Comparisons are odious especially re Clarrie and Tulip. Oliver is a contested beast inside mid, Robbie was an artist on the outside. They are both equally great, in their own way.
Lets not forget Max - will be a 5 time AA and quite possibly AA captain this year. I’m not sure any other ruckman has achieved as much.
The excuse/explanation is that he is knackered by the time he gets to shoot for goal. His brand is high octane and it is remarkable that he is so durable that he rarely misses games.
I think Sparrow’s 7 tackles saved him. Like you I am underwhelmed but then I have been by Chunks form this season as well - particularly his inability to chase and tackle.
Sparrow and Vanders have a lot in common - hard at it but caught with ball too often and turns it over. Sparrow is a better kick when in the clear but most of his disposals are under pressure.
Goodwin in his presser confirmed that May, TMac an Viney will play. He also mentioned Jones playing well in the Casey game ? Significance.
In: May TMac Viney Jones
Out: Melksham Sparrow Smith Jordon.