Does anyone else find it perverse?

[Red and Blue Flame 150]

Seekers,

FWIW I also think Daniher is a realist and understands that anything other than top four will probably se him not get another contract.

I have disagreed with some of the things he has done (particularly during matches!) down the years, however to reach the highest level of coaching and playing AFL commands some level of respect. Coaching is by no means an easy gig at any level especially in the AFL where fortunes (and supporters) can be fickle.

This thread isn't directed at people like you or Jaded who give a realistic perspective of the situation. It's more directed at the litany of morans who write things along the line of "ZOMG I hope he lose his jarb as we will b sooo much betterer under Garry Lyon or Michael Voss!!1!1"

I just find it sad that there are people who seem to be enjoying our and Daniher's plight at the moment! Because those fates are very much intwined.

if we have voss or lyon as a coach..we wont do as well as we will with daniher..we need someone who has been an assistant, i.e longmire. he would be perfect. Sure daniher has been a great servant but i can tell you, 10 years without a flag...he wouldve been gone at other clubs by now.

[Seekers SEECAMP 0]

Seekers,

FWIW I also think Daniher is a realist and understands that anything other than top four will probably se him not get another contract.

I have disagreed with some of the things he has done (particularly during matches!) down the years, however to reach the highest level of coaching and playing AFL commands some level of respect. Coaching is by no means an easy gig at any level especially in the AFL where fortunes (and supporters) can be fickle.

This thread isn't directed at people like you or Jaded who give a realistic perspective of the situation. It's more directed at the litany of morans who write things along the line of "ZOMG I hope he lose his jarb as we will b sooo much betterer under Garry Lyon or Michael Voss!!1!1"

I just find it sad that there are people who seem to be enjoying our and Daniher's plight at the moment! Because those fates are very much intwined.

Fair enough Slander...fair comment..and I totally agree with you.

[Guest dee'viator]

.... that there are a number of people on here hoping someone loses their job?

The reason this club has FAILED, FAILED & FAILED since our beloved leader Norm Smith coached is because the

dumb gentlemanly attitude, everyone knows that gentlemen will always fall in behind. Very nice in society life but in the cut throat world of pro sport, it's plain suicide. If you won't take the hard line then just hide in the shadows down the back & let some other team shine.

[Red and Blue Flame 150]

here here deeviator

[Johnny Karate 559]

I don't think you'll find a lot of posters who don't go to games as some sort of punishment to the club.

I go every week, and I stay until the final siren even if we are getting our arses handed to us on a plate (like on Sunday).

I wasn't accusing posters of not going to games but I think the attitude that people who are trying to be positive and offer support to a team under seige are accused of being blind and supporting mediocrity.

Let me ask you this, do you blindly support every player who pulls on a Melbourne gurnsey, or are you enough of a realist to recognise that some players (if not all) have their downfalls?

Putting on the jumper and jumping into the bullring deserves respect. I hope whoever plays on match day does well and proves me wrong even if I disagree with their initial selection in the side.

Anyone who doesn't is playing favourites and doesn't have the right to then turn around and accuse Daniher of doing the same.

How is that any different to Daniher? Yes, he's done a great job promoting our football club. He has battled on despite board upheavals, draft penalties, poor finances and facilities and so on, but his primary job (as he said himself) is to win games.

As a 10 year coach, he needs to be judged on his performances, not in isolation, but over the whole 10 year period. 7 years ago he got us to a grand final. 4 years ago, we were bottom 4. For the past 3 seasons who scrapped into the top 8 and were extremely disappointing in September. All this while having a relatively good run with injuries.

This year we will no doubt struggle because we have significant injuries. Nobody blames Daniher for that, but in the big scheme of things we will again be unsuccessful.

It is not different to Daniher but the reality is whether you like it or not he is coach. Whilst he is coach he deserves a level of respect and support.

Bottom line is, he hasn't got us what we all want, a premiership. Does that make him a bad person? Of course not. Does that make him a bad coach? Not even. Does that make him a candidate for criticism? Absolutely.

A lot of supporters, myself included, don't want to get rid of Daniher for the sake of getting rid of him. We want him gone because we can't see a change happening any other way.

BTW, I've always maintained that it's not who you criticise, but how you do it.

Your last point is what I'm getting at, hoping somebody loses their job and doesn't do well for an organisation we all support seems a bit macabre to me.

[Jarka 767]

.... that there are a number of people on here hoping someone loses their job?

I understand your point but the coach makes yearly decisions that finishes careers for many players, it's imperative that the right person is appointed as our coach.

[beelzebub 23,200]

I dont think anyone is enjoying our current situation too much. I dont think there are really that many who actually hate Danners ( I dont ) . I also dont think our fortunes will change much without change and in this effort there wil be collateral damge of sorts. Its nothing personal, just practical.

[Johnny Karate 559]

I understand your point but the coach makes yearly decisions that finishes careers for many players, it's imperative that the right person is appointed as our coach.

That's because it is in the coach's job description to do so and he's paid to do it.

'Supporter' is a voluntary position.

Anyone hoping somebody fails (player or coach) just to prove they were right or vindicate their vendettas cannot call themselves a supporter IMO.

[beelzebub 23,200]

is it a case of a person wishing a player or coach to fail to substansiate their stance ..

or simply taking a stance on the failure of a player or coach ?

[marfa 0]

i wish some people at my office would lose their job

[Elmag 5]

I only get confused - all summer we're supposed to be playing a run and carry game, but on the week end we're told that the skill levels at the club suddenly aren't up to the other teams standards - a run and carry game requires very good skills - I know that we have a few players out, but surely if you've been around the club for ten years, selected the players, determined a plan that is both what you require to win and can be carried out by your team, to have your coach say at round 3 you don't have the skills just amazes and amuses me.

I think if you have been in a job and still can get it right, then it is time to move on and give another a chance.

[Real Demon 232]

I have been a long time supporter of Daniher.....I think he has done a great job as coach, and he without doubt has always served the MFC with the clubs best interests at heart.........lets face it.....he is a quality bloke!

I will support Daniher as coach for as long as he is in charge, and involved with the MFC.

But do I think he should be appointed as coach for next year and beyond......no.

I actually feel slightly guilty for saying that.....but if I take the emotion out of it, I think that the time is right to move forward with a new coach. It's not that I think that what Danners does is completely wrong, just that I honestly feel that things can be done better, and as a result, that is what is best for the MFC going forward.

It's nothing personal, it's not disloyalty, a vendetta, or even unreasonable.

It's just my view.

[True Believer 1]

A true supporter accepts things as they are, takes the bad with the good or indifferent and turns up every week.

What would you prefer?

No one turns up to games or signs up as members as some form of protest against the fact we haven't won anything for 43 years and because the current team is struggling?

As for the comment "I support a club, not an individual." Good point but while Daniher is coach he is part of this club and I will support him.

Not a problem with your opinion....but others have their opinion.

I want results that are beneficial to the club....A PREMIERSHIP FLAG sooner rather than later.....I've waited a long time.

[Rogue 585]

As for the comment "I support a club, not an individual." Good point but while Daniher is coach he is part of this club and I will support him.

Ah, the Board members over the past ten years must have had the same attitude as you.

Explains why ND has had a decade at the club.

[Jarka 767]

That's because it is in the coach's job description to do so and he's paid to do it.

'Supporter' is a voluntary position.

Anyone hoping somebody fails (player or coach) just to prove they were right or vindicate their vendettas cannot call themselves a supporter IMO.

Too right it's a voluntary position, but answer this - Where does 100% of the income come for a football club come from, either directly or indirectly?

From the bloody supporters, we pay to see our team, we pay their incomes, and ultimately we have the decision as a group. If the supporters turn on the coach and stop going to games then the board will very quickly act.

Your problem with this argument is that you're trying to make it personal in an effort to try and take the moral high ground. This talk about "Anyone hoping somebody fails (player or coach) just to prove they were right or vindicate their vendettas cannot call themselves a supporter" is just complete crap. I'm sick of seeing my club being as soft as butter when the heat's turned up.

What [censored] vendetta are you talking about!!!!?