aside, Is Goody the right guy?

This may be the case now, but it prudent for the club to explore options like this for our younger players. Brown is on his last legs, and we are in a 3 year premiership window at a minimum. Development of young players is key to extending our window.

Absolutely love choc. Elite spiritual leader.

For anyone thinking that wasn't a good performance and that we should have won more easily, think again. Adelaide are a great team and could easily have been a strong top 8 team this year if a few results went their way in close games, and they were playing for their season yesterday. I'm encouraged by a number of young players coming into form, such as Koz, Chin and JVR. Melksham is exceeding my expectations at the moment, which makes for an interesting dilemma when it comes to Fritta when he's fit again. The usual suspects were immense, won't even bother naming them because you know who they are. Rivers continues to impress the hell out of me. Great result, on to the next!

You can really see how the BJJ training he does with his brother pays off

No huge loss if we're being honest. He's served as well as depth, but I certainly wouldn't lose sleep over this one.

I can confirm this. I was born in Adelaide and last night I was looking for my phone for a good 2 minutes while holding it.