Diamond_Jim

They lost 5 for 50 from when Root went out but the current pair have put on 45runs for the ninth wicket. Overall a decent performance by Australia with many English players getting good starts. Australia will need to wrap up this partnership before it does damage. I still don't think it was a smart move putting them in.

two quick wickets after tea. Game on All out for around 250 would justify sending them in

There's not much doubt that Langer runs this team. If they had taken the Root chances it may have been different but 300 plus is looking inevitable

Why pick Siddle and Marsh and send a team in England heading for a big score

A simple stat that so many don't get. This club is seriously underperforming the mean.

Here's the 2017 invite Questions had to be pre submitted by the looks of things: "You can also submit a question or topic you'd like discussed on the night. The club will endeavour to address all relevant questions." https://www.collingwoodfc.com.au/news/2017-10-10/member-forum-key-information

Would like to see a win this Test. Warner to score along with another batsman so Smith can enjoy himself. The inclusion of Marsh is underwhelming and I just don't buy the resting of the bowlers excuse given the rotation policy. An England win would be slightly deflating. Looking like five days of relative sunshine around 22 degrees max. And why do the English like dressing up in silly clothes?

Good point Dr G I would prefer to see an interview of Goodwin by a well prepared journalist addressing the key issues. This could end up as amateur hour. A supporters forum would be much better if it looked at the various value propositions for different classes of supporters.

Would want the opinion of the Richmond doctor before signing him and four years at $600k is a BIG risk. Garlett would have been on around $400k (guess) so it's a big step up.

AFL are ruing the day that they were forced to sign up to WADA. In the NFL the suspension for a first time abuser of a performance enhancing drug is four games !!

wonder if his mum had a hammer handy? https://www.scmp.com/week-asia/politics/article/3023316/chinese-missiles-likely-cripple-asia-based-us-forces-event Among the astonishing points of the FINA doping panel’s report seen by The Sunday Telegraph were witness claims that “Sun’s mother asked a guard to bring a hammer into the doping control room”.

With the nature of the charge it is hard to imagine that it was an unintended or unknown ingesting of the substance. Time will tell. Shades of a well known Chinese swimmer

Suspended indefinitely https://www.afl.com.au/news/2019-09-12/willie-riolis-drug-test-shock-eagle-suspended-indefinitely

The AFL will speak at 4:30pm EST with @tommorris32 reporting Willie Rioli has tested positive for an illegal substance. Watch here. From fox footy twitter feed

perhaps straight swap for Weideman ... where do we sign?

That's the problem. We'll get offered their second round at best which will be pick 30 or an NQR player. I think this is about money and opportunity for Frost.

good point but a thinking coaching team would have designated one player from each group.. back, mids, forward etc to be responsible for on field enforcement of the gameplan. Doesn't need to be the captains but more the players who have some tactical sense. You also have to remember that with four players on the bench rotating constantly that messages aren't too hard to get out. Smacks of yet another lame excuse to me.

Their membership would revolt.... Another matter if Goodwin was successful but he is a long way from having runs on the board. Scott of the North variety is my bet.

Bit like question time in Parliament. There will be some wonderful Dorothy Dixers and then the cutting questions from the opposition will be turned sideways. Better than nothing though. Football department aside I would like to see the 5/10/20 year plan/vision for the Club. We have some big issues such as MCC relationship as the old Demons die off and of course the arms race with the powerful clubs on so many levels.

Australia did what they had to but it was a little lacklustre. Understandable in 40 degree heat, Thinking about heading over to Taiwan for the match in October. Hard to get excited over Qatar 2022

simple.... if he stays out of contract and is not traded he goes into the PSD where any club (in order of bottom to top) can elect to take him at his stated price. If that happens we get nothing but Frost is not guaranteed to get to his desired club. The alternative is that whoever wants him trades for him

interesting comment.. no idea which is better but I suspect salary cap and term of contract wise you may not be too far off the mark. After paying overs salary wise for Tom Mac and Brayshaw last year we're not as flush as some may think. Then again no club is. Hawks , Geelong and Richmond have an inbuilt benefit because they are seen as real premiership chances and players will take say 10% less to be there.I expect the same goes for WA born players playing for WC.

But but it's a long way to get a good latte

If it's money and length of contract one would expect North to have more of both

Four years on good dollars is a long time if we get it wrong