Demonland Player of the Year

[Carn dees 108]

6. Sylvia

5. Bruce

4. Moloney

3. Davey

2. Jamar

1. Grimes

*EDIT* DAMN! Missed by 1 Minute! What happened to the 6 hour rule?

Huh? Is there a cut off time for whose votes count?

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

6. Sylvia

5. Moloney

4. Grimes

3. Davey

2. Rivers

1. Jamar

[titan_uranus 25,042]

6:Sylvia

5:Cheney

4:Grimes

3:Frawley

2:Maric

1: Watts (officially the first person on demonland to give Watts a vote)

This is surely a joke, right? Cheney wasn't in our top 6 (but he wasn't terrible either). Maric played shockingly, and really should be dropped. I can't see any justification for giving him votes. And there's no way Watts was in our top 6.

FWIW:

6 - Sylvia

5 - Grimes

4 - Warnock

3 - Jamar

2 - Bate

1 - Davey

[45HG 1,559]

Colin

Grimes for a decent job on Didak.

And the Dees fans who sat through that [censored].

[Doggo 32]

I don't think i could give votes for this game, it would be too hard finding more than just one or two. Thankfully voting is closed so i won't. All i can say is:

Sylvia BOG by a MILLLLLLLLLEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE.. Not one single player showed as much guts and intensity as Sylvia did, for 4 consistent quarters.

Like a couple of others, i agree that Cheney was one of our best, ditto Grimes, despite what their opponents did. The kids definitely showed enough g&d, as well as glimpses of class and poise, to make me excited about their futures. They got taught some very important lessons by some very good players today and will be better for it.

Jamar was pretty good as our rucks dominated the hitouts, yet our mids couldn't get near it. 31 hitouts looks nice on paper, but how many of them actually helped us get the clearance? He's much improved and is moving better than i've ever seen, but Josh Fraser did get a lot of the ball and use it to advatange on most occasions. If i had to give votes i'd give him just 2 or 1.

Struggle to find anyone else vote worthy really. All of Moloney, McLean, Bruce, Jones were servicable but beaten by their direct opponents in the midfield and the latter 2 in particular displayed their glaring disposal issues. None of the forwards deserved a vote really, and the backs were also well beaten. Definitely a tough week to find positives...

[Geddy Lee 582]

6.Sylvia

5. Absolute daylight

4.Jamar

3.Grimes

2.Cheney

1.Jones

Spot on Rhino Richards.

[Bring-Back-Powell 14,938]

I find it funny that Jamar (2 games) is already ahead of P Johnson (11 games).

[discworld demon 0]

Well I didn't see the whole game. I left 5 minutes early so I could both get out of the car park before the rush and (B) avoid the mad scum supporters who attacked Nathan Jones' dad last time.

However I was very impressed by our no. 12 and a couple of others - so:

6 Sylvia

5 Moloney

4 Grimes (the Real future of the MFC)

then I suppose

3 Jamar

2 Davey

1 Warnock

[#MYHEARTBEATSTRUE 27]

6-SLYVIA

6-SLYVIA

6-SLYVIA

6-SLYVIA

6-SLYVIA

6-SLYVIA

Ihate Collingwood.......

[cooko 124]

6 Sylvia

5 Bruce

4 Jones

3 Grimes

2 Mclean

1 Jamar

[deanox 9,987]

...

reckon you could post what the weeks contributions are as well as the leader board, so we can see who got the actual votes each week?

[Deeoldfart 8,061]

6 - Sylvia

5 - Bruce

4 - Jones

The rest? Too hard for me to separate from a maize of disappointing performances.

Just got back from Melbourne, so couldn't post selections earlier.

[H_T 3,049]

reckon you could post what the weeks contributions are as well as the leader board, so we can see who got the actual votes each week?

A comparison: -

Sylvia v Davey

Just did a quick calculation. Prior to D'lands update, by my calculations there were 14 (completed) x 6 votes for Sylvia. 84 votes.

Aaron Davey was voted for 6 times out of those 14 voters. (4,3,1,1,2,2 = 13 votes).

From the Round 10 update:

C.Sylvia went up by 8.571 points

A.Davey went up by 2.381 points