Demonsone

Lost Brayshaw now Trac and Oliver isn’t righ also, that’s 3 of our top 5 picks

Agree somewhat but top ups should be improving and didn’t address the first straight exits in 2 seasons, why let Jordan go we knew what we had vs Billings & Brayshaw was always a danger of retiring our fwd issues not addressed, yet playing JVR ruck instead of sitting at FF ti develop, were not winning clearances so use Petty etc

Have drafted vfl players billing’s, Fullerton, schache, mcaddam time will tell & Humter best days are past him, this isn’t topping up your list to win another flag & not keeping Jordan… I grant it our recruiters have done well finding late picks and turning them into gems but the last 2 yrs have been poor

It’s baffling our best young forward Jvr who can clunk marks & kick well yet getting flogged in the ruck! Rather see Pertty or Turner ruck, what’s the difference we loose clearances each week!

So he’s gifted games cause he’s won B &F , Cleary not fit enough & out of form .. he’s no different to any other player.

What ever Oliver issues were or still are which forced him to miss preseason, why was he not made to play @ Casey to build he’s fitness & form, in particular from a culture point of view

That window has closed and list hasn’t improved by bringing in spuds, game plan has gotten worse, just making up numbers if we make finals

North playing well as per their game v the pies Not sure what we are , either do the players, Jvr will request a trade as he’s not a ruckman! Oliver playing why? cringe at next week v the lions,

Only one who looks like a fwd who can take a mark & he did & kicked a goal, why his he getting wasted in the ruck

Petty is a premiership defender, Goodwin is destroying his career

Our only genuine forward JVR and when left takes a grab, why is he wasted in the ruck! Oliver is no were near it, Langdon not sure what he does anymore. The continue fumbles and kicking fwd with 2 v 1, too dlow and why players don’t attack the free space in front of them, Fritsch needs a rocket. msking up number if they play finals & will get flogged vs the lions

Not sure why Oliver is getting game time, sure he’s getting tagged but any other would have been dropped, perhaps that’s the issue, did he earn his spot after a poor preseason?

Im not in denial and have my head buried in the sand that our club has botched up the last 2 trades with spuds & given away players with taken for a bag of chips

I do but we had no control in losing him

Good to see Bedford, Jordan & Grundy doing well …

He’s not the only coach, I can think of another who’s lost 4 finals & straight sets exit at the G

Watch us get smashed next week, all the contenders have power fwds vs defenders trying to be fwds!

You look at the power fwds at the blues & many other clubs and apart from JVR our last genuine fwd was Hogan who had his own issues & prior to that Neitz who retired in 08!

That’s what the commentators said

Last 5 Coleman medalists in these 2 sides enough said

The last point is critical! Premiership teams bring in players who will improve the list, look at what they got in 22/23 and the majority were not getting games at their previous clubs, except for Hunter who can’t kick! Billings another one, Shache god help us, Fullerton who?? Mcadam jury is still out

So who is responsible for this down turn, game plan, coaches eg Mcquallter, Goodwin, player driven..

So who is responsible for this disaster??

Silence is deafening from our club

I did ready & correct, but to give up on this from both Goodwin was way too early, was the risk vs reward thought through?? It falls at the feet of the goody & the coaches