Smokey

I’d argue your view that Viney should somehow avoid (well deserved) scrutiny is what has made Melbourne a soft and fickle bunch. We’re coming into our first window in decades, there is no room for sentiment any longer. Only results.

Should just be a fine, so 1 week minimum

Sad and true. Why would the government care about about the terrible social issues these machines create when they make everyone so much money?

Good the see he’s back on top of things but gee whiz Daily Mail using the term star extremely loosely in that title

What a magnificent Sunday this is. Need to keep going and crush them. We could repent for 186 right now

A week is a long time in footy huh. The confidence we’ll be getting from this is very important

I got a good feeling we’ll finally respond to this horrible run of form today and win comfortably. It’s time for Ben Brown to step up and kick a bag. If he can find some form over the next few weeks I will go into September with far more confidence.

Small world it seems. I'm here in Canberra too and I specialize in engineering SIEM's (not Splunk though)

This looks interesting I’ll give it a read. I’ve never really looked at these heat maps much before so I’m interested in how it works

Yes I work in big data, specifically in cyber security. Just because you don't understand something doesn't mean its not fulfilling its intended purpose.

You do not understand how data visualization works at all do you lol

Agree we need a few changes this week. Reckon a few need either a rest or a spell at Casey to sort it out

I'll never suggest we don't have issues right now OD. I will say its entirely possible that our recent form can be attributed to something that won't be an issue in September, like training loads. I enjoy footy more when I look at it this way

Nah you're on to something here. Sometimes it feels like many want us to lose to validate their own assumptions that we'll fail (based on solid evidence of course)

They say everything is fine, you disagree. Fair enough. Look on the bright side - you now have the opportunity to observe a period of curiosity in waiting to see whether indeed they were right, and everything was fine. And you were wrong. We all hope for the latter right

The issue is clearly the over-complication of the rules and interpretations. Nothing more. My comment was reserved for those who would suggest that umpires affecting the result of the game is a deliberate action.

I don't feel I said that at all.

Perhaps not directly, but if the senior player's are having to worry about aspects of the game the young guys have previously been handling then perhaps they are indirectly affecting those areas. I can only speculate.

You seem like a very sad and bitter man. Imagine being terribly offended at the idea of parent buying a pizza for a child after not being picked on a sporting team, and then calling others a snowflake? Boomers don't appreciate irony like we do I guess. Laughable stuff, can't wait till your generation is the hell out of my parliament.

This is what you look like when you claim umpires are somehow conspiring to effect the result of games. It's just rubbish.

Young teams get tired in the back half of the season. Add in the fact Burgo has a tendency to increase training loads around about the same time our form started to go down and I think the answer is clear enough. Lots of over-thinking happening in this thread in my view. We have 19-20 year olds in every part of the ground ... We rely on the likes of Pickett, Jackson, Jordan and Rivers more than some may appreciate. Their decline in output has had an effect on our results. It's not the worst problem to have ... as long as we resign them

We’ll be up and about. so will they. Should be a cracking game really Dee’s by 2 goals

If Jack hits one target out of all his i50 entries and we win vs Hawthorn I love his pressure, don't get me wrong, but pressure can't be your only trick if you want to be in the starting 22 for a team competing for flag. Accumulating 30+ disposals means little to me if none of the possessions are damaging, or conversely, damaging to us. I'm not a Jack hater, I would just like to see him improve in other areas of the game. It's not 2015 anymore, all players need to be more well-rounded if we are to be a chance this September.

Nonsense. No one, especially an inside mid of which we have an abundance of on the list, is immune to scrutiny. Jack accumulated lots of footy last week but his disposal absolutely killed us. He needs to start making better decisions. He needs to stop getting caught HTB. We all love Jack but no one is immune to scrutiny if we are hunting a flag.

"Heading the Hawks’ naughty list, it should come as no surprise that Dermott ‘The Kid’ Brereton has missed more games through suspension than any of his fellow clubmen. The famous No.23 coincidently sat out a total of 23 games after receiving 14 separate charges during his decorated career in the brown and gold. Brereton added another 16 games to that tally in the final two years of his career – 14 weeks from two separate incidents in his lone year at the Swans, and two weeks from a single incident at Collingwood."