Mach5

Thats the point I was making. Beware the fool's gold of any staff coming from Hawthorn, Collingwood, Geelong, etc. It's easy to get the job done while the team's has wins coming out its backside and hangers-on are clamouring to get to club events to rub shoulders with legends. Many a coattail ridden in these circumstances. The real work is done at the also-ran clubs, and the pretender-to-contender clubs.

It was probably a point that deserved being made twice anyway.

FWIW I kinda agree with your sentiment, but the way you make the argument is poor

And for gods sake, never have Vince & Lewis in the same team again.

Yes. Roy Morgan might not be infallible, but I wonder what credible source WYL is using as a base for his theory?

A single base for all football and admin staff is sorely sorely needed.

Was it? and is it?

I'll reserve my judgment on this until I hear more, but I will say this... Beware fool's gold. Pert may have experience "growing Collingwood's membership numbers" but it was an issue of converting a largely dormant supporter base into paid up members. MFC is very different proposition, where our much smaller supporter base has a relatively high conversion rate. The experience setting up a new training venue will be valuable, although it may be more difficult without Eddie pulling so many political strings and making use of his conflicting roles to the clubs advantage (Athletics Victoria, for instance).

No consultation.

I think that it is a misrepresentation of the reality, but the man himself said he will not be involved in the decision.

Are you sure he's been endorsed by PJ?

Oh yeah, forgot about this. Saw him on Monday at the G, hobbling through the crowd on crutches. Poor bastard. Looked glum, understandably.

You had one?

Never heard of a player carrying an injury?

Clearly recall seeing him wrench his knee against Carlton. My guess is far from 100%.

Unsure of form, but against the saints last year he was a standout before Riewoldt fell on his shoulder. Hoping he can re-capture that. Confident he'll come close.

A lot of truth to him being a great strategist however.

I wonder how he'd go building a culture and developing a list though. He may be perfect in a Chris Scott getting-handed-the-keys-to-a-Ferrari type situation.

...

Goddamn paywall.

List management is all about crystal ball gazing.

I'm not thinking now - I'm thinking in 3 year's time when Oscar and Lever are in their absolute prime, and although Petty is deserving of being in an AFL team's best 22, we still have him at Casey. I'm thinking ahead. Having said that, he may force us to use Lever on a mid-sized forward, which wouldn't be the worst thing. Still - draft for talent, trade for needs.

Good call, completely forgot the extension! I've just rated Petty highly from day dot, and always expected he'd be frustrated at not getting a chance, with Oscar and Lever, plus Frost as decent back-up (not so much lately). I've anticipated he'll be clearly good enough, but lackin opportunities, so his eventual value will lie in an asset to get missing pieces. Lever's injury may have changed that.

We couldn't ignore Petty when he was still on the board in the draft, but I wonder how long before he starts to think about heading home if he doesn't get the opportunities here. Might be able to get our draft picks back off Adelaide from the Lever deal.

I think the last thing our coaching dept would be judging Hunt's performance on would be volume of possessions. I think his efforts this year have lacked the required intensity and his accountability hasn't been great. These are the things he'll be working on to get his chance at AFL level again.