MudDogs Gawn Win.. someday

Out Jetta? You should be instantly banned from Demonland.

Vince is no where near his best...

The problem Melb has not just in the backline is.. they all fly for the mark.. while their opponents stay down.. I saw T.Mac Tyson & Frost all fly for the same ball in the last qtr.. especially stupid from Tyson.. "What I have learned" is the game is ever quickly moving past both Vince & Tyson.. Tyson more so. (I'm hoping Vince is pushing through that broken toe) But Tyson is SO SLOW!! We might as well play Trengove.

Couldn't agree more. I think only those who were at the game would of actually noticed this..

I think T.Mac didn't have a shocker.. Reiwoldt just had a blinder.. T.Mac still kicked a goal on him and also set up multiple attacks from the wing and half back.. Jack was very good at reading the play and doubling back hard away from T.Mac after he left him to attack, he was caught out when the ball came back with interest and we simply had no one to cover..

I couldn't agree more.. But like the Selection Panel at Melbourne. Most demonlanders are blinded by Modern KPIs and preconceived motions.. More chance of Goodwin backing in his bum chum Jake Melksham to play ruck.

I've given up all hope of Pedersen playing again. Can't wait to see Goodwin go with an Inexperienced Mitch King or Keilty before Pedo.. Rest In (pedo) Peace.

You clearly don't watch many many games do you?

I'm sure a few posters on here will think Richmonds 4-0 is a "cheap 4-0 though"

I would be happy to see Melb trade for Bruest.

Amen! Some sense! Pedo comes in produces more than Hannah and Weid combined and releases Watts to only play fwd.

Thanks Einstein.. I was saying we were able to get two picks inside the top 3 instead of 1.

Take off your eye patch and pure jealousy of a better club. I got what you were implying, I just think it's a ridiculous thing to say.

Did you even see his possessions? He couldn't of kicked it any worse unless was Tony Shaw on injections..

Yeah.. winning a third flag in a row.. something rarely done.. incredibly cheap compared to winning 1 flag in 60 years..

Geeze.. there's being bitter and the there's just being pathetic.. The guy served his time at Melb, played under the worst management of the clubs history still became AA.. Left (which we ended up getting with picks 2&3 with his compo) And you label his premiership "cheap" the fact that you label a premiership cheap when the club we support hasn't been able to achieve since TV was Black and White..

He also averages 0.8 tackles a game (3 tackles in his 7 games .. and is a fish out of water at the moment..) if you actually watched Pedersen in the VFL you would of seen a CHF who can take a mark as well as Ruck and still have 25 touches.. probably more than the Weid has had all year.

Geeze pal.. He only kept Kennedy (best full forward in the comp) goalless.. real cheap.

If you can't see the difference Frost had instead of the nervous fumbling blind Oscar, you just straight up don't watch the game.. and most likely yell "kick it long" & "ball" every minute!

He gets to spots.. but his kicks are at best 50/50 to hit targets.. he put one out on the full yeaterday with no pressure

Out Weikaspissernam Melksham Tyson Hannan IN Hogan Pedersen JKH/Kennedy Hibberd IMO a lot of people are fooled by Tyson irrelevant touches.. he is a slow accumulator who's foot skill are ordinary and too slow to actually use it..

All you idiots calling for Bernie to be dropped probably had your heads up his ass after rd 1 yeah? And had he taken a bounce and kicked a goal from 50 yesterday to win you still would..

Yeah in 3 years time maybe. I think he may stop 3-4 goals a game but is probably costing us 4-5 maybe more..

Couldn't agree more.. seems to be fitter and in tune with the pace of the game now

OUT Gawn Weid/Smith Tyson IN Spencer Pedo Brayshaw.. Pure numbers kept Tyson in the team after Carlton.. but he was useless against the Cats.. Doesn't get to enough contests and his kicking is average. Weid is no good when he has to go man on man and was given a bath because he had the next better defender with Hogan out and Watts having to ruck. Id like to see Brayshaw bounce straight back and be given more time in the midfield! Bring back 2015 Brayshaw!