CHF & CHB For Round 1?

[Billy Baxter 0]

Two very very important key positions that need filling and I'm somewhat nervous about these two in particular. Obvioulsy if Rivers is ok, that solves the CHB problem, but who is going to rise above it at the other end. Dutchy? Has performed well there in the past or Miller, who in reality, the jury is still out with???

Comments please?

Is my nervous tension over these two positions valid or can someone ease my pain???

BB

[Bring-Back-Powell 14,833]

As much as I'd love Rivers there at CHB, the general consensus around here is that he'll be lining up for Sandy this weekend.

Holland - CHB

Miller- CHF

My defence would be:

Frawley on Mark Williams

Carroll on Roughead

Bell on Buddy Franklin

Holland on Tim Boyle

Wheatley to help out as well.

My attack would be:

Miller chasing marks between 60-80 mtrs from goal

Neitz and Robbo staying close to goal

Juice to hang around 35-50.

Davey to play most of game as our crumber (due to Bate and Sylvia missing)

Yze to hang around the goals as well. The defence experiment has failed in my book.

If our defence is getting caned (highly likely) Miller is to go back and Holland could possibly go foward (ala 2004 and late last year)

My major request is for Bailey to urge these boys to bloody kick the thing long at all costs. We have no ability to play the handball game.

[Gouga 569]

I can't see Holland being picked this week. Shouldn't be on the list imo (but that is an argument for another thread).

Assuming Rivers does not play.

Bell - Williams

Carroll - Roughead

Dunn/Frawley - Franklin

Wheatley - Boyle

I originally thought Frawley was our only option for Franklin but another poster has made a good point about Dunn. Perhaps that is worth a go first with Frawley or Miller in reserve?

[Jaded No More 68,915]

Holland - CHB

Miller- CHF

It's as if I've died and gone to hell

[Jarka 767]

It's as if I've died and gone to hell

I hear ya Jaded

[Bring-Back-Powell 14,833]

It's as if I've died and gone to hell

Any other suggestions

This is why I'm so pessimistic about Sunday.

[Mousey 47]

Firstly i dont understand the whole thing about playing Rivers in Sandy instead of putting him in the side when he is healthy. Maybe i would go down this avenue if i thought our defense was fantastic but it isnt! Why play him at sandy where he can get injured anyway!

He is needed more than anyone on our list especially playing the Hawks!

Dream- CHB- Rivers

CHF- Dunn

If rivers cant get up-

I say throw Frawley in the deep end and stick him on buddy, if it doesnt work, it doesnt work. Like i said we dont have much options if rivers does not get up

[Jaded No More 68,915]

Any other suggestions

This is why I'm so pessimistic about Sunday.

I'd rather Frawley at CHB and Dunn at CHF. Seeing Dutchy line up at CHB, is just going back instead of moving forward.

Miller at CHB is an option, but he most definitely should not go anywhere near Buddy.

I also don't mind the suggestion of Dunn on Franklin.

[Jerry Lundergard 420]

I can't see Holland being picked this week. Shouldn't be on the list imo (but that is an argument for another thread).

Assuming Rivers does not play.

Bell - Williams

Carroll - Roughead

Dunn/Frawley - Franklin

Wheatley - Boyle

I originally thought Frawley was our only option for Franklin but another poster has made a good point about Dunn. Perhaps that is worth a go first with Frawley or Miller in reserve?

I like the look of this set up the best.

Frawley did a pretty good job on on Jarred Waite last year, who has similar athleticism. But the reality is, if Buddy gets enough good supply, he will destroy us.

[drdrake 3,163]

Rivers will play at CHB and Miller at CHF

[timD 994]

Be interesting...if we can choke the midfield (not that we've shown that much to this point), then buddy become less and less effective. He is a good player on the lead - not a pack marker yet. Wouold not be surprised if whoever plays onhim pushes off a lot - maybe even Bruce. Before people report me to the mental health services, remember that bruce has played marker roles before and done well, particularly on players like johnson (dogs) and Burton (adeliade).

[Yze_Magic 3]

CHB - Rivers

CHF - Matty Bate

[Jerry Lundergard 420]

CHB - Rivers

CHF - Matty Bate

Is Bate going to be right to play?

[Guest Schtacker]

Is Bate going to be right to play?

no he's not and neither is Rivers. this is the point of the thread. what is wrong with you YM?

nobody can take Franklin he will kick 10 unless we somehow paralyse their midfield

I agree we might as well plonk Frawley on him - if its going to be a year of beltings we might as well be getting our future hopes some experience on the best. Same exact theory for Dunn at CHF. Both Holland and Miller should be delisted.

hangon, i've got the answer - you just have to VISUALISE how we are going to beat Hawthorn on Sunday

"a congenital heart defect has felled Lance Franklin moments before the match"

[CHAMP 347]

It's as if I've died and gone to hell

It is not a pretty sight and leaves a lump in the throat.........

[Seinfeld 40]

I hear ya Jaded

They Hawks have good forward line...but without their key midfelders playing who's going to kick to them?

Dee's by 27....

[Kit Walker 225]

Assuming Rivers (probably) and Bate (certainty) won't play I'll say:

CHF - Miller/Dunn

CHB - Dunn/Bell

I reckon Dunn looks a smart enough player to play in either position - time will tell.

[Yencks 8]

i mean it all depends on what the opposition do in terms of positioning and how many men they play forward...these days you rearly get a perfect FP FF FP HFF CHF HFF Wing Center etc etc...but i would like to see a bigger bodied person step into this role if the skill and perfect timing of rivers was not present, such as Holland because it is a big risk to play a potentially good player such as Dunn as early as this in a match that i think could be so very crucial for our member numbers

[Dee man 303]

Miller should play CHF with Bate injured. It means that he won't be playing defence and that's all that matters.

On a serious note, though, Bate has overtaken Miller as CHF and since he has not playing, this will be Miller's last chance to prove he can play key position forward. While we haven't seen his best in ages, Millers' best was at CHF and he must be tried there otherwise he is virtually useless on our list. By CHF, I reckon play him floating up the ground. He now knows how to kick, so now he hopefully knows what to do when he gets it 60-80m out.