dazzledavey36

Viney like the 2023 semi final loss to Carlton completely lost his way in the dying moments. When the guy is up for grabs under immense pressure, both Viney and Oliver fail to meet their end of the bargain. They crumble under pressure and Viney is an absolute liability when it comes to close games. Oliver as well. If i had an option between trading out one of Petracca or Oliver, then its Oliver for me. We would be silly not to look at trading Lever as well. Spargo will assess his options at years end. Lucky to get anything for Salem.

So you're pretty much keeping the same band that has gotten us to this absolute mess that we are in now? Oliver needs to go. He was woeful against the Saints and his last 2 minutes in the last quarter summed him up best. He loses all composure when thr going gets tough in high pressure game. The resigning of Viney was one of the biggest botched list management I've seen in a long time. Is happily let him go if we could but unfortunately we're stuck with him. Fritsch can stay but where the hell was he after quarter time?

I'd trafe No.

He suits them perfectly.

North have interest in Lever. Where do I sign? Been a grand servant of this club but his body is absolutely cooked and a cannot remember the last time he played a standout game.

I agree to some extent. We had the list capable winning more then one. But you gotta acknowledge that flags are incredibly hard to win. We should know by now that even making finals is hard enough as it is but getting to the end of the mountain and sticking the flag in is just next level difficult. I actually would have accepted it even in those years had we actually won some finals and contended all the way to preliminary final stage but unfortunately we didn't.. it was straight up two years in a row of straight finals losses.. I can't cop that at all. Inexcusable really.

"Pick one, Melbourne" Jason Taylor: "Coach number 4933721, John Longmire, Fox Footy, Sydney Football Club" "Pick Two, Carlton" ...

Haha.. old mate Macca changing the goal posts and narrative on the run when called out. Funny stuff.

Im guessing that whole process didn't come cheap either..

Its the significant drop in memberships since last year that is clearly telling. Members are clearly voting with their voice.

I dont tired from calling people up who make up and spread lies. You told me to go do my research and I did. My research dating back to the 2020 review which you referenced and again it showed you made it up like you have done plenty of times. To keep facts as facts. Goodwin did NOT get relegated to coach from the bench in 2021 by higher officials. This is a well known fact. I do love how you have had to resurface this discussion once again out of nowhere lol.. clearly got you playing perfectly in your head.

Haha stop making stuff up champ.. We've already put this to bed. You can create whatever fantasy you want but unless youve got proof that states he was officially relegated to coach (which clearly you dont when we have asked numerousof times) from the bench by higher managementthen its all a complete made up story by your good self. As in said a few pages back, take the L and move on.

Was my attempt at humour Byron...

So he says.

In: Sharp, Lever Out: Spargo, Turner

He doesn't need too. I've done it for him No need to lie and make up things and now you look like a [censored] fool because you have been caught out doing so. You said it was done after the 2020 review and I provided evidence that clearly shows that it was never mentioned nor did it happened. So yes, you made it up. Im all for the criticism of Goodwin, but to lie and make things up to suit your narrative is pretty poor. I mean, im not surprised. Take a walk and have a breather mate.

Hey @KozzyCan here's the 2020 review findings. Can you find me the part where its states that Goodwin would be relegated to the bench as per what Macca says here? https://www.melbournefc.com.au/news/833378/club-update-a-letter-from-gary-pert

I think McQualter was meant to be his replacement but that was obviously short luved. Even in his role as our midfield stoppage coach last year, he didn't exactly set the world on fire i. That area. Our mids fell apart last year.

I have done my homework. You made it up like you always do. He didn't get relgated champion. It was part of his personal choice as part of what I had already mentioned. He was back in the box at the start of the year and initially part of that plan for 2025 was to alternate in between but that fwll on its sword due to the early season losses. Its okay to L and move on.

Imagine leaving Byron Bay to play for a rabble. Stay where you are Joey and enjoy retirement.

Agree. But after Yze, hes still on the bench..

Where was he told this? Unless you can provide quotes, Goodwin has been on record to say that it was his personal choice to be on the bench as he gets to engage with the players and provide direct feedback and instruction on the spot.