I enjoyed it EGD. Gutsy effort in crap conditions.

I'm not the only one asking the question re Scully.

OK but your position on Scully is pretty clear. Do you honestly think he didnt sing the song with his team mates cos hes goin to GWS? HA HA HA laughable....

I've seen guys with knee recos, concussion, broken bones make it to the circle for the song. It is slightly strange. The only excuse for it is if he's left the ground for x rays or something.

Except the song wasn't sung in the rooms, it was sung in the cool room up on the ground.

Scully was in the rooms getting treatment, and probably had no idea the boys were going to sing the song up there. WTF was he meant to do? Run out of the rooms mid treatment after guessing the players weren't going to come into the rooms for the song? FFS, why are we making such a big deal about it!

Oh no, Scully farted, quick he's going to GWS, get your booing voice ready!

Must be gone then.

Just had a thread deleted with 3 worthless replies like yours....... All I asked was why Scully would not join the huddle with his boys to sing our song. I have seen countless players join in with bad injuries including Grimes who had a broken foot whilst on crutches. I wasn't suggesting he is off to GWS in fact I have always thought he'd stay and simply was concerned and all I got was smart a## dribble as replies. Thanks.

Just had a thread deleted with 3 worthless replies like yours....... All I asked was why Scully would not join the huddle with his boys to sing our song. I have seen countless players join in with bad injuries including Grimes who had a broken foot whilst on crutches. I wasn't suggesting he is off to GWS in fact I have always thought he'd stay and simply was concerned and all I got was smart a## dribble as replies. Thanks.

It's getting ridiculous isn't it? You can't even ask a simple question about the guy anymore without the censors stepping in.

It's a valid question.

Except the song wasn't sung in the rooms, it was sung in the cool room up on the ground.

Scully was in the rooms getting treatment, and probably had no idea the boys were going to sing the song up there. WTF was he meant to do? Run out of the rooms mid treatment after guessing the players weren't going to come into the rooms for the song? FFS, why are we making such a big deal about it!

Oh no, Scully farted, quick he's going to GWS, get your booing voice ready!

Stupid reply thinking everyone is on the page that he must be gone cos he didn't sing the song. I just noticed he wasn't there and wondered if he was hurt more badly than first thought, back up a bit.

Unless you're totally incapacitated, you get in there and sing the club song with the boys!

FFS this has given you another week of conversation hasn't it!!!

Except the song wasn't sung in the rooms, it was sung in the cool room up on the ground.

Scully was in the rooms getting treatment, and probably had no idea the boys were going to sing the song up there. WTF was he meant to do? Run out of the rooms mid treatment after guessing the players weren't going to come into the rooms for the song? FFS, why are we making such a big deal about it!

Oh no, Scully farted, quick he's going to GWS, get your booing voice ready!

Spot on there . Think about it people, were they at the g in there normal rooms/ surrounds? No. Sang the song in the fridge cos they are stuffed and scully not there. simple.

It's getting ridiculous isn't it? You can't even ask a simple question about the guy anymore without the censors stepping in.

It's a valid question.

Here here and it is so true, you mention Scully and so many members or moderators jump down your throat assuming you must be against Scully or sure he's leaving. Just and observation guys. If Trenners went off in the last with a knee in the back and didn't join in the song and I asked why he wasn't there? Would you delete my thread?

It's getting ridiculous isn't it? You can't even ask a simple question about the guy anymore without the censors stepping in.

It's a valid question.

Valid in what sense RR? We all know why you raised it, but as I said, you also probably saw reds under the bed in the 60's.

Valid in what sense RR? We all know why you raised it, but as I said, you also probably saw reds under the bed in the 60's.

If Col Sylvia or Stef Martin didn't show up, I'd ask the same question.

Other people noticed and asked as well.

It's rare for a player not to front for the club song unless they can't get off a stretcher or have gone to hospital.

If you've played footy or been around football clubs, you would know this.

Here here and it is so true, you mention Scully and so many members or moderators jump down your throat assuming you must be against Scully or sure he's leaving. Just and observation guys. If Trenners went off in the last with a knee in the back and didn't join in the song and I asked why he wasn't there? Would you delete my thread?

WHAT !!!!!

Is Trengove going to GWS

If Col Sylvia or Stef Martin didn't show up, I'd ask the same question.

Other people noticed and asked as well.

It's rare for a player not to front for the club song unless they can't get off a stretcher or have gone to hospital.

If you've played footy or been around football clubs, you would know this.

So my rational explanation above wasn't enough to halt this ridiculous discussion?

Give it a rest and go and check under your bed... I heard there may be some reds under it.

With what we now know about Eastern Europe and its structure and influence following the breakdown of the Soviet bloc, it is now generally acknowleged that there were in fact truly

Reds under the Bed

WHAT !!!!!

Is Trengove going to GWS

didn't even get close to a laugh, crap and worthless post.

With what we now know about Eastern Europe and its structure and influence following the breakdown of the Soviet bloc, it is now generally acknowleged that there were in fact truly

Reds under the Bed

hahahaha. good one

With what we now know about Eastern Europe and its structure and influence following the breakdown of the Soviet bloc, it is now generally acknowleged that there were in fact truly

Reds under the Bed

+1

If Col Sylvia or Stef Martin didn't show up, I'd ask the same question.

Other people noticed and asked as well.

It's rare for a player not to front for the club song unless they can't get off a stretcher or have gone to hospital.

If you've played footy or been around football clubs, you would know this.

It maybe your 500 posts in the last week about scully that have led people to jump on you RR

So my rational explanation above wasn't enough to halt this ridiculous discussion?

Oh, I took your comment as an attempt at facetious humour. It wasn't?

So my rational explanation above wasn't enough to halt this ridiculous discussion?

Kinda the wrong thread for anything too rational.....

Come on guys, I am sure there was a very reasonable explanation to him not being there but I can only imagine the reason the other thread was

deleted was to stop the endless spread of Tom Scully threads and keep all opinions no matter what in the one place. Nothing more conspiratorial than that.

Unless you're totally incapacitated, you get in there and sing the club song with the boys!

How did I know it would be you bring this up... definitely gone to GSW now...

So my rational explanation above wasn't enough to halt this ridiculous discussion?

WTF?? Because of how you are going about it... just a simple "he is probably just still getting treatment" would have done it, but as soon as you mention Scully around here you are shot down with fast witted replies, a question about any other would have got a normal response.

WTF?? Because of how you are going about it... just a simple "he is probably just still getting treatment" would have done it, but as soon as you mention Scully around here you are shot down with fast witted replies, a question about any other would have got a normal response.

Then how about we just go with your rational response and say.....

"he is probably just still getting treatment", which I'm sure is absolutely accurate.

And we all move on !!!

Oh, I took your comment as an attempt at facetious humour. It wasn't?

No, it was an account of a far more probable explanation than your idiotic, irrational and frankly boring need to turn anything Scully related into a negative.

Move on and just wait patiently until this contract issue is resolved. You're boring everyone half to death with this repeated [censored].

You don't know more than any of us on this matter, in fact, you probably know less, so just shut the hell up about it until you have something new and proven to add, and stop negatively portraying a MELBOURNE FOOTBALLER (and yes, he is still a Melbourne footballer).

Then how about we just go with your rational response and say.....

"he is probably just still getting treatment", which I'm sure is absolutely accurate.

And we all move on !!!

yeah "lets"

yeah "lets"

Good man, thanks!!!