SPC

Who would you pick over him?

2 things.. 1. We have blokes shirking the contest, not Viney.. Oliver and Kozy trying to flick the ball and not put their body behind it.. 2. Gee we play a horrible brand of footy.. can’t sell memberships with this crap

We need to change the midfield mix. I think Oliver, Harmes and perhaps a Salem or throw Pickett in. Keep Viney forward, Trac HFF and Brayshaw can have time forward as well. It is not our strength, it is our greatest weakness now, both in ball winning ability, pressure and disposal.

Yes.. close thread

Honestly who care. We won’t beat GWS and the Bombers will [censored] us!!

Work around contests is as bad as I’ve seen

Appreciate the tread to understand from a sliding doors perspective, just as long as we are not smug about St Kilda’s luck with McCartin.. We have butchered more drafts picks than we have got right in the last 15 years.

I love Jack, but his monotone voice made it impossible to watch. A very boring Open Mike.. Agree with others, a lot of questions missed.

A shout out the backline, Rivers, May, Salem and Lever.. excellent as a unit. Strong in the contest and great ball use. Lucky to win with an average showing from the midfield. But the forwardline- what they hell!! Vanders, horrible. Melksham, horrible. Hannan, yuck! Need to find a better mix forward of the ball. Harmes, Fritter and Maybe Hunt, Baker or Bedford to come in. One thing worth a try is Preuss ruck, Max forward in replacement of Brown.

Langdon keeps us in games as much as May.. his pressure and ground coverage is exceptional

Jones career is done tonight

I thought he was over the top biased towards us tonight.. could hardly control his excitement

No change

Gee Adelaide have had some high tackles paid

Have Brayshaw and Bennell touched it

Langdons a good player

I agree, the umps need to stamp out the pushing after a free kick.. it’s pathetic

I like the notion of moving some players around.. Salem into the midfield. Hannan back to HBF. Bring in Bedford into the forwardline. Maybe try Smith forward. We need to re-invigorate the team.. I would move out any player who doesn’t apply defensive pressure- looking at you Brayshaw and TMAC

Good interview, got some skills the lad

Worst thing is.. this is it.. no high end talent waiting to come in, nothing to look forward to.. this is our best team!! Pathetic

Let’s never play a 3 tall forward structure again.. TMAC needs another week off

Lever, May, Lockhart, Sparrow, Trac.. the rest [censored] off!!

Tom mac is a [censored] footballer

Oliver and Brayshaw can go at years end.. one cant kick, one can’t chase

Only Jackson looks likely up forward..