Injury List: Round 4

[e25 5]

I'm happy with him being the Tiwi Turtle.

[pringle 42]

I'm happy with him being the Tiwi Turtle.

That scares me. He may have to slow down to turtle pace if he keeps doing his hammies

[2014-Flag 0]

MELBOURNE*

Daniel Bell (shoulder) - 3 weeks

Max Gawn (knee) - indefinite

Neville Jetta (groin) - 1-2 weeks

Liam Jurrah (shoulder) - 12 weeks

John Meesen (ankle) - indefinite

Cale Morton (knee) - 5 weeks

Jared Rivers (knee) - test

Colin Sylvia (jaw) - test

Luke Tapscott (hip) - indefinite

Austin Wonaeamirri (hamstring) - 2 weeks

Ah i forgot about the star woops....* Please note that Melbourne's list is from last week. It will be updated when available.

elsewhere on 'land, it has been mentioned Gawn has been training at Junction Oval, especially goal kicking and doing drills. if this is so, why is he on the indefinite injury list. Personally, I believe Gawn is one of the most important recruits we have made in the last ten years. One of the reasons Fremantle is on the rise is the presence and dominance of their giant mobile ruckman. Gawn is even more mobile and more skilled, and apparently is a great kick and mark. He could be another Paul Salmon. He and mark jamar and jack watts is a couple of years time cour dominate the competition like the bombers of old. if anything that combination is even more powerful than anything they had.

It would be nice to Max Gawn on the park and firing very soon. Anyone have an update on his current condition and when we are likely to see him?

[Theo 276]

Does anybody know where Daniel Hughes is? He is not on the injured list and did not play for Casey last week. Seems to have gone missing, again!.

[Nasher 33,617]

elsewhere on 'land, it has been mentioned Gawn has been training at Junction Oval, especially goal kicking and doing drills. if this is so, why is he on the indefinite injury list.

Indefinite just means "don't know when he'll be back" (indefinite as in 'not definite' - not defined). I would've thought the answer to why is pretty obvious -- they don't know when he'll be back.

There seems to be this common misconception that 'indefinite' means 'forever' - admittedly that is what it always seemed to mean when we were talking about Guy Rigoni's back or Stephen Powell's groins.

[Inner Demon 1]

There's no hurry on Gawn. He's a massive, massive kid who is apparently still growing a bit. We need him for the next 10-12 years more than we need him for the next 10-12 weeks. Comebacks from ACLs are always fraught with danger and I'm really glad we're giving him an extended lay-off.

The 12 month rule that we usually see doesn't really apply to Max either. That usually applies to players who have been in the system and have a fitness base prior to the injury. Max missed the 2nd half of last year and the entire pre-season. Once he reaches the end of his 12 month rehab in July he'd then likely enter 'pre-season' mode. If he gets in a few games for Casey Reserves at the end of the year, great, if not, I won't lose a minute's sleep. I'm more interested in him being 100% to commence his first full-preseason next year.

[Dinosaur Rover 197]

We live locally so I can get to JO quite often, again I had a chat with Luke Tapscott as he was as he put it enthusiastically "walking my first lap", much to the horror of my lovely lady who was with me, we asked him what he did and obviously he listens to the doctors he launched into this very descriptive medical diagnosis, I know it involved the cartilage so A. is probably correct but he lost both of us.....I could only reply "well you damaged it properly then" he laughed and said yes, he again is being treated cautiously, but thanked us for our support and said he was looking forward to playing for himself ,the team and the supporters who are really supportive which he appreciated

Thanks for this Satyricon - I like his prospects with a forward with a mature body and known to be a good kick I welcome his progress and look forward to seeing him play.

[Brettmcg 24]

Word on Wonaeamirri is that it is not so much a musculoskeletal issue as a biomechanical one. That is to say, he is straining the hamstring in the last lunge of a tackle. This will mean some work with a bio-mechanist to improve technique. Hopefully this doesn't remove tackling intensity from his game, as if I remember rightly he has been a pretty solid tackler.

Edited April 15, 2010 by Brettmcg

[H_T 3,049]

Interesting. Seems as though typing B) gives you a smoking demon. It's meant to be scenario 'b' as in the letter, not scenario 'smoking demon' B)

Try b/ instead of b ) which gives you B)

[Toot182 7]

Does anyone know what's going on with Sam Blease? Haven't seen any info about him running around for the Scorps.

[pringle 42]

elsewhere on 'land, it has been mentioned Gawn has been training at Junction Oval, especially goal kicking and doing drills. if this is so, why is he on the indefinite injury list. Personally, I believe Gawn is one of the most important recruits we have made in the last ten years. One of the reasons Fremantle is on the rise is the presence and dominance of their giant mobile ruckman. Gawn is even more mobile and more skilled, and apparently is a great kick and mark. He could be another Paul Salmon. He and mark jamar and jack watts is a couple of years time cour dominate the competition like the bombers of old. if anything that combination is even more powerful than anything they had.

It would be nice to Max Gawn on the park and firing very soon. Anyone have an update on his current condition and when we are likely to see him?

I just think of Hawthorn's Max Bailey... That helps me put this one into perspective. I'm not at all suggesting that Hawthorn's medicos brought him back too soon, but rather that our medicos feel they have to be extra cautious with a giant young unit post ACL reconstruction.

Also, not that it is a hard and fast rule, but there is a higher proportion of tall gangly types who have general laxity of their ligaments (all over the body, not just in the ACL). Max may be one of those people. The best thing you can do with these "lax" athletes is to allow them time to strengthen the musculature around each joint so as to provide greater overall stability. And even if he is not one of those "lax" athletes, the added strength work around the knee will reduce the likelihood of re-injury.

Another such example would be with LJ's shoulder. There will come a time in his rehab when the repair of the labrum (cartilage rim) of his shoulder joint is strong. His comeback date will therefore hinge on when the medical staff believe that the supporting musculature is sufficient to withstand the rigors of AFL football. Considering LJ is quite slight and appears to be a gumby type with loose ligaments (just judging by the way he can contort himself on the field and kick balls at angles few others can - eg over his head), we might see a similar conservative approach to his return.

[Inner Demon 1]

Does anyone know what's going on with Sam Blease? Haven't seen any info about him running around for the Scorps.

Sam was set to play his first game for Casey Reserves on the weekend but was struck down with a virus so missed out. Hopefully he's feeling better for this weekend.

The good news is his leg is good to go.

[dee-luded 2,959]

elsewhere on 'land, it has been mentioned Gawn has been training at Junction Oval, especially goal kicking and doing drills. if this is so, why is he on the indefinite injury list. Personally, I believe Gawn is one of the most important recruits we have made in the last ten years. One of the reasons Fremantle is on the rise is the presence and dominance of their giant mobile ruckman. Gawn is even more mobile and more skilled, and apparently is a great kick and mark. He could be another Paul Salmon. He and mark jamar and jack watts is a couple of years time cour dominate the competition like the bombers of old. if anything that combination is even more powerful than anything they had.

It would be nice to Max Gawn on the park and firing very soon. Anyone have an update on his current condition and when we are likely to see him?

Well he's on the "indefinite", long term injury list. That means we can elevate a rookie, or Have? elevated a rookie in his place. When he comes back, probably after the usually mandatory 12 months for an 'ACL', then he'll be taken Off the 'LTI' injury list. This doesn't stop him training & building up strength & condition.

[dee-luded 2,959]

Word on Wonaeamirri is that it is not so much a musculoskeletal issue as a biomechanical one. That is to say, he is straining the hamstring in the last lunge of a tackle. This will mean some work with a bio-mechanist to improve technique. Hopefully this doesn't remove tackling intensity from his game, as if I remember rightly he has been a pretty solid tackler.

Oh, this is a great post with welcome news. I was hoping to hear the bio mechanical veiw.

Thanks 'Brettmcg', this is what I thought it may have been.

Their onto it!

[jayceebee31 767]

Does anybody know where Daniel Hughes is? He is not on the injured list and did not play for Casey last week. Seems to have gone missing, again!.

Trained with the rehab group last Friday---my complaint on this website has been that many times our MFC website has not told us what is happening.Fitzpatrick is another.

[jayceebee31 767]

There's no hurry on Gawn. He's a massive, massive kid who is apparently still growing a bit. We need him for the next 10-12 years more than we need him for the next 10-12 weeks. Comebacks from ACLs are always fraught with danger and I'm really glad we're giving him an extended lay-off.

The 12 month rule that we usually see doesn't really apply to Max either. That usually applies to players who have been in the system and have a fitness base prior to the injury. Max missed the 2nd half of last year and the entire pre-season. Once he reaches the end of his 12 month rehab in July he'd then likely enter 'pre-season' mode. If he gets in a few games for Casey Reserves at the end of the year, great, if not, I won't lose a minute's sleep. I'm more interested in him being 100% to commence his first full-preseason next year.

He maybe ready for China in October

[e25 5]

There's no hurry on Gawn. He's a massive, massive kid who is apparently still growing a bit. We need him for the next 10-12 years more than we need him for the next 10-12 weeks. Comebacks from ACLs are always fraught with danger and I'm really glad we're giving him an extended lay-off.

The 12 month rule that we usually see doesn't really apply to Max either. That usually applies to players who have been in the system and have a fitness base prior to the injury. Max missed the 2nd half of last year and the entire pre-season. Once he reaches the end of his 12 month rehab in July he'd then likely enter 'pre-season' mode. If he gets in a few games for Casey Reserves at the end of the year, great, if not, I won't lose a minute's sleep. I'm more interested in him being 100% to commence his first full-preseason next year.

there's also a big difference between running in straight lines and kicking, and changing direction and having strength in the full range of movement of the knee joint.

I found articles about Jared Waites recovery from an ACL fascinating and the cross-training he did up in QLD with a leading expert on rehabbing these injuries.

Apparently he did a lot of trampoline work and other strange things.

[Inner Demon 1]

He maybe ready for China in October

You seem convinced the club is preparing a squad for this post-season exhibition match.

They're not.