DubDee

Why isn't Frost a RFA? he has played 8 seasons

I reckon Corey is worth another look for sure. he is ~21yo and runs all day. has plenty of mongrel in him too suspect his older brother might be in trouble though. he has not come on in the past 2 years

Mixed feelings with Frosty, he finally began to play some consistent footy but it must be hard to play a system when you have a headless chook back there. Which is why I am baffled as to why the hawks would want him, high possession, kicking team. smacks of desperation from Clarko. he needs to go back to the draft but he might be too stubborn Frosty is a good B grade type player but we can't be paying guys like him big wages or we'll be screwed soon. so if he goes, he goes.

Is Frosty a RFA?

Fantastic to get him for free. he is worth an early second rounder i reckon. hasnt been able to play in his best position on the wing due to GWS's talent. We desperately need run and spread so no idea what people are on about saying he doesnt address a need just turned 26yo, 136 games. exactly what our young list needs. and at 6'4" can fill KP gaps if needed Tomlinson and Langdon on the wings make us a much better team. they are not stars but they are what we need

I like the look of Flandersisis at number 10 not just for the simpsons joke opportunities. big body, mid and fwd. if we split pick 3 he's the type we might get

no-one suspect the man hiding in the bin

true but 5 rising star nominations shows how pointless those noms are

righto Viney won the BnF in 2016 and deserving of co-captaincy in 2017 imo. unfortunately he's had couple of years of injuries and no preseason. he put a full year together finally this year (although didnt play great footy) and with a preseason we will see our inspirational leader back next year. Max would not be the player he is today if he was weighed down by captaincy in 2017/2018 imo

So West Coast will add Tim Kelly to their midfield of Yeo, Gaff, Shuey, Sheed, Masten, Nic Nat, Lewis. their fwd line is the best in the league: Kennedy, Darling, Ryan, Rioli, Cripps. not to mention their defence! if they win the flag this year - they have zero injuries so I reckon they are a chance, they would easily go 3 in a row I've been a critic of Nic Nat over the years but he was amazing last night. inspirational

you would have preferred Jones as sole captain this year? wow

Thanks for your service Todd. You have been part of taking us from a basket case to a club capable of on-field success Loves the club, his house is often littered with young demons looking for a feed I agree it is good timing to part

Merrett and Parish being show up for the soft players they are. Bombers team has talent but no strength/leadership to stand up in finals. The worst recent record in finals of all teams suck on that bombers fans

Pass the popcorn too early to text bombers fans??

Coke versus Peptides - which wins? The Demons taking a chance on Ketamine didn't work this year

100 Point + win to West Coast would be sweet. Woosha sacked and essendon crocked. please make it happen!

Up the Dubs!!! have to say i feel for Mayo - my mam is from castlebar and they have been in so many all ireland finals and never won it. I would be wrapped if they won it one year

Yeah let's follow Adelaide's terrific example of leadership Maybe listen to commentary of the Prelim loss to WC while blind-folded on a bus too? FMD

I'd be surprised if J Smith doesnt request a trade

so still only 2 blokes delisted?? all exit interviews would be had by now yeah?

Read the latest article on the MFC website - he said he hasn't done a preseason for 3 years. not that they were interrupted, that he didnt really have one any year. what happened 3 years ago you ask? he won the BnF he is a champ

Thought this thread was about Carlton for a second

With Jonesy pretty sure to retire at the end of next year, our next most experienced player is Melksham with 168 games! gives a good indication of the lack of senior experience in the team

Centre square: Gawn, Oliver, Viney, Brayshaw (rotation, Harmes, Trac, Milkshake) Wings: Langdon, Salem, (back-up: Baker, KK - hopefully he can make a come back) a pretty good group imo but we need depth/more outside talent

easily fixed. pre-season camp anyone??!?