Scott Selwood

[Fitz Fitzpatrick 886]

of course Selwood is currently superior. hes been playing for 5 years . Adams and swallow are still kids. Does that mean they dont have more talent? GCS have the most skilful list in the competition, player for player. still doesnt win them games ... because they are young. but their future is very bright. likewise the 3 players i mentioned. Brent moloney can have more impact on a game than adams. does that mean youd rather take moloney in a trade than adams?! clueless

[ignition. 1,426]

selwood has been playing for several seasons and in my opinion has reached his potential. a bit of a brent moloney type. the 3 i mentioned have far more upseide and show more class in what they do. Just too young to do it consistently yet. I watch a lot of football. You are "prendergast" in your talent spotting abilities.

Hahaha if I'm Prendergast you must be Phil Scully's wife.

[ignition. 1,426]

of course Selwood is currently superior. hes been playing for 5 years . Adams and swallow are still kids. Does that mean they dont have more talent? GCS have the most skilful list in the competition, player for player. still doesnt win them games ... because they are young. but their future is very bright. likewise the 3 players i mentioned. Brent moloney can have more impact on a game than adams. does that mean youd rather take moloney in a trade than adams?! clueless

Mate I haven't had a crack at those two, I'd be over the moon to have either. I just stated that S. Selwood is a gun, and at his current age there is still plenty of improvement to be made and by no means has his already great game halted.

His game, age and work ethic would fit perfectly into our list. Although it's unlikely to happen (since reported).

[Fitz Fitzpatrick 886]

Mate I haven't had a crack at those two, I'd be over the moon to have either. I just stated that S. Selwood is a gun, and at his current age there is still plenty of improvement to be made and by no means has his already great game halted.

His game, age and work ethic would fit perfectly into our list. Although it's unlikely to happen (since reported).

Ignition, my mistake for not clarifying who my posts were directed at.. My last 2 posts were directed at sweet puff's appraisal of selwood being a bigger 'get' than swallow or adams. yes selwood would be a handy addition but if we are lumping him in with adams, martin swallow then we are referring to trading pick 2 for selwood. In that respect swallow and adams have much more 'bang for our buck' than selwood as their ceiling i believe is much higher than selwoods.