haha not sure CAC has learnt anything.

Looks like it was Warnock's decision, not Richmond's

To the contrary, it was Richmond's decision not "to come to the party with a 4th year on their offer".

I would suggest that this should also be Melbourne's decision.

It's lunacy to pay that sort of coin for a player like Warnock.

End of story.

david armitage for pick 19 is what i've heard if the club dont use 19 on warnock or any other trade

I seriously doubt St Kilda would trade Armitage.

The guy has talent and was picked for the finals, so Armitage can't blame lack of opportunity.

I would however take the trade in a heartbeat.

reliable source: and you can bet your bottom dollar if we get another top 20 pick or another there abouts pick, and don't use 19 on warnock- the deal will happen. It's been arranged.

reliable source: and you can bet your bottom dollar if we get another top 20 pick or another there abouts pick, and don't use 19 on warnock- the deal will happen. It's been arranged.

Love those "reliable sources".

i know, don't we all.

reliable source: and you can bet your bottom dollar if we get another top 20 pick or another there abouts pick, and don't use 19 on warnock- the deal will happen. It's been arranged.

Love those "reliable sources".

I also love those "if's", "buts" and "maybe's".....

heightens the aniticipation doesn't it

It's official. Warnock is going to Richmond for their 3rd choice on a reported $550K pa on a 4 year deal. Just joking.

According to a report in the paper this morning Warnock will go to Carlton for pick 24, he will get paid $1.5m over 4 years. He apparently said the opportunity to play beside Judd influenced his decision.

Mind you Freo want pick 6 so it's not a done deal yet, but Melbourne have seemingly pulled out of the race because of the size of the contract he is seeking.

Im over this hack now anyway. Stef Martin could even be a proposition judging by his efforts yesterday and i know he has played in the ruck.

According to a report in the paper this morning Warnock will go to Carlton for pick 24, he will get paid $1.5m over 4 years. He apparently said the opportunity to play beside Judd influenced his decision.

Mind you Freo want pick 6 so it's not a done deal yet, but Melbourne have seemingly pulled out of the race because of the size of the contract he is seeking.

Im over this hack now anyway. Stef Martin could even be a proposition judging by his efforts yesterday and i know he has played in the ruck.

Which paper?

Which paper?

Was mentioned in the West Australian and the South Australian Advertiser.

It should be noted that the author of that article has a history of being anti-fremantle.

For what it's worth (and I don't care if you beleive me or not) - I spoke with a player in Carlton's Leadership Group on Grand Final day, who told me that (amongst other things) Warnock to Carlton is a done deal, including an agreement with Fremantle.

Was mentioned in the West Australian and the South Australian Advertiser.

It should be noted that the author of that article has a history of being anti-fremantle.

For what it's worth (and I don't care if you beleive me or not) - I spoke with a player in Carlton's Leadership Group on Grand Final day, who told me that (amongst other things) Warnock to Carlton is a done deal, including an agreement with Fremantle.

Of course its a done deal and of course a member of Carlton's leadership group is going to just tell some random about the deal.

exactly thats just bullS***

if we don't get warnock

what are we going to do? we need a ruckman. Jamr is crap, and PJ is better as the no 2. cos he can play forward and back

spencer is a while off but looking good, and meesen is a dud

exactly thats just bullS***

if we don't get warnock

what are we going to do? we need a ruckman. Jamr is crap, and PJ is better as the no 2. cos he can play forward and back

spencer is a while off but looking good, and meesen is a dud

$1.5 mill over 4 years - leave him to Carlton

no no- as in, we need a ruckman! simon taylor could be good with PJ

Of course its a done deal and of course a member of Carlton's leadership group is going to just tell some random about the deal.

Comprehension not one of your strong points?

See the bolded section below:

Was mentioned in the West Australian and the South Australian Advertiser.

It should be noted that the author of that article has a history of being anti-fremantle.

For what it's worth (and I don't care if you beleive me or not) - I spoke with a player in Carlton's Leadership Group on Grand Final day, who told me that (amongst other things) Warnock to Carlton is a done deal, including an agreement with Fremantle.

Comprehension not one of your strong points?

See the bolded section below:

I don't think its a matter of believing you mate... for me its more a matter of believing the player.

Word of mouth is a powerful tool. Could be just saying it to get the word out and give Warnock a little shove, if he's only leaning their way.

Could be any number of reasons they'd say it - because its true is only one of them.

Comprehension not one of your strong points?

See the bolded section below:

Oh... it's a strong point.... I saw your comment and I'm glad you don't care that people know you're a complete and utter liar..... I comprehend that just fine, Champ.

Im over this hack now anyway. Stef Martin could even be a proposition judging by his efforts yesterday and i know he has played in the ruck.

Understand your point of view, but sprinting 100m - you can't judge him alone on this effort for a ruck proposition Mousey. But geez the run was impressive for a big man.

exactly thats just bullS***

if we don't get warnock

what are we going to do? we need a ruckman. Jamr is crap, and PJ is better as the no 2. cos he can play forward and back

spencer is a while off but looking good, and meesen is a dud

Patience and a strong resolve is needed by our recruiters. If we start paying players above thier worth now it will come back to bite us when we have a crack at a flag.

Warnock would be nice but not at any cost. The down side and precedent it sets is a big risk.

Spencer is a while off, Meesen doesn't look like it but could make. Rookie list another ruckman maybe, some very good ruckmen have been developed this way. We wont need a ruckman to play finals next year. Spencer or someone else may thrust thier name forward by 2010.

400,000 a year, you have to be joking!!

Well done MFC to push his price this high (if true). Sell your VISY shares, they will struggle to turn a profit with these guys on the books.

hahaahahaha 400K a year for an anorexic beanpole who has done nothing at AFL level.

Cant wait til we play Carltank and PJ gives his bony arse the run around.

Report in Sunday herald sun that we are out of the race for him as we cant fit him into our salary cap, if this is true then we are doing something very wrong worst performed side for the year we pay the highest compared to any other club.

W.T. F is going on

Report in Sunday herald sun that we are out of the race for him as we cant fit him into our salary cap, if this is true then we are doing something very wrong worst performed side for the year we pay the highest compared to any other club.

W.T. F is going on

The Hun report didn't mention the salary cap. We're out of the race because Warnock's $ claims are over the top.

seriusly wtf is all this hype about warnock hes will be a good player but all this talk seems hes goin to be a champ

he aint worth wat hel get from carlton money wise