Everything posted by Engorged Onion
- Trade Rumours 2023
- Trade Rumours 2023
-
Farewell James Harmes
Holy hell thatās euphemistic! Whatās the definition of an inside slider (in a football context, rather than urban dictionary)?
- Trade Rumours 2023
- Christian Petracca a chance to win the 2023 Brownlow Medal?
-
Farewell James Harmes
Newish jargon of a ācoolerā, sounds naff. Question for those hipster football analysts, whatās the difference between a ātaggerā? Harmesy will be good for depth - the game moves on quickly ehā¦
-
Christian Petracca a chance to win the 2023 Brownlow Medal?
Was discussing this whilst watching the first quarter (Bris and Carlton), theyāre professional AND they are part time. Thatās an important distinction to be made On a side note, a good friend of mine was an umpire for 10 years or so with the AFL and post career (roughly 10 years) he has never run more than 2km since. The training is THAT effortful.
-
2023 GRAND FINAL
I agree with the sentiment, and thatās not really how it works in reality, is it? Anyway, tin foil hat time ,- I sat with 5 people last night, 1 Collingwood - 1 Freo and 2 Geelong supporters, and another Dees supporters, who all felt the game was umpired with a strong bias towards confecting to a particular outcome. 3 in particular had never previously harboured a sense that the AFL attempts to manipulate outcomes - although all agreed they do it off the field, be it tribunals, or Essendon, or the umpire that was charged with betting, or HR issues, orā¦ They were gobsmacked about the first quarter and a bit.. about the non calls being made, and even the Collingwood supporter could reflect enough (female!) that GWS did not get the ārub; in the final quarter the night before. Anyway - your comment got me thinking about the Dogs - and how simultaneously in EPL there was also the fairytale story of Leicester in the same yearā¦ HOW Convenient! and then the Dees, winning in an already compromised (financially) Covid yearā¦ yep - I think Iāve gone off the deep end
-
Game plans, tactics and all that jazz
Hey fellow Dees Devotees, The air is thick with reflections pondering, and aggressive drive bys on the forum dressed up as āasking the crucial questions that no one else has the cajoles to do soā. Anyway as we've witnessed our team maintain a consistent top 4 presence but not clinch the premiership. Itās a pivotal moment for our Football Department to reassess, strategically recalibrate, and capitalise on the strengths within our i list. With our listās flexibilty, we have the opportunity to control the tempo, and as evidenced, we seemed to win in different ways throughout the year, suggesting flexibilty and composure. Not just wrestling it back to our method. Our squad boasts diverse talents allowing for a dynamic shift in roles. Iām interested in our teams adaptability and allowing us to exploit the identified weaknesses in other contenders strategies and setups. Given the strength of our midfield unit, thereās a decisive advantage to be gained in contested situations. By intensifying our focus on mastering contested ball skills, we can disrupt and dismantle opponent play in critical match scenarios. We will have a new coach with new ideas, I am excited about what strategies and analytics are brought in. Our forward line has the potential to elevate and intensify pressure, forcing critical turnovers and allowing us to capitalize on oppositions errors. We didnāt have the cattle at the right time of year - I think people genuinely forget it. With adept intercept markers, a strategic refinement in our defensive structures will help the ball carrying and ball movement out of the back to try to distrupt defensive structures of other teamsā¦ By leveraging our squad's fitness levels and endurance, which in my view was beyond most other teams, can we continue to secure a competitive edge and dominate even in the closing minutes of the game. Some thoughts around the trends of the game going forward. is the explosiveness and quick ball movement is fine when you have it, and how do you best counteract it - and where do you try to cut it off - particularly if we tend to have lots of repeat inside 50āsā¦ and that seems problematic with the density of the forward line - sure media pundits keep suggesting we bomb it long - as that is the only strategy - but [censored] it, so does every other club - and when it comes off its a great pack mark (see Cox last night) and that could have easily been dropped and rebounded, and thus interpreted as ādumb playā. What strategies are there to employ considering the list that we have. I look forward to some good input over the summer lull.
-
Non-MFC: Finals Week 03
Well done to Collingwood. They snuck through and took their chances. Seems to be the theme of the season for those teams in contention. The industry is so tight, it could have been Us, or GWS into the GF. Not to beā¦ Game day moments matter - like us, GWS would reflect on a few and rue them. Bringing it back to us, overall though, our best is good enough, and to have been in the top 4 for 3 seasons, is an incredible feat, considering how tight the competition is and small the margins of error.
-
Yze replacement
How is Don Pyke relevant these days? * Sorry if that was abrupt , Is he still in the industry?
-
TMac & Brown
Iāll be disengaging, mostly because there is an infinite loop of trying to convince each other that our opinion is the correct opinion, and the other layer of me being sensitive, and you being sensitive to me being sensitive and feeling a need to be a condescending [censored]ā¦ šā¤ļø
-
TMac & Brown
Reread your posts - Itās not asking uncomfortable questions is it? Itās deriding choices made based on assumptions and things that you presumably have no direct knowledge about. Apologies if the previous post was passive aggressive - Iāll be more direct in the future.
-
TMac & Brown
What are your terms and conditions for acceptability in those given circumstances. Now unless you were there, and either a player agent, a list manager, or the player themselves, youāre entitled to an opinion no matter how articulate , but actually have no idea about what got things over the line. have Richmond made an unacceptable list management decision with T Lynch, considering there is a similar trajectory? contributed nothing? Thatās in the eye of the beholder - if you think that football clubs only operate in a vacumn for 2 hours of game dayā¦
-
TMac & Brown
Send in your resume @BaliDemon you seem to have all the answers retrospectively ā¤ļøš
-
Non-MFC: Finals Week 03
A fire in the pit of my gut, or the FDās gut or āshamingā by media pundits or supporters, doesnāt help planning, training and game day outcomes in 2024. we lost 2 finals in 2022 because we were severely depleted by injury. Letās not forget context and lump it all in togetherā¦ sure itās easy to do when youāre disappointed. Happy to be in the minority - just because a majority has a populist view doesnāt mean itās accurate to the specific circumstance- see Trump. Letās agree that we are both disappointed in the outcomes, and we see the factors contributing to it, and what it means about the club, and what to do about it - vastly different. ššš¼
-
Non-MFC: Finals Week 03
I appreciate itās different expectations for all clubs. if you win a premiership then the expectation is that youāll win a few more - ie: Richmond etc. This sounds like your and a few others specific expectation - itās not mine though. For me, itās not nuanced enough analysis. I wonder If those hardcore supporters of the Dogs think they have wasted their generational opportunities - but from other supporters perspectives, has it been wasted? Probably not. Charges sticking like mud? Holy moly Manā¦ different lenses I suppose ššš¼
-
Non-MFC: Finals Week 03
17 teams are ābrokenā every year. there is this weird supporters bollocks of the notion of using loses as fuel ā¦ itās just a sense making tool as a post hoc analysisās about our expectations. anyway lets hope Goodwin decide to review the Collingwood and Carlton matches eh š
-
How do players lose the skill of kicking straight?
@Watson11 sport isnāt a place to relax its a place to have stress and discomfort and still execute. id never ask a client to relax. Thatās not helpful and if you interpret any of my posts over the years that anyone needs to relax then you are misinterpreting me. The problem Is the NEEd to feel relaxed/comfortable/whatever because as soon as you donāt have it - you chase short term comfort (change in technique) at the expense of whatās useful if youāre relaxed, fan[censored]tastic. If youāre not - have the discomfort and execute anyway. Perfect consistent practice doesnāt exist it doesnāt replicate game day stressors, so yes, look inward, get to know your own stories as to why you tighten up and change your technique and then do some good work in that space. all your examples alude to what goes on, the brain shifts itās attention from task to fix issues that donāt actually matter in the moment. From an outsiders perspective it looks like technique - ball drop, bent too far over, spinning ball - theyre all versions of something called experiential avoidance. The desire to avoid unwanted internal experiences - thoughts, feelings and physical sensations. thatās the space the psychs and the athlete do their best work in. have the discomfort and kick āas you wouldā anyway - and then lo and behold - If you kick a goal - you feel good (confidence) and then it comes easier the next timeā¦ knowing that your brain wonāt ever shut up about how much it hurts when you fail or [censored] up or let team mates down or just in case you may embarrass yourself in front of 4 million people watching on tv with this shot you take 25 metres out on a slight angle that any person should kick, but the context of the game means itās reaaaaaaaaaallllly important - thatās the pressure stuff right there.
-
Do the Demons need to do a new football department review?
They have a sports psych Steve Rendell who has been in the industry for years. All good there. Things have moved on significantly since Bills time.
-
How do players lose the skill of kicking straight?
Apologies Iām a š¤
-
How do players lose the skill of kicking straight?
It really is a simple as this. if a player can kick the goal in training, then it means they have the biomechanical and technique means to do so in the game (taking out environmental factors such as wind and rain). the only thing that changes in game day setting is āmeaningā and context about the person that of what does it mean if they fail to kick it. If it is evaluated as a threat, then the brain will āchangeā the biomechanical and technique responses āon the flyā/during the action to have the athlete remain āsafeā. In sports, understanding "meaning" and "context" is pivotal. Athletes excel during training, mastering their biomechanics and techniques for goal kicks. However, on game day, the dynamics shift. Increased pressure and the significance of the moment can alter an athlete's focus. Embracing their emotions rather than resisting them, athletes can stay present and committed to their values and goals, reducing external pressures. This approach enables them to maintain their skills, even when faced with an uncomfortable kick. Often, it is the uncomfortable kicking action in these moments, that is the ācorrectā kick.
- Campbell Brown calls the Melbourne Football Club "fragile"
-
Clarry Act of Sportsmanship against Carlton
That doesn't fit in with the short sighted narrative that you need to be ruthless to win matches/premierships!
- Exit interviews 2023