dazzledavey36

Couldn't have said it any better. Oscar is up there with one of the worst players I have ever seen.

Rubbish footballer. Pass. Please don't give me the old he's played in a premiership though. Up there along with few other spuds like Mitch Morton, Mark Blake, Jon Simpkin, Steven Armstrong and many others.

I look at someone like Nick Haynes from GWS and see a lot of similarities to Young in terms of his intercept marking.

Played last few games for Dandy on a wing and definitely looked comfortable in that position.

Can u pm me as well mate.

A player that intrigues me the most on our list. Looking forward to seeing him play a few games.

I have seen nothing of him that remotely screams X factor.

This seriously annoys me. https://m.afl.com.au/news/2019-10-17/blues-ponder-free-agency-swoop-for-saints-wingman

Agree wholeheartedly. You'd think this bloke was an absolute star. Had done nothing in his career to justify the hype. He reminds me of Richard Tambling. Who hasn't got an ounce of hard work in him and will coast through his career on talent alone. Carlton can have this lazy campaigner, suits their culture perfect. Rather focus on the likes of Jack Newnes who would actually add a lot to our side. Or if we are planning on taking risk then do it on Harley Bennell, at least he has shown to be quite elite when on the park. Watched Bennell kicked 6 in a game against Geelong playing as an on baller collecting 27 disposals back in 2014.. Breathtaking talent.

Wouldn't be surprise is Hawthorn are all over him.

Wanted him in his draft year and still want him now.

Here

Looks like he still wants to get to Carlton.

I feel like a developing mature tall that plays forward or back.

One of the very few media person I thoroughly enjoy listening too is plough. He mentioned on Twitter 2020 will be his last year and will retire after that.

Jay Clark reported we are genuinely interested in Martin, but he is content in joining the blues still and could potentially refuse to speak to other clubs. https://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/gold-coasts-jack-martin-is-set-on-joining-carlton-in-the-preseason-draft-despite-genuine-interest-from-melbourne-in-the-star-midfielder/news-story/b7b227115aabcb563ca1a9cc8a607f06

If we had a choice between Billy or JKH then I'm choosing Billy. One of the most professional players at our club and with 2 kids coming through from the draft early on, I wouldn't mind billy taking them both under his wing Clayton Oliver style.

No

You've said this a million times now, we get it, you don't like Ash.

None of this makes any sense.

Let's not get too excited as of yet. Martin has to verbally say he wants to commit to us before he nominates for the pre season draft. He could also be delisted and be picked up as free.agent by the blues.

Sun's could easily just delist Martin and Carlton take him as a delisted free agent.

B- We still lack a genuine key forward. Don't know if i am sold on going with Weideman and McDonald again. The rest I really like though!

You can tell us now @Yokozuna

source?