dazzledavey36

I hope Tmac goes into coaching or a career in media. I could honestly listen to him all day.

Wow never seen someone get triggered quite easy over a comment that has has nothing to do with them. And I am sorry, but point out where anyone on this thread has been derogatory towards a player? Everyone is having a fair discussion without being nasty towards a player or poster. But yet AGAIN you try and make this all about you ya big sook. Some of us are allowed to enjoys who make fine contribution to training reports and are willing to engage in a mature and healthy discussion. Then there's you. Let's not derail this thread please.

Because they haven't seen him properly play. He's a right footer, but he also uses his left foot to get himself out of trouble around stoppage. He is a whole different breed of a ruckman. His upside is scary.

Yep agree 100%

Don't ever change what you do Kev, your reports are articulated and at a measured standard. I anticipate reading your reports at every training session.

Where are you basing his poor kicking at?

Brilliant as always Kevie!

Training gallery https://m.melbournefc.com.au/news/2019-11-15/training-gallery-november-15

@kev martin make it down mate?

Advertise as of 10:30am but out on the track at 9:05am? Seesh... you really do need to get there at 2:30am.

He was officially measured at draft camp at 199cm.

Which Jackson is exactly. So you're already wrong. You've already made a stupid statement not long ago questioning Harley Bennell mental state on the back of no evidence. I'll back our recruitment team any day over some random who clearly has no idea.

What a stupid and silly statement. While we have had some hits with the likes of Davey and Farmer, we've also had some big misses like Weetra, Wonaeamirri, Lawrence, Bennell, Johnstone etc. Bedford is still an unknown so far. Let's keep things in perspective first before we start making silly statements like you've just done.

Back. Goes missing far too often when playing up forward. Snags the odd goal here and there but that's about it.

Spot on.

If he was 26 then i would be all for it. But he will be 30 next year and if we are just bringing him in for depth only then I'd like at Josh Walker who is still only 26 years of age, solid body and someone who has had an impact up forward and back.

We've decided not to pursue Murray.

Can't read the full article, so if anyone is happy to inbox me the actual article that would be great ? https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/teams/melbourne/braydon-preuss-sheds-9kg-as-he-aims-to-form-a-ruck-partnership-with-max-gawn-in-2020/news-story/3c947be3dce4f5ddb15a05d6c1397def

Holy [censored]! Interesting thay Cal Twomey said on one of his program the Kossie Pickett is really firming for our top 10 selection.

It didn't upset me Bob. I have far worse things in life that upsets me. Not old mate captain obvious. Goddard is only telling us what majority of supporters have seen all of 2019 and even when Hogan left, a few on here also had concerns that we were too arrogant as a club to replace Hogan, instead putting all of our eggs in the Weideman (off 2 finals games) and McDonald basket. I still have concerns. While i have been a big supporter of Sam Weideman, he hasn't exactly shown much to suggest he will be a solid AFL player. I actually have more faith in Harry Petty becoming a better forward then Weideman. McDonald I am just not sure If he is capable of being the number 1 forward as of yet. This year he was taking the number one defender and struggled, unlike back in 2018 when he was taking the 2nd best defender. Our key forwards are still a worry. Oh and it's Brendan Goddard, the guy is the biggest sook and whinger the game has seen. Played with a former Essendon rookie last year who said that he was quite disliked by majority of younger to mid players. We dont have to like every player thats played the game Bob...

Tell us something we don't know Goddard ya Pretzel [censored]

Just to be safe you better get there an hour early at 3:30am.

Is Bernie still at the club? Barely heard boo from him?

I don't have mail, but reading recent writes ups and articles seem to point thay we are having serious consideration for Green at 3. I believe Giants are looking for a needs base with Jackson and Young firmly in their sights.

If we bid on Green and GWS don't match then this would be a huge coup for us. Green is rated on level with Rowell and Anderson. The comparisons to Cripps is real. Drums are beating that it's looking more likely we will bid on Green and GWS really considering whether to match or not.