Everything posted by spirit of norm smith
-
CASEY: Rd 02 vs Gold Coast
@Redleg yes re Blake Howes โฆ I meant back to Casey next week and adopt the taller HFF role
-
Xavier Lindsay Update?
@DeeZone Was posting earlier Just got the news โฆ relief. XL20 ๐๐ป Probably miss a few weeks though and look to bandage /strengthen the knee
-
Xavier Lindsay Update?
Xavier Lindsay will be a star. Showed it in his first two games already. Fingers crossed on his knee scans! As many know, I posted numerous times last year that he was the player that the Dees needed. Has footy IQ, good pace and ballwinning, with elite skills. Imv Worth trading out our 2025 pick. What was strange was the add-ons in the trade. I think gave up too much Bombers - pick 9 plus 2025 third-round pick to Melbourne. Dees -2024 picks 28, 40, 46, 54 & 65 PLUS first-round pick in 2025.
-
Time to start a rebuild?
Interesting now that JVR seems to have gone backwards. Not sure how our development goes. 2022 he looked good as a 19 year old at Casey. 2023 debut v Swans (just turned 20) was very good with 3 goals and big strong marks But in 2024 and start of 2025, he couldnโt catch a cold (his inability to mark or hold the footy is really poor) โฆ is he wearing oven mitts was one posters comments. He looks hesitant to lead up. When he does, he often has to wait whilst the midfield overuses or kicks it โon his headโ and itโs impossible to compete. I think JVR is part of our future. But he needs to move more and actually fuc@$&)n one grab the footy. A more accurate delivery from the mids might also help.
-
CASEY: Rd 02 vs Gold Coast
Howes played really good footy for Sandy Dragons AND Casey as a wing/half forward. Heโs a capable goalkicker. Iโd like to see him put back to Casey next year and adopt that role. Try to slot him back into MFC as a taller half forward. The role as a last line defender is not his go in my view.
-
POSTGAME: Rd 03 vs Gold Coast
Fritsch is the obvious one to go !!! He cost us with missed tackles, missed shots and missed goals. Turn the opportunities in 3-4 goals and we were within a 2 goal reach at 3/4 time. Unfortunately once it blew out, the umps and suns turned up the heat.
-
POSTGAME: Rd 03 vs Gold Coast
Nailed it. This is perfect for any of the AFL talk fest shows to dissect. Itโs clear to the fans. Unfortunately doesnโt seem clear to Simon and co. Slow and steady and then turnover footy is a horror show. We can improve with better ball use and run, but the complete loss of winning contested footy and clearance work (our previous number 1 strength) is a huge concern. Being outworked, outrun and outbodied.
-
Time to start a rebuild?
Thanks. Spargo needs to do a lot more. A lot more. He wasnโt impressive at all in 2022 and 2023 and as we know was out injured in 2024. Seems to be our players have average performances and still get new deals and extensions. Accepting mediocrity is our weakness.
-
Time to start a rebuild?
Melksham. Tmac. Billings. All will retire. Doubts over so many โฆ Laurie, Woey jnr, Sestan, Kentfield, Adams, Hore, McAdam, Spargo. Thatโs 11 to go. Some might question or think thatโs harsh. I think itโs needed. Thereโs young players needed and the talent is available.
-
VOTES: Rd 03 vs Gold Coast
Suns destroyed us. Embarrassing skill errors. Easy soft 15 metres passes then turnovers. Dees very poor in the midfield especially. At the clearance and in contested footy. Trac and Clarry and JV7 looked 2nd rate. Rowell and Anderson just ran away from them. Votes ? 6- Bowey 5- Langford 4- Langdon 3- Sharp โฆ thatโs enough
-
POSTGAME: Rd 03 vs Gold Coast
The Game in reflection 1st qtr ๐คฎHenderson turnover inside 50 ๐คฎOliver turnover inside 50 ๐Lindsay knee injury - subbed off ๐๐ปSharp to Chandler (miss) ๐คฎUmp free and fifty50 (Oliver brain fade to kick the ball away) ๐คฎPetracca 30 metre out -miss - kicking for goal (looked devoid of wanting to kick the goal , very unsure) ๐คฎFritsch - turnover ๐คขLangford miss on the run ๐๐๐Langford to Bowey โฆ goal ๐คฎ๐คฎ๐คฎrivers poor lazy handball - asleep Noble runs and goal ๐คฎTrac kick to inside 50 but straight to a suns 2v1 ๐คฎMay error dropped mark Suns 4.5.29 Dees 1.4.10 2nd qtr ๐คฎLangdon poor kick into fwd50. Turnover ๐๐๐Langford to Melksham โ ๏ธumps. Johnson two tackles - players had prior opportunity - not rewarded ๐คฎFritsch miss from 25 metre out ๐คฎOliver fumbles and fumbles ๐คฎFritsch miss from 40 metre out โ ๏ธumps 1/2 time Dees 2.9.21 to Suns 5.8.38 3rd ๐lucky. Sharp goal ๐คขumps Billings grabbed without the footy โฆ miller goal ๐คขmay 20m away from king ๐๐Melksham to Trac - left foot goal ๐๐Sharp goal โญ๏ธโญ๏ธโญ๏ธโญ๏ธRowell โญ๏ธโญ๏ธโญ๏ธโญ๏ธ ๐๐Chandler goal ๐คฎ๐คฎViney disposal - killing us dees 29 points down ๐คฎ๐คฎ๐คฎ๐คฎ๐คฎFritsch drop mark 15 metre out !!! Unmanned โฆ drops the mark then fumbles and falls over ๐คฎ๐คฎ๐คฎ๐คฎ๐คฎ๐คฎumps - suns goal in last 0.0000171 seconds of third quarter Dees 6.12.48 to Suns 12.10.82 4th ๐คฎ๐คฎ๐คฎ๐คฎSkill errors Langdon. Viney. Oliver. Seriously poor ๐คฎFritsch miss shot ๐คฎOliver disposal poor again ๐คฎTrac disposal - lazy ๐๐Langford - goal on the run ๐คกSalem disposal - so poor ๐คฎjohnson dropped mark - 25 metres out !! ๐๐JVR mark and goal โ ๏ธโ ๏ธโ ๏ธUmps - free kick to King against May ๐คฎ๐คฎ๐คฎ๐คฎ๐คฎ๐คฎsmashed at centre clearances and at the contest Could not match the Suns midfield Dees 8.14.62 to Suns 18.12.120
-
CASEY: Rd 02 vs Gold Coast
Turner and Bonner would be handy inclusions. So imv only Turner (as Bonner is not AFL listed). Not sure why he wasnโt considered to recruit as heโs only just turned 28yo but has excellent left foot disposal. Disposal is much better than most of our AFL listed squad.
-
PREGAME: Rd 04 vs Geelong
Lever May Salem Rivers Petty Bowey Windsor. Viney. Langdon Sharp. Turner. Petracca Fritsch. JVR. Pickett Gawn. Oliver. Langdon Tmac. Sparrow Chandler Johnson Sub. Melksham
-
PREGAME: Rd 04 vs Geelong
In. Lever. Windsor. Pickett. Turner Unavailable. Throlstrup. McVee. Outs. Billings. Henderson. Howes. Lindsay (knee)
-
GAMEDAY: Rd 03 vs Gold Coast
๐คฎ๐คฎ๐คฎ๐คฎSkill errors Langdon. Viney. Oliver. Seriously poor ๐คฎFritsch miss ๐คฎOliver disposal ๐คฎTrac disposal ๐คกSalem disposal ๐คฎjohnson dropped mark
-
GAMEDAY: Rd 03 vs Gold Coast
Ever !! Worst ever !!! Missed shots. Missed tackles. Dropped marks. Worst ever !!! Basic footy errors.
-
GAMEDAY: Rd 03 vs Gold Coast
๐lucky. Sharp goal ๐คขumps Billings grabbed without footy ๐คขmay 20m away from king ๐๐Melksham to Trac ๐๐Sharp โญ๏ธโญ๏ธโญ๏ธโญ๏ธRowell โญ๏ธโญ๏ธโญ๏ธโญ๏ธ ๐๐Chandler goal ๐คฎ๐คฎViney disposal ๐คฎ๐คฎ๐คฎ๐คฎ๐คฎFritsch drop mark 15 metre out !!! Unmanned then fumbles and falls over ๐คฎ๐คฎ๐คฎ๐คฎ๐คฎ๐คฎumps suns goal
-
GAMEDAY: Rd 03 vs Gold Coast
WATCHING MELBOURNE FOOTY CLUB IS A HEALTH HAZARD
-
GAMEDAY: Rd 03 vs Gold Coast
2nd qtr ๐คฎLangdon kick into z50. Turnover ๐๐๐Langdon to Melksham โ ๏ธumps. Johnson two tackles not rewarded ๐คฎFritsch miss from 25 metre out ๐คฎOliver fumbles and fumbles ๐คฎFritsch miss from 40 metre out โ ๏ธumps
-
GAMEDAY: Rd 03 vs Gold Coast
Yes do your blood pressure a favour โฆ errors and turnovers killing us
-
GAMEDAY: Rd 03 vs Gold Coast
1st qtr ๐คฎHenderson turnover ๐คฎOliver turnover ๐Lindsay knee injury - subbed off ๐๐ปSharp to Chandler ๐คฎUmp free and fifty50 (Oliver brain fade) ๐คฎPetracca 30 metre out -miss - kicking for goal (looked unsure) ๐คฎFritsch - turnover ๐คฎLangford miss ๐๐๐Langford to Bowey ๐คฎ๐คฎ๐คฎrivers poor handball - asleep Noble goal ๐คฎTrac kick suns 2v1 ๐คฎMay error dropped mark Suns 4.5.29 Dees 1.4.10
-
GAMEDAY: Rd 03 vs Gold Coast
Whoโs missing? (From best 22) Pickett. Lever. Windsor McVee Throlstrup
-
Melbourne Football Club - The CEO
Surely thereโs an experienced sports administrator available and willing to take the job. Bizarre that itโs vacant to be honest.
-
2025 MFC Injury List
Starting to feel the dreaded Dees injury curse again Injury & Suspension List: Round 3 [player, injury or suspension, estimated return] Jake Lever โ ankle / fitness test Steven May โ larynx / test Jake Melksham โ hamstring / test / likely Casey Kysaiah Pickett โ suspended / 1 week Matt Jefferson โ hand / 1 - 2 weeks Caleb Windsor โ infection in his foot / 1 - 2 weeks Koltyn Tholstrup โ back / 2 - 3 weeks Judd McVee โ hamstring / 2 - 3 weeks Jai Culley โ foot / 2 - 3 weeks Marty Hore โ calf / likely 2-3 weeks Luker Kentfield โ illness / 3 - 4 weeks Shane McAdam โ Achilles / next season Andy Moniz-Wakefield โ knee / next season โโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโ- ps Darren Burgess - fitness coach at the Crows. Their injury list is two players probably ranked in the last few on their list
-
Goody on Unfiltered
MFC COACHING STYLE