joeboy

May - better after first Gawn - no votes today Chandler. - strong running game Rivers - often an observer Petracca - important but limited Fritsch - seemingly without passion Salem - just a plodder Oliver - couldn’t handle tag Lindsay - needed more involvement Johnson - replace with Roo Pickett - unfortunately well held Melksham - little drive today Turner - a solid game McVee - not his best Langford - looking very tired Windsor - poor under pressure Langdon - untypically quiet game Sharp - Viney obviously replaces Sparrow - little involvement again Bowey - little defensive drive Petty - limited contesting effect Lever - liability in defense Laurie - made no difference

Pickett - genius at work Gawn - great without dominating Salem - cool under pressure Oliver - getting more involved Langdon - great team ethos Petracca - exciting when needed Rivers - great tagging game Lindsay - beautifully smooth mover Chandler - had little involvement Fritsch- just some cameos McVee - reliable and steady Bowey - becoming a weapon Turner - impressive first half Langford - everything with ease May - little to do Lever - needed the run Melksham - no heroics necessary Petty - generally competed well Spargo - little impact again Sharp - took his chances Sparrow - played his role Johnson - an almost game

Slightly off topic but relevant for those who’ve been harangued or abused by opposition supporters: Some years ago we were playing the Magpies and as inevitability has it, I was surrounded by evil opposition supporters. I’m pretty sure we were being trounced so when I made a negative comment aloud about a Collingwood player all hell broke loose. A Collingwood player , Lockyer, was awarded a free kick and without hesitation I called out, ‘ get a real name Tarquin ‘(his actual first name ) I thought it was a pretty harmless request, but fists were raised in my direction not to mention the profound umbrage and verbal aggression that spewed forth . At a quiet moment I let myself out😱

You forgot: 3 votes / Carlton C… Judd

I actually DID add it but it’s appeared on a repeat thread: Some important involvement

Gawn - beast at play Pickett - please never leave Langdon - great second half Salem - rarely wasted disposals Melksham - genius at work Rivers - impressive all game Petracca - dominant second half Oliver - amazing tagging game Bowey - maintained impeccable form Lindsay - mature beyond years McDonald - another outstanding performance Langford - great second half Sparrow - great tagging performance May - reminiscent of yesteryear McVee - efficient and effective Petty - competed with courage Spargo - didn’t effect result Fritsch - found his position Windsor - surprisingly poor disposal Sharp - didn’t take chances Johnson - justified soccer training Turner - some valuable involvement

Time to be proactive and try to win the match: Turner forward and Petty back. Fritsch on for Spargo

On paper, the currently listed setup must be the shortest forward line EVER

Will our sponsors be willing to reinvest in a team that has limited exposure?

Hawthorn - most hatable players Umpires - consistently proven incompetent Fitness staff - seemingly non existent Gawn - couldn’t dominate enough Pickett - regularly overran ball Bowey - continued to excel Langford - exciting and brave Petracca - prolific without hurting McVee - loose and careless Windsor - great until last Turner - wasted in defense Langdon - few positive possessions May - tried but limited Rivers - seemingly going backwards Spargo - waste of space Chandler - very limited performance McDonald - continued impressive year Sparrow - rarely noticed again van Rooyen - disappointed yet again Sharp - some limited disposals Lindsay - was rarely noticed Oliver - not a tagger Fritsch - continued being irrelevant Jefferson - just an amateur Tholstrup - limited game time

Not much to disagree with there

From the horses mouth, just now. The Ox’s son, who is 20, has no interest in pursuing AFL football 🤦‍♂️😱😰

Gawn - continues to astound Viney - wonderful tagging performance Petracca - creative and impressive Chandler - excellent second half Turner - versatile and valuable Langford - prolific without dominating Rivers - reliable and safe Windsor - not convincing defensively Pickett - surprisingly limited output Langdon - better second half Bowey - not as convincing Melksham - experience was everything Tholstrup - little to admire McDonald - continued to impress Spargo - had little involvement Salem - was rarely convincing May - limited but important Fritsch - almost invisible again McVee - will get better Lindsay - steady and reliable Sparrow - was rarely noticed Sharp - one clever goal Petty - quiet before injury