6 - Moloney

5- Warnock

4- Petterd

3- Cheney

2- Frawley

1- Jones

Honorable mention to Green

Bartram is Simon Godfrey reincarnated. Did a great job nulifying Harvey's influence, but gee his skills are shocking.

Thought PJ's ruckwork was pretty good today. Held his own and looked far more comfortable than Spencer in the guts. But yes, both his (and Spencer's) efforts in the last qtr to go with McIntosh when he pushed forward were pretty disappointing.

PJ had the job of following McIntosh and didnt. Spencer in his first game is more value that a 200cm rover whose disposal was iffy and is wooden below his knees

My best

6.Moloney

5.Cheney

4.Petterd

3..Warnock

2.Frawley

1.Jones

6 - Moloney

5- Warnock

4- Petterd

3- Cheney

2- Frawley

1- Jones

X 2.

6: Moloney

5: Warnock

4: Petterd

3 : Cheney

2: Frawley

1: Jones

Warnock excellent. Have I mentioned that.

6 Moloney

5 Petterd

4 Jones

3 Cheney

2 Warnock

1 Frawley

I'm a little confused about this scoring ratio system, but here's my votes

6. Moloney

5. Petterd

4. Cheney

3. Warnock

2. Morton

1. Jones

I'm a little confused about this scoring ratio system, but here's my votes

6. Moloney

5. Petterd

4. Cheney

3. Warnock

2. Morton

1. Jones

My votes:

6. McDonald

5. Moloney

4. Petterd

3. Jones

2. Bruce

1. Frawley

My Votes:

6 - Cheney

5 - Moloney

4 - Warnock

3 - McDonald

2 - Petterd

1 - Green

6- Pettard (should have finished with 4 goals, and was good up forward)

5- Moloney (would have been my best player had he not handballed so much)

4- Bartrum (i know his skills weren't great, but his job today was to negate Harvey. And he kept him to 16 touches and no effectiveness)

3- CHeney (played the sweeping role effectively. Only a slight questio on his decision making)

2- McDonald (the general in the guts)

1-Frawley - (plenty of the ball from the backline- gonna get better)

6. Moloney - starting to look like the form he had at the cats 29 touches & 5 tackles

5. Green -gutsy. always put the body on the line. was placed in the forward line in the last qtr, but it didnt come that way too often. 18 touches

4. Cheney - for a first gameer, he had poise, an a good footy brain. he will be a star of the future if he keeps this up. his first opponent was Wells. 22 touches 7 marks 91% effective 3 -1%ers and the only contested mark for the team!

3. Jones - instead of just making packs, he actually got the ball out and made clearances. 23 touches 78% effective

2. Bruce - 22 touches 77% effective. same old Cam.

1. McDonald 23 touches only 65 % effective. had a chance to kick his first "Captains goal" from 30m on and missed.

Honourable mensions the whole back line. there only kids and it was Rivers first game in about 8 months (and Mclean). they will soon be a force to recon with. Now if we onlt had a forwad line that looked the same!

1. McDonald 23 touches only 65 % effective. had a chance to kick his first "Captains goal" from 30m on and missed.

Hardly a basis to get a vote at all. He struggled today and made a number of crucial errors. His stats bear that out.

Well, this is how I saw it:-

6: Petterd

5: Green

4: Cheney

3: Jones

2: Moloney

1: Warnock

And, I thought Frawley, Bruce and Spencer were OK.

Hardly a basis to get a vote at all. He struggled today and made a number of crucial errors. His stats bear that out.

I do agree some what but i realy would have stoped at 5 votes. We had some other good contributers at times and then faded. We scored 1point fron the 22 min mark of the 3rd to the 20 min mark of the last, another quarter fade out like the practice matches. It was mostly skill errors that let us down. Whilst dissapointed in loosing, Nth was a top 4 side for most of last year. we will get better. Just wait till we see Watts as a target in the games and years to come. I was still all in all happy what i saw. Just a thought when was the last round 1 game that didnt have the names of Neitz, White, Yze or Robbo in the line up?

6. Moloney

5. Cheney

4. Jones

3. Green

2. Petterd

1. Frawley

The leader board after Round 1:

11.941 Brent Moloney

8.624 Kyle Cheney

6.634 Ricky Petterd

5.970 Nathan Jones

1.990 James Frawley Neville Jetta

1.327 Clint Bartram Brad Green Matthew Warnock

0.663 Paul Johnson

6. Moloney

5. Jones

4. Warnock

3. Cheney

2. Bartram

1. Petterd

6. Moloney

5. Petterd

4. Cheney

3. Warnock

2. Jones

1. Bartram

The leader board after Round 1:

11.941 Brent Moloney

8.624 Kyle Cheney

6.634 Ricky Petterd

5.970 Nathan Jones

1.990 James Frawley Neville Jetta

1.327 Clint Bartram Brad Green Matthew Warnock

0.663 Paul Johnson

I understand that taking 3 random sets of votes is fair, but it's a pity that one of those 3 sets of votes happened to be the only one that had Johnson, who really doesn't deserve anything for his work yesterday.

X 2.

6: Moloney

5: Warnock

4: Petterd

3 : Cheney

2: Frawley

1: Jones

Warnock excellent. Have I mentioned that.

X 3!

6: Moloney

5: Warnock

4: Petterd

3 : Cheney

2: Frawley

1: Jones

6. Jetta - Great Debut.

5. Jones - Much imporved decision making.

4. Warnock - Solid all day.

3. Cheney - Another star defender, great dubut.

2. Moloney - Worked his azz off, tough at thee ball.

1. Petterd - Love him forward, presented well, spewing he didn't kick more.

Votes were taken completely at random.

There is a limit however on the number of times a poster's votes will be accepted.