Demonsone

Disaster was not playing him…. Should still be there

More frustration than anything .. overall recruiting has been great yielding us premiership defence & late pics turned into gems…BB lasted 1/2 a season before succumbing to knee issues….our last recognised gun forward was Neitz who retired in 08 .. Hogan could have been the one but… not sure why we can’t find them

Issue we have Petty & Melksham both injured & the latter want be back until late in the season, Tmac & BB it’s gone passed them & if they can get on the ground, so what’s left Shache… that’s right he was better than Grundy …. either we’re just not a destination clubs or our recruiting & coaches are asleep at the wheel

Liam Henry to the saints …. We are so proactive in reinvigorating the list with thus far a ruckman who couldn’t get a game at the lions…. What’s their strategy … Cleary front half issues yet virtually zero trades ….

If people are thinking that Tmac who can hardly turn, BB who’s knee is shot, Melksham who want play until end of season with knee reco, Petty wit foot issue.. enough said

Somehow pies are adding to their fwd line stocks with talent eg schaultz yet what we doing hoping that our injury riddled fwds of BB, Tmac, Petty , Melksham .. I’d be surprised if any get on the park & backed up with young Jvr .. Fullerton who can’t get a game at the lions will get us through honestly we have our heads buried in the sand

Great apart from our draft improvements ti get young talent our Fwd solution working wonderfully unbelievable… another trade period of achieving sweet f@@@ all to improve our list..looking at the other top 4 teams what they brought in over the last 2-3 trades to improve what have we done since our flag in 21 ?? Expecting Tmac & BB to be our key fwds

So Grundy trade wasn’t? Having Shache as a sub to cover if Gawn went down really…

Agree with Oliver & Petty.. I’d like the club to comment on the whole Grundy disaster in particular Goodwin 360 in him & what went wrong …will be egg on his face if Grundy succeeds at the Swans even more so if they happen to win a flag!

Agree our trades prior to 2021 flag were great but last 2 seasons have bee misses , let’s hope 2023 brings in talent

My question was around trades on ready made talent eg pies brought bobby hill, mcstay , lions got Dunkley etc ours have been disastrous

2 drafts since the 21 flag, which trade deals have improved our list? 2021- Dunstan x 5 games retired 2022- Grundy gone, Schache x 2 games , Hunter only player getting a regular game… How has our list improved comparing this to Collingwood & Brisbane??

It’s amazing his both Tmac & BB are on our list, With continued injuries, respect they are premiership players but what can they add in our shrinking window.. what’s even more concerning if we don’t end up drafting an establish fwd whilst watching the filth get Shultz

What’s our status of drafting atm on a fwd as to date not hearing much with all of our talls with ongoing injury issues.. all we have done is strengthened the Swans with Grundy & Jordan & they also got Adams, Harmes is gone also …who are our back up mids as we have Gus with concussion issues & a well documented other one, understanding they have cleared a fair bit of cap space. With our fwd line consisting of brown, t Mac & petty all with injuries… let’s hope something is done

Wy did they give away 14,27,35 for 11 … must be working on a trade offer?

Is there a method to the madness by Lamb ??? It seems we have been shafted by the Swans getting Grundy for pick 46 after we gave pick 27!for him …. They also got JjJ & Adams from the pies for pick 33, & we lost harmes for pick 30 …what ever trades we do will name or break us & if no genuine fwd is gotten it will be another flopped trade to go along with the 22 draft

Pies won a flag with Miecheck

Love the reaction …. Let’s c what happens

Hanging out for a fwd yet the filth are going to get Schultz from freo.., what is our club doing apart from letting JJ, Harmes & Grundy go????

It sounds great but need to keep this in house, as will cop the bs from them continuously if we lose

Not a huge fan of what he said … sure say we can match it with the best etc but don’t give the filth opportunity to come back as they are plastering thus all over social media & the pies are going to town on him & the club

Unfortunately his comments at the B&F re the filth have made it on social media…. The filth will use as motivation

Both played a pivotal role in our premiership, unfortunately injuries have impacted their ability, loosing 2 kpp is tough & should be treated with respect as premiership players …club though still needs to make tough decisions to maximise the whatever window is left to win a flag…

Compare that to Collingwood last 5 in Melbourne vs 2 road trips for all the other 7 finalists! Afl do deals with the so called bigger clubs .. until you play each other twice continue to expect a shafting & god knows the draw the pies will get next season

Club needs to clear the air of the Grundy saga as many unanswered question what went wrong & why he wasn’t played.. just can’t be swept under the carpet! look at what the pies brought in from the 22 trade vs us, there are ur answers