Demonland Player of the Year

[joeboy 2,945]

6 - Jamar

5 - Moloney

4 - Warnock

3 - Rivers

2- Frawley

1- McLean

[Neita3000 37]

6:Jamar

5:Rivers

4:Frawley

3:McLean

2:Warnock

1:Sylvia

[Jaded No More 59,748]

6- Jamar

5- Rivers

4- Grimes

3- McLean

2- Warnock

1- Maric

[montasaurus 0]

Thought Bennell was great improving every game he plays. Ditto Grimes. Shame we have no forward line

[waynewussell 4,220]

6 Jamar

5 Maric

4 Warnock

3 Grimes

2 McLean

1 Whelan

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

6. Rivers

5. Jamar

4. Warnock

3. Frawley

2. Whelan

1. Grimes

[H_T 2,941]

6:Jamar

5:Rivers

4:Grimes

3:McLean

2:Frawley

1:Sylvia

[warren dean 193]

6. Rivers

5. Jamar

4. Warnock

3. Frawley

2. Whelan

1. Grimes

6.Grimes

5. Jamar

4. Rivers

3.Whelan

2.Frawley

1. Maric

[montasaurus 0]

Off the MFC Website, Maybe there's a mid season draft!

Best

Melbourne: Jamar, Rivers, McLean, Bruce, Green, Moloney, Goddard

[Doggo 32]

6. McLean

5. Green

4. Jamar

3. Grimes

2. Frawley

1. Sylvia

Thought McLean was excellent today. His best game for the year IMO.

[Dappa Dan 2,188]

Thought McLean was excellent today. His best game for the year IMO.

AFL website is saying his direct opponent was Hayes, who was a clear BOG. If true, that would lower his colours considerably.

[Pipefitter 2,081]

6: Jamar

5: Rivers

4: Green

3: Warnock

2: Frawley

1: Bennell

Couldnt really award any of the midfielders points. They were good but each were beaten by their respective opponents. The bulk had to goto the defence who held the saints to a fairly low score considering the amount of times it went in the F50.

[Deeoldfart 7,839]

6- Rivers (getting back to his best)

5- Jamar (one of his best games - keep it up 'Rush'.)

4- Grimes (skilfil and composed)

3- McLean (lots of grunt work, and disposal better than recent weeks)

2- Frawley (solid, with some good run)

1- Maric (excellent first half, just ok second half)

[olgreydingo 51]

6: Jamar

5: Rivers

4: McLean

3: Bruce

2: Green

1: Grimes

[titan_uranus 23,129]

I'm assuming that Rivers played on Koschitzke? From the radio I couldn't tell. About the only thing that got Rivers a mention was a couple of poor kicks (which, actually, is something Rivers needs to work on).

[Demonland 66,835]

Not much movement among the leaders and Aaron Davey still has a significant lead:

78.849 Aaron Davey

50.906 Brent Moloney

40.932 Cale Morton

40.844 Brock McLean

33.559 Nathan Jones

23.937 Colin Sylvia

21.989 Brad Green

19.408 Brad Miller

17.835 James Frawley

15.794 Cameron Bruce

14.443 Matthew Warnock

12.825 Jared Rivers

12.420 Paul Johnson

11.805 Ricky Petterd

8.867 Mark Jamar

8.827 Jamie Bennell

8.794 Matthew Bate

8.624 Kyle Cheney

7.296 Stefan Martin

6.300 Addam Maric

6.126 Russell Robertson

5.367 Jack Grimes

4.374 Clint Bartram

3.333 James McDonald

3.077 Neville Jetta

0.667 Lynden Dunn

0.613 John Meesen

[Deeoldfart 7,839]

I'm assuming that Rivers played on Koschitzke? From the radio I couldn't tell. About the only thing that got Rivers a mention was a couple of poor kicks (which, actually, is something Rivers needs to work on).

Yep, was on Kosi for majority of the night. Lots of strong spoils (kept him one goal despite the ball being delivered to Kosi's advantage on many occasions.), a couple of strong marks, and lots of 'trademark' Riv. work, leaving his man, when appropriate, to assist team mates in other contests, etc ie. the sort of stuff that doesn't get a mention in most radio coverage. Agree that kicking has never been Riv's strongest suit.

[titan_uranus 23,129]

Yep, was on Kosi for majority of the night. Lots of strong spoils (kept him one goal despite the ball being delivered to Kosi's advantage on many occasions.), a couple of strong marks, and lots of 'trademark' Riv. work, leaving his man, when appropriate, to assist team mates in other contests, etc ie. the sort of stuff that doesn't get a mention in most radio coverage. Agree that kicking has never been Riv's strongest suit.

Good on him.

[cooko 124]

6. Jamar

5. Rivers

4. McLean

3. Frawley

2. Whelan

1. Moloney

[Carn dees 108]

6-Jamar

5-Rivers

4-Mclean

3-Grimes

2-Green

1-Maric

[Doggo 32]

AFL website is saying his direct opponent was Hayes, who was a clear BOG. If true, that would lower his colours considerably.

Thats the problem with watching games on TV. You can never really tell who's playing on who because the camera angles are too close. Why can't they televise the game in a wider angle, instead of always close up's of the player in possession!

I actually thought Moloney spent the majority on Hayes, with McLean on Ball?

[joeboy 2,945]

Interesting that Jamar was an almost unanimous choice as our best yet failed to be mentioned in the best lists of the 2 Sunday papers .

[H_T 2,941]

Interesting that Jamar was an almost unanimous choice as our best yet failed to be mentioned in the best lists of the 2 Sunday papers .

That was interesting. It also confirms to me that some journalists rely heavily on stats racked up by midfielders, and overlook the likes of not only Jamar's good work, but that of Jared Rivers down back too. Not surprising really. I also thought Frawley was handy too.

[Binmans PA 26,661]

That was interesting. It also confirms to me that some journalists rely heavily on stats racked up by midfielders, and overlook the likes of not only Jamar's good work, but that of Jared Rivers down back too. Not surprising really. I also thought Frawley was handy too.

Yeah, it's more than likely they simply look at the stats and base a lot of their assumptions on them. I've noticed that a few times this year. Anyone who watched the game the other night couldn't have overlooked Jamar. He clearly killed Gardiner and King and took a couple of strong pack marks. That's in the best for me, particularly considering our second half.