Demonsone

Longmire 1 x flag 3 x GF losses host of finals a lot more though 13 seasons vs 8, need to look deeper at their recruiting the Swans getting older players is excellent and highlights their quality recruiters/ list mgrs … not sure what Taylor & Lamb strategy has been since 21 as our u23s are great but scratch your head at the older players traded in and what we let go… Is this Goodwin doing???

Longmire 1 x flag 3 x GF losses host of finals a lot more though 13 seasons vs 8, need to look deeper at their recruiting the Swans getting older players is excellent and highlights their quality recruiters/ list mgrs … not sure what Taylor & Lamb strategy has been since 21 as our u23s are great but scratch your head at the older players traded in and what we let go… Is this Goodwin doing???

They drafted well & we helped them with Grundy & Jordan .. based on our 2 yrs of bringing spuds in .. it’s comical

Goodwin 8 seasons for finals in 18, 21 , 22 & 23 .. results 1x flag 2 finals is in 18 & straight sets 22&23… strategy after the flag resulted in trading in spuds & letting young talent, fwd issues remain & the ruck wit Gawn playing on 1 leg, the handling of Oliver, injuries aside who’s responsible? Footy dept needs a shake up & recruiters, who do you replace Goodwin with?

Goodwin & Co have managed to unravel this team & slam the premiership window shut, the disastrous trades over the last 2 seasons with list cloggers sitting @ Casey, whilst losing Jordan & Harmes, the ruck situation after having Jackson & Grundy,Goodwin conceding we have no other rucks worthy whilst Gawn is playing on 1 leg is a joke! Footy dept needs a review of what’s occurred and a clean out of coaches & the list cloggers! I have carried on about the pathetic trades but this is what successful multiple premiership teams eg tigers, cats , hawks do, they improve theirs not weaken them!

Shut! Failed to trade decent talent to grab another flag! The situation playing max hurt & yet no other back up ruck! Casey filled with spuds from other teams

Shut! Failed to trade decent talent to grab another flag! The situation playing max hurt & yet no other back up ruck! Casey filled with spuds from other teams h

Cats had already won 2 flags & still in a premiership window playing finals … we have gone 0-4 finals wins & no finals

What’s occurred since our flag is a disastrous failure & Goodwin can’t hide from it 0-4 final loses & no finals in 24, pathetic trades who can’t get a senior game! No worthy Ruck other than Gawn playing on 1 leg! Game plan, centre clearances/ mids = Mcqualter failure

Sums up his performances minus since 21 have been poor … not sure what strategy is & confusing 1 over 2 or 1 ruck & our mids getting smashed , failed to trade any decent marquee player of any position .. needs to be moved on

Good question to as Mcqualter & Goodwin our once feared mids are nothing

Mcqualter is destroying our mids

Somehow they found a way to load up with spuds who are at Casey’s for a team in a premiership window, it’s as if they wanted to push this team off the clif with the dumbest trades and boot out an All Australian ruckman in Grundy & watch Gawn play on 1 leg … it’s a comedy show & amateur hour from our coaches & recruiters

What a joke we have become.. very sad and as usual the typical mfc cliff has arrived

Why do you think Dogs got rid of him?? Poor due diligence by our club which is unbelievable as common knowledge..first hand knowledge

A thorough review of the footy & recruiting dept is needed on the drafting of these experienced players who have brought virtually zero a team who WERE in a premiership window vs what’s walked Jordan, Harmes, Grundy, would love to hear them explain the strategy around this??

That 94 team fwd line of Lyon, Schwartz, Charles, jackovich injured, pike, Then Stynes, Tingay, Lovell , Lovetts, Neitz, etc etc the most talented team not to win a flag

I had this infection in my leg it’s not great as it spread & was out of action for 4-6 weeks

Yeah we lost quality but it shouldn’t disguise the real issues of our coaches/game plan, poor drafting and what’s we have lost and exposed our ruck & mids, a review is needed on our list mgt & new assistant coaches

We are cooked and disappointing, but only hope we can knock out the pies from playing finals

Reality is how Hawthorn have won more games than us and the dogs have turned it around! The blow torch needs to go onto Goodwin and his assistants as something is clearly wrong with our game plan and our smashing of clearances all season, a review of our footy dept including the horrible trades of what’s come in vs what we let go

It’s baffling how hawthorn could possibly have won more games than us considering the top 4 finishes and our list demographic, how the dogs have turned their season around, something is seriously not right from our game plan & list mgt! Can’t see us beating the dogs at Marvel

Not sure what ur point is?? We also should be angry at the missed opportunities and were we currently stand …

Dogs will take 8th spot & will smash us next week …our season was over when we lost by 90 points to Freo..

Don’t buy that sure Brayshaw & Trac are hard to replace but leaving the front door open and not defending goal side is defence 101.. Mcqualter is responsible for this, it just continues to happen in most games …