DistrACTION Jackson

I do have to question the decision making of our overall selection panel when we have a generational key forward and we choose a journeyman over him. I don't want to see JVR out of this side ever again unless he is injured or needs an actual rest, not to go and play in a wet game down at Casey.

Actually that's not enough. Chandler out, AMW in.

If we don't reward good form in the VFL after that performance I am going to be ropeable. Get your head out of your a$$ Goodwin and ensure there are repercussions for poor form. In: Woewodin, Oliver & van Rooyen Out: Harmes, Smith & Fritsch Chandler & ANB lucky because we literally have no other small forward options.

We have now lost 4 games in the wet and one of the issues is we have a lot of below average skilled players and these guys are found out in bad conditions. ANB, Langdon, Hunter, Trac, Viney (loved his game but still terrible skills), Pickett (he is highly skilled but wtf was that). I am so frustrated watching this side, it is just the worst gamestyle to watch.

Realistically, what tall forward options are there available? Himmelberg & Georgiades? Neither are really a big key forward and play more the 2nd or third tall, maybe less so Himmelberg.

I was impressed with him from what I watched of Casey on the weekend. Think he will be a player.

Interesting this has come up after a game in the wet, when I thought they dominated the game v Collingwood and were a key part of the reason we won. Definitely not worried about this, but I do believe Max is a better option both forward and behind the ball rather than in the centre square.

I'm really not sold on him coming into our side, given he is a liability when the ball hits the deck. We always have a 200cm bloke down there already so not sure we need two.

Agree. We played our best late in the first through to 3 quarter time, when it was raining.

If Smith drops off then I'd move Petty forward and play Tommo back. But I like what he brings when the ball hits the deck, so happy to give him another 2 weeks to show this.

In regards to team changes I think we need to look at the following: - Bowey to come back in to improve foot skills out of the backline - Salem & Kozzy to spend a bit more time through the middle to improve our kicking inside forward (why did we stop using Kozzy there?) - Oliver hopefully back and chomping at the bit - Gawn to play 70% forward/back and Grundy to ruck the majority of the game (Gawn is a much better mark around the ground and forward and Grundy is better in centre bounces with his mobility and ground work) - I would say Petty forward and Tommo back but hard to drop Smith after last week.... though not sure why we dropped Tommo either so who f'ing knows B: Bowey May Lever HB: Salem Petty McVee C: Langdon Oliver Hunter HF: ANB van Rooyen Pickett F: Fritsch Gawn Chandler R: Grundy Petracca Viney Int: Rivers Sparrow Smith Brayshaw Sub: Jordon

For $500k.

But how about we play it at the MCG every now and then AFL.... that might be nice

Not really related to the game last night, which I was at btw and was so flat after..... But I'd like to see us get on board with the retro round theme given it's the two oldest clubs and bring out new jumpers for that game.

Apparently we are also training with different dimensions of the field this week as well....

It's unfathomable to me that De Goey got three for a late, high pump that was vicious and Mansell get's the same for a split second decision to brace for contact and protect himself.

The Mansell appeal is going now apparently. I really hope he gets off, there's literally nothing else players can do in this situations other than pulling up and not actually going for the ball.

Got a ticket with my mate, first time going down to the Cattery for a Dees game.... hope we can somehow get the win!

Yeah agreed. Not sure what the outrage is. He clearly slung him into the ground and could've let go once he knew the momentum was heading towards the ground. The Mansell one I absolutely hate, similar to Hunter. Mansell was a micro second off getting the ball and Aish should've had more awareness as well and protected himself. The MRO/Tribunal have to start every assessment by determining is this action actually a reportable offence, not just saying oh Aish's headband flew off and he was concussed so we better suspend him.

haha there's a 10 year old girl giving one.... amazing

Trac said in his interview they are back tomorrow I think.

He's definitely a bust as a top 3 pick, but if you can pick him up as a delisted free agent or for a late pick it would be a smart option for depth. Dunstan will probably be delisted after this season.

Feels like an all or nothing game for Carlton tonight. They will either rise to the challenge and make a contest, or they could be completely overwhelmed and loser by 70 points.... time will tell.

I'd be interested to hear if anyone hits a target under a small amount of pressure and if a forward leading to mark the ball isn't impeded by his own team?

I get why the media hate this.... but tbf I think a young player would just be happy to be getting a game even if it is as sub.