What do we do? Im almost sure its that he doesn't care enough. Ive always held high hopes but im belatedly off the band wagon. Recruited as a midfielder, has his best 2 pre-seasons and does nothing in the midfield. Also does nothing up forward. I guess he could have a run as a back pocket. If that fails he can become a full time night club bunny.

In: Maric/Aussie/Grimes/Shannon Motlop

Out: Sylvia

/End thread

keep persisting with him

Named in the best according to afl.com. Interesting.

In: Maric/Aussie/Grimes/Shannon Motlop

Out: Sylvia

/End thread

Hahah BRING BACK MOTLOP!

Named in the best according to afl.com. Interesting.

Maybe afl.com are rewarding the Melbourne players who haven't touched the ball by giving them votes, because by logic, if you don't get a touch you can't stuff up

I wont be pumping up his tyres anymore.

Man, we were unlucky getting two top 5 picks in the worst draft of all time.

I wont be pumping up his tyres anymore.

Man, we were unlucky getting two top 5 picks in the worst draft of all time.

tell me about it. imagine if we got buddy and roughhead with those picks

i think we need to try a few different things with Col... perhaps give him a tagging job for a couple of weeks, let him run with some class midfielders to learn how hard he needs to work to play in the midfield... he won't be able to go all day, but give him some spells there and see if he learns a few things...

the other option is to play him on a half back flank... he looked good at half back, when he played there for a little bit last season... put him there and see how he goes...

I wont be pumping up his tyres anymore.

Man, we were unlucky getting two top 5 picks in the worst draft of all time.

correct weight... it was a shocking draft... lets hope this years draft isn't as bad

Play him till the end of the season and then delist him. If he turns around good for us, if not its not going to affect our season too much. But definitely no more excuses. Put up by years end or good bye.

Of Bailey is going to keep him in, he should be used at Full Forward only.

He's fast become Aaron Fiora Mark II.

I must admit in his first couple years I was a fan - looked strong, could take a mark and find the footy.

But has he improved at all in 4/5 years?

Named in the best according to afl.com. Interesting.

What did they do? Draw names out of a hat or something?

who here would swap Sylvia to have Trav back from Brisbane. Sorry just had a brain fade.

you have got to persist with him.. Will be interesting the next few weeks with players returning at the selection table

you have got to persist with him.. Will be interesting the next few weeks with players returning at the selection table

I think he should be dropped and bring in Maric. Sylvia is offering nothing at the moment. He needs an extended run in the seconds. If he really wants to play senior football he needs to show the club he has the determination.

you have got to persist with him.. Will be interesting the next few weeks with players returning at the selection table

persist with him at casey. nd can someone please tell him that the sun does not shine from his arse. cocky lil ..........

Of Bailey is going to keep him in, he should be used at Full Forward only.

Jack just choked on his Milo and is asking for a trade as we speak <_<

you have got to persist with him.. Will be interesting the next few weeks with players returning at the selection table

Why do we have to persist with him? He is Cupido mark 2. He is lazy, undisciplined and lacks any football smarts aside from a good set of hands. If he does not understand his career is on tenderhooks then he is the dumbest footballer there is. Dump him to Casey I dont care who for and delist him at years end or trade him for whatever you can get.

I wont be pumping up his tyres anymore.

Man, we were unlucky getting two top 5 picks in the worst draft of all time.

It just shows yet again your lack of ability in identifying who is a good footballer and who is not.

I think its best if you dont pump up anyone else ever again unless they have at least put together some sort of consistent effort over at least three weeks of football.

Sylvia's commitment to contests is terrible. He got 14 possessions, five marks but hopefully he can have another go next week.

What did they do? Draw names out of a hat or something?

I'm pretty sure it isn't a hat that they use.

After he got reported he played better, but persist with him. Who do we bring in if he gets weeks? Jurrah? or maybe Robbo (If fit enough).

Sylvia's commitment to contests is terrible. He got 14 possessions, five marks but hopefully he can have another go next week.

Yeah true heals, he just doesn`t work hard enough, although he did get some clean clearances and did lift a bit since he got reported.

Rubbish, yet nothing new, so no surprise here.