Jump to content

What

Members
  • Posts

    12,999
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    32

Everything posted by What

  1. Ill never understand how someone can run for that long in that period of time without dying. Well done Jess.
  2. They certainly were handing them out, and the MFC outfoxed all comers. Georgiou RR Martin great thread btw, you called it
  3. Still cant believe Dawes is on the banner
  4. Wiedemannn does seem like this years slider. Something not quite right about him. Mathiseon butchers the ball by foot, no thanks. Milera does look the goods, would like to get him at 7.
  5. Hes never played in a final. Dont forget he comes from Essendope, not a proper AFL team.
  6. Best 22 is a flawed exercise. They will help add depth to the list and thats what matters.
  7. Any side with Dawes in it cant be taken seriously
  8. What happens if Carlton bid on Callum Mills with pick 1? Would Sydney even have enough points from this draft or would they have to use picks from next year as well? I find the idea that Carlton possibly have the power to set Sydney back so far both hilarious and awesome
  9. Agreed on Gawn. Hes already in the top handful of ruckmen in the AFL on ability, now he needs to stay on the park and he will certainly be an A grader.
  10. Nows as good a time as any to do a best 22 .. pick 3 or 7 likely wontl be a walk up start for Round 1 like Brayshaw was, and Petracca would have been Without further ado B: N.Jetta L.Dunn C.Garland HB: H.Lumumba T.McDonald J.Melksham C: C.Salem D.Tyson B.Vince HF: C.Petracca S.Frost A.Brayshaw F: J.Garlett J.Hogan D.Kent R: M.Gawn J.Viney N.Jones I/C: T.Bugg A.Vandenberg B.Kennedy J.Harmes Emergencies - C.Pedersen J.Watts B.Newton Cant justify naming Trengove just yet as his foot is still a big question mark. Bugg was an easy choice to fill the role as designated shut down player, which will give Viney and VInce more freedom to play attacking footy. Frost to resume the role he started in 2015 before his injury, a floating key forward that can back up ruck and with the ability to play down back. Backing Lumumba in to bounce back, cant see him not being a regular. His presence with Melksham on the other back flank will release Salem to more of a midfield role.
  11. Good summary WJ So we have 5 spots left on the senior list... two of those will go to Vanders and Harmes as rookie upgrades Leaving three spots..... and we have 4 draft picks worth using (3, 7, 46, 50) Terlich will surely be delisted and paid out to make way for the use of that fourth draft pick
  12. Feels like we have stashed him , and no doubt for good reason Hes 193cm and has elite speed. Other than that I know nothing about him and nobody has ever seen him play footy but im gonna bump us up to an A+ now just cos I can go dees
  13. well done to poster armstrong35 who called this a few days ago And well done to the MFC for some left field thinking! I may be wrong but I thnink Shaun was 187 cms in his playing days. Joel looks a good size
  14. It appears as though he doesn't understand the points system and is asking someone to explain it to him Just guessing though
  15. We are definitely taking a KPF with one of the picks, nothing is surer
  16. I recall either he or that Barrett [censored] calling our outlook bleak just a few days ago Guess it was Barret, which of course is a big surprise
  17. Im changing to an A I said B originally as I was worried about trading out the 2016 first rounder. Truth is that should not matter, all it means is we are bringing our first rounder from next year a year ahead, and we are a good chance to outplay the break even value of that 2016 pick, making the trade a big win Of course that all matters on who is picked and how they develop so we wont know for years, but for now its an A And if you factor in the cultural change, bringing in competitors and backing ourselves in to rise up the ladder its an A++++
  18. No we should keep the picks, and bid on Mills at 3.. effectively wiping them out of the draft with all the points theyd have to stump up Its time for the underdog to get nasty
  19. He also said the Howe and Kennedy deals will be seperate He then weaved some sort of magic to get us 3 and 7 Looking forward to us being the proud owners of pick 1 and 2 by 2 pm tomorrow
  20. Depends on many factors, I give it a B+... only reason its not an A is we had to move out our 2016 first rounder in what will likely be a relatively high pick (though I hope not) in whats meant to be a stronger draft than this one But if you factor in that we did these deals with a view to moving faster up the ladder and challenging ourselves to strive for success and making next years first round pick somewhere in the teens, then its an A+
  21. No chance he falls past Essendon, and I wouldn't be surprised if we took him at pick 3
  22. Ideal scenario 3 - Melbourne - Parish 4 - Essendrug - Francis 5 - Essendrug - Weideman 6 - Gold Coast - Balic or Milera 7 - Melbourne - Curnow
×
×
  • Create New...