Massive dilemma

[thaipantsman 180]

Mass exodus-Moloney, Jurrah, Green, Davey, Dunn, Gysberts and younger players Cook etc simply not achieving under Neeld.

Compounding this is the lack of any attraction at Melbourne ATM. Does any of the hot talents really want to come to Melbourne or does a Carlton under Malthouse or Freo under R. LYon seem a more attractive option?

A Coach with little charisma and a boring scripted game plan that is obvious to all.

Say what you will as the rounds tick by in 2013 the pressure will build on Neeld. IMO Neeld is a good coach but not of the standard to lead us out of this one.

Would not of been ideal but would of been better to give the job to Craig with Neeld as assistant. Obviously Lyon, Mattews, Sheedy or Malthouse is what the club needs.

[Bingo 305]

honestly mate....just give it a rest....or start being a supporter. you choose

[dees_rule_4eva 22]

Mass exodus-Moloney, Jurrah, Green, Davey, Dunn, Gysberts and younger players Cook etc simply not achieving under Neeld.

For starters Davey, Dunn, Gysberts & Cook have not all left as yet. Davey will stay, as stated by Neeld yesterday on SEN. I'd say Dunn will also stay, no indication from the Club that he is in danger of being moved on.

That leaves Gysberts & Cook, who have not been mentioned formally by the Club as yet - but are both the topic of conversation on the rumour mill.

So your mass exodus theory is a little flawed at this stage (although it may well prove to be the case).

Gysberts, while showing potential, has not really proved anything at this stage and I wouldn't be heartbroken if he was moved on. I think he has alot of talent but needs to put on some serious size before he can mix it with the big boys on a consistent basis. As for Cook, I really don't think we're losing anything here (apart from wasting a #12 draft pick).

[olisik 4,060]

Can this thread be locked? There are already about a million threads about this

[Lucifers Hero 40,364]

Mass exodus-Moloney, Jurrah, Green, Davey, Dunn, Gysberts and younger players Cook etc simply not achieving under Neeld.

Compounding this is the lack of any attraction at Melbourne ATM. Does any of the hot talents really want to come to Melbourne or does a Carlton under Malthouse or Freo under R. LYon seem a more attractive option?

A Coach with little charisma and a boring scripted game plan that is obvious to all.

Say what you will as the rounds tick by in 2013 the pressure will build on Neeld. IMO Neeld is a good coach but not of the standard to lead us out of this one.

Would not of been ideal but would of been better to give the job to Craig with Neeld as assistant. Obviously Lyon, Mattews, Sheedy or Malthouse is what the club needs.

At this rate you should change your name to Ballantyne The Serial Pest! Please go away!!

[beelzebub 23,383]

Detour required

[Cheap Seats 3,310]

We need to sack everyone I reckon - where is tonatopia he'll back me up!!

After all the players exodusing are genuine stars - it's Neelds fault they didn't play well this year

[Cheap Seats 3,310]

Haha needed the lols

Edited September 13, 2012 by Unleash Hell

[thaipantsman 180]

For starters Davey, Dunn, Gysberts & Cook have not all left as yet. Davey will stay, as stated by Neeld yesterday on SEN. I'd say Dunn will also stay, no indication from the Club that he is in danger of being moved on.

That leaves Gysberts & Cook, who have not been mentioned formally by the Club as yet - but are both the topic of conversation on the rumour mill.

So your mass exodus theory is a little flawed at this stage (although it may well prove to be the case).

Gysberts, while showing potential, has not really proved anything at this stage and I wouldn't be heartbroken if he was moved on. I think he has alot of talent but needs to put on some serious size before he can mix it with the big boys on a consistent basis. As for Cook, I really don't think we're losing anything here (apart from wasting a #12 draft pick).

Gysberts IMO has massive untapped potential.

[Whispering_Jack 30,674]

I agree this subject has been canvassed on countless other threads already and doesn't need to be rehashed now in different form.

Thread locked.