What

LOL I quoted the wrong post..but yes I do agree with your analysis Skuit Go Dees

I think thats the second time all three have made the Team of the Week already this season.. Gawn two weeks in a row

Caro more than anyone put the blowtorch on Hird and Essendon and continues to do so, and for that I thank her.

Checking out the highlights on the MFC website and ANB, who is in superb form, is looking very strong in the body. He deserves a call up maybe more so than anyone, the kid will be a player and a half no doubt about it.

Amazing how much more an effective player Heritier is when he lowers his eyes and hits targets instead of blazing away. Suddenly he goes from the most frustrating player in the team to a gun.

in Matt Burgans latest article he did a best 22 of players who didnt play vs the Pies B: Terlich, Garland, Grimes HB: Neal-Bullen, O.McDonald, Melksham* C: Trengove, Petracca, Stretch HF: VandenBerg, Dawes, Newton F: Kennedy-Harris, Weideman, Garlett FOLL: Spencer, Vince, Michie I/C: White, Max King, Mitch King, Hulett, Smith I would comfortably back that team in against the 2012-2014 MFC teams

The same guy who held him goalless last season when we trounced them - Tom McDonald

Doubt he plays for a while but the important thing hes an 18 year old key forward playing very nice footy in the VFL.. looks like another home run for Jason Taylor and co.

Sir Wagner scored votes in The Age COLLINGWOOD v MELBOURNE(Peter Hanlon)Jack Viney (Melbourne) 8Nathan Jones (Melbourne) 8Dom Tyson (Melbourne) 8Josh Wagner (Melbourne) 7Jack Watts (Melbourne) 7

Supercoach and other games like it are the worst possible guide for judging players. They are worthless.

He is too harshly judged by posters on here

"Stop playing so well Benny, I am trying to get my AFL debut god damn it"

I wonder if Jake Melksham would be in the team at the moment if available. I suspect he wouldd have locked in a spot off half back and be doing well for us. Will be another nice 'recruit' for next season.

Agree to dsagree Nut, I think hes terrible. Takes a screamer once every couple of weeks and does nothing else. Hes like a headless chook up forward and he is useless as a midfielder. Hes decent as an intercept defender but in the current climate its important to have creativity, good disposal and dash in that role - he nas none of those attributes and he cant hurt teams once he does get possession on half back. As I said, very glad he is gone. He was part of the problem and he will fade to nothing at the Pies..

;lol classic ET

We are playing all these kids and have a bunch players on limited game time and we still smashed the Pie scum Go dees

Frosts role yesterday - run rings around the Filth and bring joy to the MFC faithful Go Dees

Theres no role for Dawes anyway as he cant ruck Pedersen and Frost are comfortably ahead of him as both can play either end of the ground and can ruck

Heritier in the votes two weeks in a row, nice to see him settling in after a down season

The replay confirms all four were excellent. Thats easily Frosts career best game

The solid efforts were few and far between... in fact they were rare as hens teeth He should have been dropped many times but our list was so unbelievably poor and shallow that he was gifted games He is a terrible fooitballer and hes now the Magpies problem and on big coin,. Love it.

Although it appears Gus has a slight concussion.. so a chance to sit out vs Tigers

Watched the 4th quarter replay, and I automatically regretted suggesting Oliver be dropped He was manic and full of energy in the final term and so creative, same with Angus. Both will play vs Richmond.

Hogan, Weed, Watts, Petracca Schwarz, Neitz, Lyon, Jakovich Go Dees