dazzledavey36

Petty plays the lock down just fine?

Yeah can't say I agree with the team selections to be honest. Hope we are not playing with fire. Really thought Jordon would be still in and Sparrow out. Though Sparrow did have 7 tackles. Problem is also the imbalanced of the midfield. Dropping Jordon takes away outside spread where as now we are just too one dimensional with Viney back in. Backing Goody with this one but [censored] I'm extra nervous now.

Hibberd dropped

Hibberd dropped

No j agree. Just know the club rate Smith enormously and would be finding ways to fit him in.

Yep I agree!

Wonder if they'll pull a surprise selection? Dropping Hibberd for May instead of Joel Smith?

Don't know where to get that stat from.

Let's be honest, it's really a pipe dream anyway (it is for me..). Parker just strengthens our midfield to another level. Jacob Hopper would be someone I'd look at as well.

Well that's incorrect mate.. His kicking efficiency this year alone is higher then Petracca and Viney and on par with Oliver's. So realistically he becomes one our better ball users in the midfield. Currently averaging 27.8 disposal per game and has kicked 15 goals so far. So a goal kicking mid. Petracca has kicked 24 goals this year. Next best midfielder is Oliver with just 7. An All Australian mid and a 2 time best and fairest winner (won it in a year they played in a grand final mind you ).

I'm in the Luke Parker boat. We would be crazy if the club weren't at least having the discussion. Really think he's exactly what we need to bring something different to our midfield mix. Would bring experience, leadership and great standards on and off field. I'd rather my starting midfield as Petracca, Oliver and Parker, instead of Petracca, Oliver and Viney.

Was having this same debate with another Melbourne supporter friend of mine. My argument was that imo Tomlinson is now depth for me. Not only has Petty fitted in the role seamlessly, but his intercept marking and reach has really impressed me alongside his defensive work. With the consistency of games that Petty has been able to play now I expect this will only give him great confidence heading into next year. A bigger and more fitter Petty excites me. The other aspect is Tomlinson might not be ready to play come round 1? If we go off the 12 month recovery period then it's fair to say he'll miss first couple of rounds into next season and then have to go through VFL to push his claim once again. Good depth player to have though.

Not entirely sure Jason Taylor and co rated Stephens all that highly. I remember a podcast he did with Cal Twomey right before the 2019 draft and he reeled off a bunch of names that were in our sights such as Jackson, Green, Young, Serong, Ash, Kemp, Weightman and Pickett. Stephens wasn't mentioned nor was there really any talk of the Dees being interested at the time.

Not according to this if this report comes becomes reality..

How so?

I'd trade Steven May for him.

Just watched the injury report and seems McDonald and May only need to get through tomorrow main training session to play on the weekend.

I think it's 50/50. Their game plan was always built on the chip around style and overwork teams. Certainly helped his short 15m passes. But I think this is also been his natural game well before simmo came on board. Simmo just strengthened it even further.

This has been a significant part of Gaff's game for a long time. He simply has no hurt factor and as Garry Lyon said, it's also been part of his natural game for a long time. 32 disposals for only 284m gained is not good numbers for a wingman of his calibre. The game plan itself is outdated and ordinary.

There was some footage on Gaff last night from On The Couch. It was pretty damming to say at least. Little 15m chip backwards that resulted in no forward thrusts. If anyone can get the footage that would be helpful.

That's blatantly not true at all.

I was shocked how well Lynch moved on the weekend. Just remember we did show considerable interest a few years back...

No.