Trading pick 1 & 3

[rjay 24,583]

I think that mini-draft market was distorted because picks could be offered - that should not have been allowed. GWS couldn't actually use the mini-draft pick themselves but they could use the traded picks.

In addition the mini-draft targets were a year off and possibly less definite. Here we're talking specifically about Boyd, available to play in 2014. And MFC can just opt to take him.

It's going to take a desperate club - Pavlich and Brown are in their twilight and there's daylight 2nd on those lists, they need to act before the sun goes down - how's that for a mixed metaphor?

I would take Boyd and trade some of our other forward options for mids, as 'Bob' says non of the other clubs will give up a star mid for the pick. Lets trade for the more experienced mids and set up our forward line for the next 10 years. You don't let a player like Boyd go.

[Redleg 40,077]

I don't think clubs will give up stars for pick 1. If you believe GWS nobody would trade good players to them in the mini-draft.

Much more likely would be pick 1 for a mid range mid (say Reddan) and a first or second rounder. I think that's a much more likely scenario.

Then I would keep pick 1 if we got it.

Boyd is being spoken of as a star and 10 year player for whoever gets him. The deal you would want for that pick would be skyhigh. That is why, if GWS have pick 1, they will not trade it unless they get a mighty package in return.

If we get it we should adopt the same attitude.

[Redleg 40,077]

I would take Boyd and trade some of our other forward options for mids, as 'Bob' says non of the other clubs will give up a star mid for the pick. Lets trade for the more experienced mids and set up our forward line for the next 10 years. You don't let a player like Boyd go.

Agree.

This is a big "if" of course, but if Boyd was say another plugger, would you pass him by because we need mids?

[Slartibartfast 16,876]

I would take Boyd and trade some of our other forward options for mids, as 'Bob' says non of the other clubs will give up a star mid for the pick. Lets trade for the more experienced mids and set up our forward line for the next 10 years. You don't let a player like Boyd go.

Clark and Dawes are injury prone and on inflated salaries. Not worth much. On your theory you wouldn't trade Hogan. We don't have another power forward.

No team gives away established A grade mids and a player must agree to a trade. A graders are usually very well treated, have a loyalty to their club and don't want to move.

We might get a good young mid wanting to return home but there will be competition and we will have to pay a high price. I think it's a doubtful proposition that we will get what you want and my proposition is more achievable. I also think that fair to good quantity is perhaps better than one quality mid.

[old55 22,778]

Agree.

This is a big "if" of course, but if Boyd was say another plugger, would you pass him by because we need mids?

Yes I would for a quality player like Rockliff or Fyfe - if we didn't have Hogan it would be different story.

[old55 22,778]

No team gives away established A grade mids and a player must agree to a trade.

Of course no-one is going to trade an established A-Grade mid for a pick #1 that will net another mid - - why would you?

No team has offered to trade a pick #1 power forward in my memory - we're in a unique position, having picking up Hogan, Dawes and Clark in recent times.

Money talks - if the trading club wants to do the deal, the player can be convinced but clearly we'll have to pay big time. Roos would be a big positive factor.

I think quality IS important - and we can get more with pick 3. We can round out some quantity with pick 20 and 38 and free agency.

Edited September 3, 2013 by Fifty-5

[rjay 24,583]

Clark and Dawes are injury prone and on inflated salaries. Not worth much. On your theory you wouldn't trade Hogan. We don't have another power forward.

No team gives away established A grade mids and a player must agree to a trade. A graders are usually very well treated, have a loyalty to their club and don't want to move.

We might get a good young mid wanting to return home but there will be competition and we will have to pay a high price. I think it's a doubtful proposition that we will get what you want and my proposition is more achievable. I also think that fair to good quantity is perhaps better than one quality mid.

I wasn't necessarily talking power forward but Watts and Fitz may draw something, Dawes is still an option and I see Clark as a better ruck option that adds to the midfield strength straight up.

Dawes is a problem with injury mainly because he seems prone to soft tissue problems, Clark has just had recurring problems with the one injury (apart from when he tried to kill himself taking a mark) and if he gets over that he should be ok.

Clark and Boyd rotating in the ruck with Dawes and Hogan holding down forward positions looks pretty good to me.

[hughtinkler 22]

Pick 2 and 20 for zaharakis and hibberd?

[InVINCEable 358]

Been going through this all day and thinking what clubs would be willing to do if we got the PP as pick 1, let me know what you guys think.

Pick 1 Luke Tapscott and Pick 3 for Michael Barlow, Matt de Boer or Lachie Neale

Pick 3 and 2nd round pick for Nick Dal Santo and David Armitage

Pick 1 and a 2nd round pick for Liam Picken and Tom Liberatore

Pick 1 for Viv Michie, Tendai Mzungu and Matt de Boer

Pick 1 and Cameron Pedersen for Andrew Gaff and Matt Rosa

Pick 1 and Pick 3 for Daniel Hannaberry

Pick 3 and Luke Tapscott for Ryan Bastinac and Sam Gibson

Pick 3 and Luke Tapscott for Heath Shaw and Dale Thomas

Pick 1, Jake Spencer, Pick 3 and 2nd round pick for Tom Rockcliff, Patrick Karnezis, Jared Polec and Sam Docherty

Pick 2 for David Swallow

Pick 1 and Pick 3 for David Swallow and Dion Prestia

Pick 1, Jake Spencer and Pick 3 for David Swallow, Dion Prestia and Brandon Matera

Pick 3 for Taylor Adams and Adam Treloar

Pick 1 and Jake Spencer for Taylor Adams and Devon Smith

Pick 1 for Bryce Gibbs, Mitch Robinson and Chris Yarran

Pick 3 for Mitch Robinson and Chris Yarran

Pick 1 and Pick 3, Jake Spencer for Steele Sidebottom, Heath Shaw and Dale Thomas

Pick 3 and Jake Spencer for Bernie Vince, David McKay and Richard Douglas

Pick 3 for David McKay and Bernie Vince

Pick 1 and 3 for Dustin Martin

Pick 1 for Ben Howlett, David Zaharakis and Jake Melksham

Pick 1 for Dyson Heppell

Pick 3 for Shane Savage, Isaac Smith and Liam Shiels

Pick 3 and a 2nd round pick for Shane Savage, Isaac Smith, Liam Shiels and Brendan Whitecross

Pick 1 and Pick 3 for Hamish Hartlett, Cameron Hitchcock and Matthew Broadbent

Pick 1 Luke Tapscott and Pick 3 for Michael Barlow, Matt de Boer or Lachie Neale

Pick 3 and 2^nd round pick for Nick Dal Santo and David Armitage

Pick 1 and a 2^nd round pick for Liam Picken and Tom Liberatore

Pick 1 for Viv Michie, Tendai Mzungu and Matt de Boer

Pick 1 and Cameron Pedersen for Andrew Gaff and Matt Rosa

Pick 1 and Pick 3 for Daniel Hannaberry

Pick 3 and Luke Tapscott for Ryan Bastinac and Sam Gibson

Pick 3 and Luke Tapscott for Heath Shaw and Dale Thomas

Pick 1, Jake Spencer, Pick 3 and 2^nd round pick for Tom Rockcliff, Patrick Karnezis, Jared Polec and Sam Docherty

Pick 2 for David Swallow

Pick 1 and Pick 3 for David Swallow and Dion Prestia

Pick 1, Jake Spencer and Pick 3 for David Swallow, Dion Prestia and Brandon Matera

Pick 3 for Taylor Adams and Adam Treloar

Pick 1 and Jake Spencer for Taylor Adams and Devon Smith

Pick 1 for Bryce Gibbs, Mitch Robinson and Chris Yarran

Pick 3 for Mitch Robinson and Chris Yarran

Pick 1 and Pick 3, Jake Spencer for Steele Sidebottom, Heath Shaw and Dale Thomas

Pick 3 and Jake Spencer for Bernie Vince, David McKay and Richard Douglas

Pick 3 for David McKay and Bernie Vince

Pick 1 and 3 for Dustin Martin

Pick 1 for Ben Howlett, David Zaharakis and Jake Melksham

Pick 1 for Dyson Heppell

Pick 3 for Shane Savage, Isaac Smith and Liam Shiels

Pick 3 and a 2^nd round pick for Shane Savage, Isaac Smith, Liam Shiels and Brendan Whitecross

Pick 1 and Pick 3 for Hamish Hartlett, Cameron Hitchcock and Matthew BroadbentPick 1 Luke Tapscott and Pick 3 for Michael Barlow, Matt de Boer or Lachie Neale

Pick 3 and 2^nd round pick for Nick Dal Santo and David Armitage

Pick 1 and a 2^nd round pick for Liam Picken and Tom Liberatore

Pick 1 for Viv Michie, Tendai Mzungu and Matt de Boer

Pick 1 and Cameron Pedersen for Andrew Gaff and Matt Rosa

Pick 1 and Pick 3 for Daniel Hannaberry

Pick 3 and Luke Tapscott for Ryan Bastinac and Sam Gibson

Pick 3 and Luke Tapscott for Heath Shaw and Dale Thomas

Pick 1, Jake Spencer, Pick 3 and 2^nd round pick for Tom Rockcliff, Patrick Karnezis, Jared Polec and Sam Docherty

Pick 2 for David Swallow

Pick 1 and Pick 3 for David Swallow and Dion Prestia

Pick 1, Jake Spencer and Pick 3 for David Swallow, Dion Prestia and Brandon Matera

Pick 3 for Taylor Adams and Adam Treloar

Pick 1 and Jake Spencer for Taylor Adams and Devon Smith

Pick 1 for Bryce Gibbs, Mitch Robinson and Chris Yarran

Pick 3 for Mitch Robinson and Chris Yarran

Pick 1 and Pick 3, Jake Spencer for Steele Sidebottom, Heath Shaw and Dale Thomas

Pick 3 and Jake Spencer for Bernie Vince, David McKay and Richard Douglas

Pick 3 for David McKay and Bernie Vince

Pick 1 and 3 for Dustin Martin

Pick 1 for Ben Howlett, David Zaharakis and Jake Melksham

Pick 1 for Dyson Heppell

Pick 3 for Shane Savage, Isaac Smith and Liam Shiels

Pick 3 and a 2^nd round pick for Shane Savage, Isaac Smith, Liam Shiels and Brendan Whitecross

Pick 1 and Pick 3 for Hamish Hartlett, Cameron Hitchcock and Matthew Broadbent

[demonkeaney 61]

I think you've missed a few

[Matt Demon 1,407]

Not a hope in hell we'll have an early priority pick. If anything it will be at the end of the first round imo.

[rpfc 28,047]

lol

[Goodvibes 3,596]

lol

C'mon that was the single greatest first post in Demonland history. It was in the spirit of Pants' Paperclip approach to trade week.

[InVINCEable 358]

C'mon that was the single greatest first post in Demonland history. It was in the spirit of Pants' Paperclip approach to trade week.

Thanks

[DeeZee 7,296]

We will not get a priority pick.

[InVINCEable 358]

We will not get a priority pick.

You say that because you don't want anyone to diss you for being a Melbourne supporter and call you the AFL's spoilt child because they are [censored] they didn't get a PP for having one "rough" year and finishing ninth.

[rpfc 28,047]

C'mon that was the single greatest first post in Demonland history. It was in the spirit of Pants' Paperclip approach to trade week.

You're right, I didn't realise.

I will gif the excellenceness of the achievement:

Well done!

And welcome - here is a smile:

[InVINCEable 358]

You're right, I didn't realise.

I will gif the excellenceness of the achievement:

Well done!

And welcome - here is a smile:

Hahahahahah thanks guys, i am feeling the love