Bon Scott is rolling in his grave

[daisycutter 29,604]

.......

Think some of you just have a problem with Judd because he didn't choose to become a Demon

And that isn't good enough reason for you!!

people have been killed for less

[Kiss of Death 747]

And that isn't good enough reason for you!!

people have been killed for less

Depressing thought isn't it!

Nope, while I was very hopeful he would come to the red and blue, I just don't like how he shopped himself around, the little arrogant looking smile, the whole captaincy/job thing... Looking back I would have been disgusted if we offered him captaincy, totally lessens the achievements of homegrown heroes like Junior.

Sure he didn't have Judds raw skill but by god he earned respect and bled for the guernsey.

On a side note, who else cheered when hearing Grimesy and Sculls getting 3's?

Oh, and edit: most importantly I just don't think he was best and fairest this year.

Edited September 20, 2010 by Kiss of Death

[Watt and Howe? 16]

Why was a poof with no sleaves and $20 'Bono' glasses butchering a classic?!? Hard to watch. However loved how much time was spent talking to Jimmy!

[Jaded No More 68,867]

Oh, and edit: most importantly I just don't think he was best and fairest this year.

He didn't even make the starting 18 in the AA team FFS.

And to whoever said that we begrudge him for not choosing Melbourne, well I don't. In fact I think we dodged a massive bullet. I just hate that he was too much of a coward to admit that money was his sole motivation. He made clubs waste their time chasing him and came up with pathetic excuses about why he turned each club down. To stand up in a room full of AFL greats and profess your love for Melbourne and Jimmy but then turn around and say a [censored] up at the race with Greg Swan was your deciding factor is a joke.

[The Big Ticket 94]

Well I missed the long way to the top cover, thank god.

Who was the band who covered it?

Couldn't believe it when I opened up the AFL site...what a joke. I actually feel for Swan.

[Gorgoroth 12,924]

Reality is that as said by others, Swan was best player with Ablett, then Judd.

The difference is the other people in the teams of those two took votes from them, Judd had no one take votes off him.

Not fussed he won it as team mates taking votes of each other is part of it all.

[Dee*ceiving 1,674]

He didn't even make the starting 18 in the AA team FFS.

And to whoever said that we begrudge him for not choosing Melbourne, well I don't. In fact I think we dodged a massive bullet. I just hate that he was too much of a coward to admit that money was his sole motivation. He made clubs waste their time chasing him and came up with pathetic excuses about why he turned each club down. To stand up in a room full of AFL greats and profess your love for Melbourne and Jimmy but then turn around and say a [censored] up at the race with Greg Swan was your deciding factor is a joke.

Hear, hear Jaded! Summed him up perfectly.

If i could have thrown a shoe at his smug head last night without risking the health of my TV I would have.

[DemonoidNumber9 7]

It actually says a lot about where Carlton are at that Judd gets so many BOG's. There's no Pendlebury to take votes off him, for one. Judd's second Brownlow came because his teammates are so bad that he's the only one that stands out.

I think this says a lot about a winner of a Brownlow....anyone that can poll so many votes after being the NO 1 TAGGING OPTION in his team week in week out.

thats the whole point of this. he gets tagged every week (unlike swan!) and still dominates. doesnt matter who's around him. one on one. best in the comp!

[Choko 493]

He didn't even make the starting 18 in the AA team FFS.

And to whoever said that we begrudge him for not choosing Melbourne, well I don't. In fact I think we dodged a massive bullet. I just hate that he was too much of a coward to admit that money was his sole motivation. He made clubs waste their time chasing him and came up with pathetic excuses about why he turned each club down. To stand up in a room full of AFL greats and profess your love for Melbourne and Jimmy but then turn around and say a [censored] up at the race with Greg Swan was your deciding factor is a joke.

Agree 100%. The whole shop around was a cynical self-indulgent joke.

But I think it's unfair those that say he's not a ball player and he doesn't win his own ball. He wins plenty of his own eyeball.

[Jaded No More 68,867]

Agree 100%. The whole shop around was a cynical self-indulgent joke.

But I think it's unfair those that say he's not a ball player and he doesn't win his own ball. He wins plenty of his own eyeball.

He is a gun player, one of the all time greats.

But he also happens to be smug and selfish when it comes to his football (he might not be in real life).

He was lucky to win last night, but as I said to my Carlton friends, one player a team does not make.

[H_T 3,043]

This is the 'Chris Judd Medal'

what a disgrace.

Deserves his medal. Good on him.